Subverting the religious freedom of a Jewish school – WORLD News Group
Posted By admin on July 2, 2022
Earlier this month, a New York court judge ruled that Yeshiva University must extend official recognition to a campus LGBT club even though the club contradicts Yeshivas understanding of the Jewish faith. According to the court, Yeshiva is not sufficiently religious to qualify for an exemption under New York Citys public accommodation law. This ruling strips religious liberty protections from every organization unless a court determines religion to be an organizations primary purpose, posing an existential threat to nearly every religious school, hospital, and non-profit in New York City.
Plaintiffs in the casemostly former studentsargued that Yeshiva must officially recognize an LGBT club on campus, even though their club contradicts the universitys core religious beliefs. They claim that New York Citys public accommodation law applies to Yeshiva and that the schools refusal to sponsor clubs that contradict its religious beliefs amounts to discrimination based on sexual orientation.
Yeshiva officials pointed out that the public accommodation law expressly exempts religious organizations. It applies only to places of public accommodation and expressly excludes a religious corporation incorporated under the education law from the definition of such an accommodation.
Yeshiva is a religious educational institution that should easily qualify for the exemption. Indeed, the New York judge admitted that at first blush that conclusion seems obvious. Yeshiva has a proud Jewish heritage and a mission to combine the spirit of the Torah with an excellent education. Judge Lynn R. Kotler was even willing to assume that Yeshiva had a religious function (a fact hard to deny) and noted that its religious character defines it and sets it apart from other schools and universities of higher education.
Yet Judge Kotler evaded the straightforward conclusion that Yeshiva is a religious educational institution by looking to the schools stated primary purpose. The record shows that the purpose students attend Yeshiva is to obtain an education, not for religious worship or some other function which is religious at its core, Kotler wrote. Because Yeshiva operated primarily for educational purposes, it could not be a religious corporation. The courts standard would make it exceedingly difficult for an educational institution to be eligible for religious liberty protections (despite the clear legislative directive to afford religious educational corporations an exemption). To qualify, Yeshiva must be akin to a house of worship and have been formed primarily for a religious purpose.
The courts opinion overlooks that many religious institutions also have other purposes. Many parents choose religious education so their children can be taught consistent with their faith traditions. Just last week, in Carson v. Makin, the U.S. Supreme Court explained, Educating young people in their faith, inculcating its teachings, and training them to live their faith are responsibilities that lie at the very core of the mission of a private religious school.
Judge Kotlers reasoning is horrifyingly broad. If the court is correct, then there is no such thing as a religious hospital, a religious homeless shelter, a religious soup kitchen, a religious crisis pregnancy care center, or a religious school. Such a result is inconsistent with New York Citys law and with common sense. As Yeshiva leaders put it, the ruling that Yeshiva is not religious is obviously wrong.
The New York court also erred by failing to find Yeshiva protected by the First Amendment. Yeshiva argued that the free exercise clause prevented New York City from requiring it to sanction an LGBT club in violation of its religious beliefs. Judge Kotler disagreed, finding that New York City could apply its public accommodations law notwithstanding the First Amendment because the citys law was, in legal terms, neutral and generally applicable.
Recent U.S. Supreme Court precedent forecloses that argument. In Fulton v. City of Philadelphia, the high court held that Philadelphias refusal to contract with Catholic Social Services unless it agreed to certify same-sex couples as foster parents violated the free exercise clause. The court explained that strict scrutiny applies whenever a law prohibits religious conduct while permitting similar secular conduct. New York Citys public accommodations law, however, excludes private clubs with up to 400 members. This exception means that the law is subject to the most rigorous scrutiny. The plaintiffs must (but cannot) show that applying New York Citys public accommodation law to Yeshiva University promotes a compelling governmental interest and is narrowly tailored.
Yeshiva University vowed to immediately appeal the decision that it is not sufficiently religious. That is an argument it should easily win.
View post:
Subverting the religious freedom of a Jewish school - WORLD News Group
- How we are giving Jewish Heritage Month the attention it deserves - Religion News Service - June 4th, 2023
- Senate Unanimously Passes Rosen-led Resolution Recognizing Jewish ... - May 24th, 2023
- Biden to mark Jewish American Heritage Month with Broadway stars, speak ... - May 17th, 2023
- Biden to mark Jewish American Heritage Month at White House with Broadway stars - The Times of Israel - May 17th, 2023
- Biden speaks out against 'antisemitic bile' during Jewish American Heritage Month celebration - The Associated Press - May 17th, 2023
- Every Republican Governor Honors Jewish Heritage Month in Joint ... - May 3rd, 2023
- A Proclamation on Jewish American Heritage Month, 2023 - May 3rd, 2023
- 5 Ways to Celebrate Jewish American Heritage Month | AJC - April 30th, 2023
- Some GOP leaders say Republican Santos 'lied' about career and Jewish ... - December 29th, 2022
- Heritage Florida Jewish News Homepage - November 10th, 2022
- History of the Jews in Iraq - Wikipedia - October 25th, 2022
- Nuremberg Laws - Wikipedia - October 25th, 2022
- 8 Powerful Ways to Celebrate National Hispanic Heritage Month - October 17th, 2022
- A Jewish comedian didnt mention Israel in his act. He was still heckled with Free Palestine - Forward - October 17th, 2022
- Russia-Ukraine war, as it happened: nearly 9,000 Russian troops to be stationed in Belarus; Putins forces continuing forced deportations - The... - October 17th, 2022
- UWS Synagogue Refuses to Rent Space to Republican Club for Speech by Election Denier - THE CITY - September 21st, 2022
- Glossary Of Jewish & Judaism Terms | Dictionary.com - September 16th, 2022
- Jewish cuisine as a force to connect Israelis and American Jewry - JNS.org - September 16th, 2022
- East Valley rabbi and CEO connects with his Sephardi side - Jewish News of Greater Phoenix - September 16th, 2022
- All those adages about being a grandparent? They're true. J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - September 16th, 2022
- 'Tova the Poet' provides Jewish affirmation on Instagram J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - July 28th, 2022
- Funny Girls, Money Men: The Complications of Jewishness on Broadway - American Theatre - July 28th, 2022
- Messengers from the Russian moral abyss | Joshua Berman | The Blogs - The Times of Israel - July 25th, 2022
- Russia's move to oust Jewish Agency is act of revenge, observers say - Ynetnews - July 25th, 2022
- GOP shows three-way split over past and future: The Note - ABC News - July 25th, 2022
- Jewish American Heritage Month passes without enough fanfare, says ... - July 14th, 2022
- Giants' Jewish slugger Joc Pederson makes the MLB All-Star Game J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - July 14th, 2022
- This 'water warrior' is walking 200 miles to trace East Bay water source J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - July 14th, 2022
- How the American right became aligned with Hungary and its authoritarian leader - NPR - July 14th, 2022
- NYC's Holocaust museum uses personal objects to tell the story of lives lived and lost - Jewish Exponent - July 6th, 2022
- Library event to focus on art of henna - Delaware Gazette - July 2nd, 2022
- Books to Read for Jewish American Heritage Month | Book Riot - June 25th, 2022
- Statement by Minister Hussen on Canadian Jewish Heritage Month - June 21st, 2022
- Elan Carr: Jewish American Heritage Month passes without enough fanfare ... - June 21st, 2022
- New York City Mayor Eric Adams celebrates annual Jewish Heritage Month ... - June 21st, 2022
- Reflections on Jewish Heritage Month from Dr. Ayelet Kuper - June 21st, 2022
- May is National Jewish Heritage Month in Canada - UIA - June 14th, 2022
- The Cal Alumni Association Celebrates Jewish American Heritage Month - June 14th, 2022
- Guests at New York mayors mansion for Jewish Heritage Month note rise ... - June 14th, 2022
- Doug Emhoff speaks to Holocaust survivor and his AI twin in LA - The Jewish News of Northern California - June 14th, 2022
- Holocaust Survivor Reunited with Daughter After 80 Years - aish.com - Aish - June 14th, 2022
- Groundbreaking Research Identifies Opportunities to Increase Educational Equity in Israel - PR Web - June 14th, 2022
- Toronto's Metropolitan Community Church wants to take its social-justice work to the next level with plan for a human-rights centre - The Globe and... - June 6th, 2022
- Why are AIPAC and J Street endorsing the same candidates? - Forward - June 4th, 2022
- I'm a Jewish gay man who resisted apartheid. LGBTQ rights in the U.S. are slipping away from us. - Forward - June 2nd, 2022
- Reno student says anonymous gun tips used to bully him - Nevada Appeal - June 2nd, 2022
- NYC mayor urges Jewish New Yorkers to speak out in support of the police - Forward - May 29th, 2022
- 'It was the oldest continuously in-use synagogue in the United States': Jewish history tour chronicles more than a century of change in Easton - The... - May 29th, 2022
- New coast-to-coast series brings trailblazing Jewish musicians to audiences everywhere - The UCLA Herb Alpert School of Music - UCLA Herb Alpert... - May 29th, 2022
- Daily Kickoff: IRGC terror designation to stay + Stevens and Levin debate - Jewish Insider - May 29th, 2022
- Antisemitic markings discovered at Piedmont High School J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - May 29th, 2022
- Jewish Heritage Month Virtual Program - This event has already occurred - Ajax - May 29th, 2022
- Man in Custody in Every New Yorkers Worst Nightmare - The New York Times - May 29th, 2022
- RELEASE: Gottheimer Helps Lead House Passage of Bipartisan Legislation Condemning the Rise in Antisemitism - Josh Gottheimer - May 20th, 2022
- Jewish in the big leagues: Power hitter Shawn Green dishes at White House event - Forward - May 20th, 2022
- Best Things To Do This Weekend In Los Angeles And SoCal: May 20 - 22 - LAist - May 20th, 2022
- North Bay recognized for standing up to hate and racism - My North Bay Now - May 20th, 2022
- Letters To The Editor May 20, 2022 - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - May 20th, 2022
- People, Places and Things - Birmingham Times - May 20th, 2022
- Peggy Tarr: In the month of May - Evanston RoundTable - May 12th, 2022
- Oregon Rises Above Hate to host Old Town event for AAPI Heritage Month - KOIN.com - May 12th, 2022
- Death of journalism professor who helped revive Judaism in Lincoln after 750 years - Jewish News - May 12th, 2022
- Humans of New York featured this onetime rabbinical student and readers have donated $1.2M to his passion project - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic... - May 12th, 2022
- Min Jin Lee wants to keep building on the Asian-American experience in real life and on the page - The 19th* - May 12th, 2022
- Whats open in the Mid-Hudson Valley for May 12, 2022 - The Daily Freeman - May 12th, 2022
- Liberation Is Jewish History. Let's Make It Our Future, Too. - OtherWords - May 10th, 2022
- Stunning Rise in Anti-Semitic Incidents in the US - Daily Kos - May 10th, 2022
- Putin Claims Hes Ridding Ukraine Of Nazis. Ukraines Jewish Population Knows Better. - HuffPost - May 10th, 2022
- May is merry, and the UO has the arts events to prove it - AroundtheO - April 30th, 2022
- In the conspiracy world, Judaism is always suspect' - Haaretz - April 30th, 2022
- Why these Israeli farmers became heroes after killing their crops (hint: its in the Bible) - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - April 20th, 2022
- Pew's Religious Landscape Study Shows There Are US Jews and Then There Are Committed Jewish Americans - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - April 20th, 2022
- Russia preparing to celebrate Victory Day: What could this mean for Ukraine? - NewsNation Now - April 20th, 2022
- Passover 2022: What is Passover, Passover greetings, and Passover dates 2022 - The Scotsman - April 20th, 2022
- 'Living history': meet the Mosul residents rebuilding their city - Art Newspaper - April 20th, 2022
- Things to Do This Week in LA [4-18-2022 to 4-22-2022] - We Like L.A. - April 20th, 2022
- 'The sky's the limit': Gesher Disability Resources working to meet needs of Jewish students with disabilities - The Arizona Republic - April 11th, 2022
- What the UAE taught Egypt on doing business with Israel - Haaretz - April 11th, 2022
- A work camp in the lowest place on earth is Israel's latest tourist attraction - Haaretz - April 11th, 2022
- What to do this week, from Slay and Ecolution to August Wilson and Charlie Chaplin - NEXTpittsburgh - April 11th, 2022
Comments