Its clear its antisemitism. But how to fight against this hatred isnt as clear cut, rabbi says – NJ.com

Posted By on January 7, 2020

By Clifford Kulwin

An assailant with a machete storms into a rabbis home in Monsey. Shooters bent on killing Jews go on a rampage in Jersey City. A recent Anti-Defamation League (ADL) study finds a dramatic increase in physical assaults on Jews in recent years.

I dont know anyone who rejects the notion that antisemitism in the United States is on the rise.

Daily, we hear about violent attacks, defacing of Jewish buildings, desecration of Jewish cemeteries, Cosmopolitan Jew references in the public square (e.g. George Soros controls the media), and other antisemitic acts.

Jews are genuinely worried about their personal safety. I hear it all the time. Forget about it cant happen here. Many now curb the visible aspects of their Jewish lives: they visit Jewish institutions less often, alter their dress, and maintain a new and unwanted sense of alertness as they go about their day. The subject dominates conversations within the Jewish community. Its what we talk about.

Public officials have been quick to respond, but their responses must reflect a critical reality: antisemitism is a complex phenomenon.

In the Rhineland Massacres of 1096, Crusaders destroyed entire Jewish communities and killed all the inhabits, in the name of avenging their Lord. This is religious antisemitism, based on the belief that Jews killed Jesus. And it continues. Yes, the Nostra Aetete statement of 1965, and every reputable historian of the era, assure us this was not so, but two years ago another ADL study found that over a quarter of Americans believe that the Jews killed Jesus.

In a Facebook post just after the deadly shooting at the Jersey City Kosher Supermarket, Jersey City Board of Education member Joan Terrell-Paige demonstrated another kind of antisemitism: African American homeowners in the Jersey City neighborhood were threatened, intimidated and harassed by the Jewish newcomers, whom she said threatened to bring drug dealers and prostitutes to live next door to you if homeowners wouldnt sell their houses.

This is economic antisemitism. In the post, Terrell-Paige accuses Jews of using economic wherewithal to get what they want, at the expense of those who are too poor to fight back.

And if we assume that a handful of unscrupulous individuals did just what Terrell-Paige says they did, by choosing not to attack them as individuals, but rather going after an entire people, she demonstrates a third kind of antisemitism: racial antisemitism, the belief that Jews as a race seek control over other races, an antisemitism of which Adolf Hitler was especially fond.

In fact, in Mein Kampf, Hitler calls Jews a race that exploits other races, the same charge essentially made by Terrell-Paige. How ironic that Hitler would have despised her, an African American, as much as he would have despised me, a Jew!

There are other antisemitisms, too, like social, ethnic and even literary antisemitism, in the form of Dickens Fagin, who embodies every negative Jewish stereotype imaginable, and T.S. Eliots poem Burbank with a Baedeker, Bleistein with a Cigar.

But how do we define antisemitism? I go back to the definition I learned from a rabbinical school history professor 40 years ago: Antisemitism is opposition to Jews, as Jews. By this definition, the December 10 supermarket shooting was an act of antisemitism, as was last weeks machete attack in Monsey, N.Y., as was 2017s white supremacist rally in Charlottesville and 2018s synagogue attack in Pittsburgh.

But we also have to be aware that, sometimes, the anti-Jewish part of an antisemitic attack is not all thats important.

Within hours of the Monsey attack, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo labeled it an act of domestic terrorism. Yet it now appears machete wielder Grafton Thomas was seriously mentally unbalanced. Wouldnt it be more productive to focus on how someone so severely ill slipped through the system?

David Anderson and Francine Graham arrived in Jersey City intending to shoot Jews. They committed a horrible, antisemitic slaughter. But as well, Anderson had a history of armed violence and spent several years in and out of jail. What does it mean that someone like him was able to secure firearms?

Terrell-Paiges remarks are straight, undiluted antisemitism. The backlash, against her, starting with Governor Murphy, has been reassuring to witness.

And the thousands who marched in Charlottesville, sparking President Trumps notorious remark that there are good people on both sides, knew exactly what they were saying when they shouted Blood and soil, Jews will not replace us.

Public officials have announced their commitment to address this increase in antisemitism. Thats good. But while the definition of antisemitism is straightforward, engaging it must be as multifaceted as the problem. Increased police patrols in vulnerable neighborhoods are essential, but they are just a start.

Are the roots of a specific incident economic or religious? Is it racial? Does an attack have more to do with gun control or mental health? Is it a domestic manifestation of the Middle East conflict? Or a radical preacher exhorting followers to avenge a 2,000 year old crucifixion?

Answers to questions like these will be complicated. They will require study and analysis. They will have to combine law enforcement, education, cultural advocacy, and public policy. But anything less is lip service.

Jews today are nervous. Prejudice is everyones enemy. Hopefully, those we entrust with the responsibility to lead us recognize that, and will spare no effort in keeping America a safe and nurturing place for all who call it home.

Clifford Kulwin is Rabbi Emeritus of Temple Bnai Abraham, Livingston.

Bookmark NJ.com/Opinion. Follow us on Twitter @NJ_Opinion and on Facebook at NJ.com Opinion. Get the latest news updates right in your inbox. Subscribe to NJ.coms newsletters.

Continue reading here:
Its clear its antisemitism. But how to fight against this hatred isnt as clear cut, rabbi says - NJ.com

Related Post

Comments

Comments are closed.