Nazi comparisons have long been off-limits for American Jews. But not this year. – Connecticut Jewish Ledger
Posted By admin on October 8, 2020
By Ron Kampeas
(JTA) Is it OK to compare Donald Trump to a Nazi?
In line with their longtime opposition to such rhetoric, antisemitism watchdog groups are speaking out against the use of Nazi comparisons to attack Trump and his administration.
But that bright line appears to be blurring for many with the president stepping up his efforts to discredit the election results in November and refusing to promise a peaceful transfer of power should he lose to Joe Biden.
The immediate flashpoint in the debate is a new 30-second ad released Tuesday, Sept. 29 by the Jewish Democratic Council of America that draws parallels between the rise of fascism in Germany and the Trump presidency.
In swift and strong rebukes, the antisemitism watchdogs condemned the ad as offensive. One came from the Anti-Defamation League, which has been anything but shy in calling out a range of Trumps statements and actions.
However, some endorsed the ad, notably the prominent Holocaust scholar Deborah Lipstadt and the ADLs former longtime national director, Abraham Foxman, himself a Holocaust survivor. They expressed sympathy for such concerns about the state of America under Trump.
On Tuesday night, the Jewish Democratic Council was playing up its ad, connecting its ominous message to Trumps failure to condemn white supremacists in his first debate with Biden, the Democratic nominee. Instead, Trump appeared to instruct an extremist right-wing group, the Proud Boys, to stand back and stand by.
The condemnations of the ad were part of the longstanding effort of Jewish groups to make Nazi and Holocaust comparisons taboo. But a growing number of historians, activists, politicians and journalists many, but not all of them liberals or Democrats have taken up the line that Trump and his administration are deploying rhetoric and breaking norms in a manner similar to the Nazis as they rose to power and took control of Germany.
The Jewish Democrats ad contrasts images from the rise of fascism in Europe in the 1930s with images from the nearly four years of the Trump presidency. They include neo-Nazi marchers in Charlottesville, Virginia, in 2017, Trump speaking at a rally and the massacre of 11 Jews in the 2018 Pittsburgh synagogue shooting. A synagogue defaced with graffiti in the present day is presented alongside photos of graffitied Jewish shops in the 30s.
Titled Hate doesnt stop itself, it must be stopped, the ad implies that Trump is responsible for the antisemitism of the far right. It comes days after Biden said Trump is sort of like Goebbels, referencing the Nazi propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels.
You say the lie long enough, keep repeating it, repeating it, repeating it, it becomes common knowledge, Biden said on MSNBC.
The ADL did not directly weigh in on Bidens Goebbels comment, but it did issue a sharp condemnation of the Jewish Democratic Councils ad.
This has no place in the presidential race and is deeply offensive to the memories of 6M+ Jews systematically exterminated during the Shoah, tweeted Jonathan Greenblatt, the ADLs CEO. [T]he hate [and] extremism in this race is alarming and should be repudiated unambiguously. Elected leaders who engage in lying, scapegoating, and routinely call for violence should be condemned, full stop. At the same time, we urge leaders & their surrogates to refrain from invoking the #Holocaust in the context of the current election. It is not the same. Stay focused on the issues.
The American Jewish Committee and Simon Wiesenthal Center also called for the ad to be taken down.
The Jewish Democratic Council did not appear to be chastened by the condemnations from legacy groups. Its executive director, Halie Soifer, seized on Trumps Proud Boys moment to reinforce the ads message.
Trump just refused to condemn white nationalism, she said on Twitter, reposting the ad. He called on Proud Boys and others featured in this ad to stand-up and stand-by. (Trump, in fact, said Stand back and stand by.)
Rep. Ted Deutch, a Florida Democrat who is a leader in the unofficial Jewish congressional caucus, said it was Trump who had pushed boundaries.
Does the ad seem to push the boundaries? It does, he said Wednesday. But last night Donald Trump once again obliterated the boundaries when he refused to condemn white supremacists.
Soifer said in an interview that the ad is set to play on web platforms in swing states with substantial Jewish populations, including Florida, and a TV ad buy was being considered. In a text to the Jewish Telegraphic Agency, she noted the expressions of joy that Trumps stand by call elicited from white supremacists on social media.
The presidents blatant refusal to condemn white supremacists which has clearly incited the Proud Boys underscores the importance of our message, she said. I hope those who are concerned by the presidents words last night understand that the urgent warning in our ad that hate does not stop itself, it must be stopped is both accurate and timely.
In a sign of how disorienting the discourse has become, Greenblatt found himself condemning Trump on Twitter hours after he had condemned the Jewish Democratic Council for analogizing Trumps presidency to the rise of fascism.
Trump owes America an apology or an explanation, the ADL leader said.
The ADL and the Wiesenthal Center stood by their statements condemning the ad after Trumps Proud Boys episode on Tuesday. The Wiesenthal Center said it is extremely disappointed and troubled that President Trump did not explicitly denounce white supremacists. He needs to.
The Jewish Democratic Council did not exactly come empty-handed to the debate over whether invoking Nazi comparisons was legitimate when talking about Trump. Lipstadt, the Holocaust historian, argued that in fact it was fine to compare 1930s Germany and what critics call Trumps breaking of norms.
Lipstadt, who has been tapped by administrations of both parties for her Holocaust-related expertise, also stressed that the ad made use of images of Nazi Germany but not of the Holocaust itself.
I would say in the attacks were seeing on the press, the courts, academic institutions, elected officials and even, and most chillingly, the electoral process, that this deserves comparison, she said in a videoconference hosted Tuesday by the Jewish Democratic Council. Its again showing how the publics hatred can be whipped up against Jews. Had the ad contained imagery of the Shoah, I wouldnt be here today.
Likening a political opponent to Nazis has long been a taboo that some leading Jewish institutions and organizations have sought to enforce: The Holocaust was unprecedented and unmatched since in the breadth of its horror and its ambition, the total destruction of the Jews. Comparisons, the argument went, diminished the Holocaust and deprived its lessons of the potency to prevent its recurrence.
Lipstadt has taken that stance in the past.
When you take these terrible moments in our history, and you use it for contemporary purposes in order to fulfill your political objectives, you mangle history, you trample on it, she told Haaretz in 2011.
But in the current era, Lipstadt said, the key to acceptable Holocaust comparisons is precision and nuance.
I do think certain comparisons are fitting, said Lipstadt. Its certainly not 1938, when Nazis led the Kristallnacht pogroms throughout Germany. Its not even September 1935, and the Nuremberg Laws institutionalizing racist policies. What it well might be is December 1932, Hitler comes to power on Jan. 30, 1933 it might be Jan. 15, 1933.
Foxman, the former ADL director, has long spoken out against Nazi comparisons.
Germany did have institutions and they did have democracy and it did fall apart so, yeah, its not Germany, and its not Nazism, but our antennas are quivering, Foxman told JTA.
Soifer, the Jewish Democratic Councils leader, defended the ads tone.
Were not calling Donald Trump a Nazi, she said. We are warning against the ominous parallel of the rise of Nazism and the use of hatred for political purposes and the numerous signs that Donald Trump is doing the same.
The Republican Jewish Coalition condemned the ad.
The rule in debate is that if your only argument is to call your opponent a Nazi, you have no argument at all, RJC Executive Director Matt Brooks said in a statement.
Brooks on Twitter called on Lipstadt to address the ad. Lipstadt directly replied in the Zoom call, saying Trump was emulating Goebbels in repeating a lie until his followers had internalized it.
Foxman said the intensification of hatred, including the rise of antisemitic attacks and attacks on other minorities, did not have to rise to the level of Nazism to set off alarms.
There is serious hate out there which is reminiscent of the hate that we lived through, part of our history, he said. Jewish antennas quiver it doesnt have to be Nazism to worry us that hate is out there, and hate is not being challenged.
Main Photo: A screengrab from an ad by the Jewish Democratic Council of Americareleased on Sept. 29, 2020. The ad draws parallels between the riseof fascism in Germany and the Trump presidency.(YouTube)
See more here:
Nazi comparisons have long been off-limits for American Jews. But not this year. - Connecticut Jewish Ledger
- Decoding the extremist symbols and groups at the Capitol Hill insurrection - ABC17News.com - January 12th, 2021
- Lawmakers Fear More Violence Ahead Of Inauguration Day : Insurrection At The Capitol: Live Updates - NPR - January 12th, 2021
- The Big Question: Can the U.S. Defuse Violent Right-Wing Extremism? - BloombergQuint - January 10th, 2021
- Opinion: We have to work together to protect democracy from threats - The Detroit News - January 10th, 2021
- Sacha Baron Cohen on Facebook, Twitter and Trump - Variety - January 10th, 2021
- Extremists intensify calls for violence ahead of Inauguration Day - WDJT - January 10th, 2021
- Trump Helped Take Extremist Views From The Fringes Of Society To A Mob Attacking The Capitol - FiveThirtyEight - January 10th, 2021
- US Capitol: Q-Anon, Confederate flag man, and Baked Alaska - here are the people who stormed the building - Sky News - January 10th, 2021
- Domestic terrorism and hate exploded in 2020. Here's what the Biden administration must do. - ABC News - January 1st, 2021
- Arizona hate crimes bounced back in 2019, experts fear a surge in 2020 - Cronkite News - January 1st, 2021
- Weeks-Old Statue of Breonna Taylor Is Battered in Oakland, Calif. - The New York Times - January 1st, 2021
- Hanover police need help identifying possible menorah vandals - The Union Leader - December 27th, 2020
- Boycott urged on firms that assist Israel's occupation - Triple Pundit - December 27th, 2020
- After Dartmouth menorah was vandalized, Hanover police seek more information - Concord Monitor - December 22nd, 2020
- New York bans display of Confederate flag and other hate symbols on state grounds - WDJT - December 22nd, 2020
- 'We're against everything they stand for': LGBTQ-owned clothing company Verillas pushes back after Proud Boys wear its kilts - USA TODAY - December 22nd, 2020
- Thomas O'Brien on Boston's Newest Luxury High-Rise Residential Tower, Bulfinch Crossing Development, Pandemic and 2021 - Boston Real Estate Times - December 22nd, 2020
- Hate groups receive millions of dollars in federal funds - WVTM13 - December 14th, 2020
- 'Is this what we're becoming?': Anne Frank memorial in Idaho, the only one in US, defaced with swastika stickers - USA TODAY - December 14th, 2020
- Opposition Mounts Against Proposed Appointment of Far-right Chairman to Israeli Holocaust Museum - Hyperallergic - December 14th, 2020
- Only yesterday - The Hudson Reporter - December 14th, 2020
- Chelsea FC launches exhibition about Jewish Athletes and the Holocaust - Chelsea FC - December 14th, 2020
- Evergreen Mill Elem. student named 'Kid of the Year' finalist - Loudoun Times-Mirror - December 14th, 2020
- Conservatives flocked to Parler after the election. But its explosive growth is over - KCTV Kansas City - December 14th, 2020
- Anti-Defamation League to honor health secretary Levine ... - December 5th, 2020
- The Anti-Defamation League Is Not What It Seems | Boston ... - December 5th, 2020
- Travel Fairness Now Hosts Webinar with Health Care, Consumer and Travel Experts to Improve Traveler Access to Vital Information During Covid-19 and a... - December 5th, 2020
- ADL and Aspen Institute Announce Two Civil Society Fellowship Classes in Response to the Heightened Need for Civil Discourse in a Divided America -... - November 17th, 2020
- Tens of thousands rally in DC to support outgoing President Trump; at least 20 arrested as protesters clash with counterprotesters - USA TODAY - November 17th, 2020
- White supremacist jailed for 2 years over plot to bomb Las Vegas synagogue, ADL - The Times of Israel - November 15th, 2020
- ADL webinar addresses election, extremes - Cleveland Jewish News - November 13th, 2020
- Jewish orgs. react to presumptive win of Dem. nominee Joe Biden - The Jerusalem Post - November 13th, 2020
- Sharon L. Klein Named to Working Mother's Top Wealth Advisor Moms 2020 - PRNewswire - November 13th, 2020
- Facebooks redoubled AI efforts wont stop the spread of harmful content - VentureBeat - November 13th, 2020
- Proceed with eyes open - Isthmus - November 13th, 2020
- Tip lines allow voters to report intimidation, extremism at the polls - Chicago Sun-Times - November 3rd, 2020
- Hate Speech on the Rise - PBS39.org - November 3rd, 2020
- 100-year-old Jewish cemetery in Michigan vandalized with red paint - New York Post - November 3rd, 2020
- Who are the 'Proud Boys'? Photos of Austin protesters circulating online - KIIITV.com - November 3rd, 2020
- In Texas, Jewish Republicans step in against lawsuit seeking to reject 127,000 drive-through votes - Haaretz.com - November 3rd, 2020
- Uncomfortable Conversations: Fighting racism against Asian Americans in wake of COVID - AdAge.com - November 3rd, 2020
- Suspect In Ithaca String Of Hate Crimes Arrested - WSKG.org - November 3rd, 2020
- The risk of violence and protests on Election Day - Vox.com - November 3rd, 2020
- The Color Of Water | Opinion | coronadonewsca.com - Coronado Eagle and Journal - November 3rd, 2020
- Desperation - And Response (2) - The Chattanoogan - November 3rd, 2020
- Opinion: Why Gen Z and Millennials need to vote in 2020 - WHYY - November 3rd, 2020
- ADL says election-related hate on the rise: 'antisemitism, racism, xenophobia & all forms of bigotry.' - The Boston Globe - October 25th, 2020
- CAPAC: New ADL Report Ties Spike in Anti-Asian Bigotry to Trump - The Rafu Shimpo - October 25th, 2020
- Resisting the Tide of Bigotry - The Cairo Review of Global Affairs - October 25th, 2020
- Order allowing Texas counties to have multiple mail-in ballot drop off sites is upheld, but appeal halts openings - Katy Times - October 25th, 2020
- Video of Trump rally appears to show attendee making hand gesture commonly used by white supremacists - USA TODAY - October 25th, 2020
- Hate Groups Active In Ohio Long Before Plot To Kidnap Michigan Governor - WOSU - October 25th, 2020
- Students at Foothill College pass antisemitism resolution J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - October 25th, 2020
- New Initiative Unlocks the Power of Consumers and Brings Brands and Social Media Platforms Together to Clean Up Hate Online - PRNewswire - October 25th, 2020
- Pernod Ricard gets industry buy-in for tool that reports hate speech on social media - Marketing Dive - October 25th, 2020
- 5 Things You Need to Know Today in Worcester Oct. 21, 2020 - This Week In Worcester - October 25th, 2020
- Hate Crimes on the Rise in Orange County - Fullerton Observer - October 25th, 2020
- On its 50th anniversary, the secret Jewish history of Doonesbury - Forward - October 25th, 2020
- Berkeley man known to police charged with Oakland synagogue vandalism - The Jewish News of Northern California - October 25th, 2020
- GOP mailer in the 165th decried as anti-Semitic - The Delaware County Daily Times - October 25th, 2020
- AP Explains: What's Behind Trump's Town Hall Answer on QAnon - WTTW News - October 25th, 2020
- Who are the Proud Boys: Englewood business owner proud to lead controversial group - yoursun.com - October 25th, 2020
- What Is a Militia? And Why Is the Word So Controversial These Days? - The New York Times - October 25th, 2020
- New Pernod Ricard Initiative Aims to Clean Up Hate Online - BevNET.com - October 25th, 2020
- QAnon: YouTube bans conspiracy theory content that justifies real-world violence - Euronews - October 16th, 2020
- LEADING NATIONAL AND STATE ADVOCACY GROUPS, BEN & JERRY'S, AND THE SACRAMENTO BEE ENDORSE PROPOSITION 17 - Civilrights.org - October 16th, 2020
- What You Need to Know About The Trial of the Chicago 7 - The New York Times - October 16th, 2020
- Gateway to Radicalization: Wisconsin cultivates extremism with ties to Michigan insurrection group - Milwaukee Independent - October 16th, 2020
- Affirmative Action on the Ballot: A Closer Look at Prop 16 - Fullerton Observer - October 16th, 2020
- Community organizations to hold virtual summit focused on race, hatred and social justice - SILive.com - October 12th, 2020
- Grand jury releases report on hate speech in San Mateo public schools - The Jewish News of Northern California - October 12th, 2020
- Anti-government groups shift focus from Washington to states - Idaho Business Review - October 12th, 2020
- On the Move: East Valley JCC, Arizona ADL and Valley Beit Midrash - Jewish News of Greater Phoenix - October 8th, 2020
- Facebook says it will now ban all pages supporting QAnon, the anti-Semitic conspiracy theory - Forward - October 8th, 2020
- Are the Proud Boys anti-Semitic? A primer on the far-right group - Jewish Community Voice - October 8th, 2020
- Committee talks rebranding of Waterloo Police insignia - kwwl.com - October 8th, 2020
- Proud Boys presence in North Carolina according to SPLC - WCNC.com - October 8th, 2020
- Everything 'potentially up for grabs': What Jewish groups are watching for in this unusual Supreme Court session - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic... - October 8th, 2020
- White supremacy gang may have had a role in escape attempt thwarted at Lee County Jail - News-Press - October 8th, 2020
- What Jewish groups are watching for in this unusual Supreme Court session - The Jerusalem Post - October 8th, 2020
Comments