Historian: Holocaust Comparisons Are Frequent In US Politics – Texas A&M University Today
Posted By admin on October 8, 2022
The gates of the Nazi concentration camp at Auschwitz, Poland, circa 1965.
Keystone/Getty Images
Robert Keith Packer, a 57-year-old Virginian, achieved a measure of infamy at the Jan. 6 Capitol riot whenhe was photographedwearing a sweatshirt emblazoned with a skull and crossbones along with the words Camp Auschwitz. Work Brings Freedom, the front said, a translation of the notorious motto Arbeit macht frei thatappeared on the gates of Auschwitzand several other Nazi concentration camps. On the back was the word Staff.
Packer was sentencedto 75 days in prisonon Sept. 16, 2022, for his role in the riot he was tried for his actions, not his clothing. But his sweatshirt was far from the onlyHolocaust referenceon Jan. 6 or in its aftermath.
Rioters havecompared their arreststothe persecution of Jews, and commentator Candace Owenscompared Jan. 6 to the Reichstag fire, which Adolf Hitler used as pretext to consolidate power in 1933.
It is a reminder of something that is all too apparent to scholars of the Holocaust, likemyself: Americans are willing totrivialize the genocideby turning it into a tool for their own political goals.
As a historian who has written about the American role inliberating concentration campsat the end of World War II, I have spent a great deal of time thinking about how Americans have and have not talked about the Holocaust in the decades since. There is little evidence that outright denial of the Holocaust is widespread. Instead, the problem is apoor understanding of the tragedy, including this countrys response the focus of a remarkable documentary series, The U.S. and the Holocaust, which recently premiered on PBS.
The contemporary American story of the Holocaust focuses on the U.S. role in helping to bring the Nazi regime of terror to an end. A more nuanced understanding of Americas reaction is less comforting.
The PBS series, produced by acclaimed filmmakers Ken Burns, Lynn Novick and Sarah Botstein, traces what Americans knew about the vast and murderous campaign against civilians in Nazi-occupied Europe in the 1930s, as a flood of Jewish refugees attempted to flee Hitlers Germany.
The U.S. did not enter the war to stop Nazi persecution of Europes Jews. In fact,a majority of Americansopposed entering the war at all until 1940, a year before the Pearl Harbor attack brought the U.S. into the conflict.
Many Americans had no interest in protecting the rights of religious or ethnic minorities at home or abroad.Antisemitism and anti-foreign prejudicewas a core element of American society in the early 20th century, just as white supremacy was. These forms of hatred and exclusion drew from the same well of supposedly scientific beliefsabout racial hierarchy.
While the U.S. allowed almost125,000 Jewish refugeesto enter the country during the years between Hitlers rise to power and the start of the war, many more weredenied entryorleft in limbo.
This part of the countrys response has been largely forgotten, in favor of a story where the U.S. plays a more heroic part.
The liberation of the concentration camps in the spring of 1945 plays a central role in public memories of the war today, along withthe Allied landings in Normandyon D-Day in 1944. The hall through which millions of visitors have entered the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washingtonis lined with flags of the liberator divisions of the U.S. Army.
There is no question that the arrival of American forces at Buchenwald, Dachau and other camps across western and southern Germany saved thousands of prisoners facing murder or death by starvation and sickness. In reality, however, the systematic murder of Europes Jews had largely concluded, and primarily took placehundreds of miles to the eastin what is today Poland, Ukraine, Russia and the Baltic states. By the time American forces landed in western Europe, Europes Jewish population had already been reduced to a few small pockets.
Within weeks of the arrival of American troops at Buchenwald, Americans saw images andnewsreel filmof the horrors of the camps. However, it took decades for the story of camp liberation to become the most important act of the war in Europe in Americans minds. It would not be until the 1980s, when the liberators and survivors were entering old age, that the Holocaust was firmly entrenched in American school curricula and popular culture.
One important consequence of this long wait was that the stories told by and about liberators changed in the intervening decades. As Americans became more familiar with the events of the Holocaust throughtelevisionandfilms, liberator stories began to grow more similar to each other and merged into a general story of the Holocaust, which increasingly focused on the horrors of the death camps in German-occupied Poland.Liberators of Buchenwalddescribing the event decades afterward, for example, thought they remembered gas chambers at the camp, when in fact there were none at that location.
Auschwitz-Birkenau in Poland the most infamous camp facility, with its gates saying Arbeit macht frei came to represent all concentration camps in American memory, and even in family stories. In 2008, for example, then-presidential candidate Barack Obama told a crowd about hisgreat-uncles participation in the liberation of Auschwitz. Auschwitz was actually liberated by the Soviet army in January 1945. Obamas campaign later clarified that his great-uncle, Charles Payne, participated in the liberation of Ohrdruf, a subcamp of Buchenwald.
The centrality of camp liberation to the American story of the Holocaust has real consequences. It turns the Holocaust into a story of American triumph over evil and overlooks the countrys refusal to do more to save the victims.
This simplistic version of a complex history has allowed many Americans to use the Holocaust and Nazism asshallow symbolsfor any kind of government action they oppose and deem oppressive, particularly public health measures during the COVID-19 pandemic. Opponentshave comparedinfectious disease specialist Dr. Anthony Fauci to SS physician and torturer Dr. Josef Mengele. Representative Marjorie Greene hascompared face mask rulesto forcing Jews to wear Star of David badges, and Capitol police agenciesto the Nazi-era Gestapo.
As Burns documentary emphasizes, the U.S. is once again in a time of national reckoning about race, discrimination and histories of oppression. In the final minutes of The U.S. and the Holocaust, viewers see marchers in Charlottsville, Virginia, chanting Jews will not replace us, television pundits opining about the threat of cultural decline through immigration, the 2018attack on the Tree of Life congregationin Pittsburgh, and the Jan. 6 riot. There in the crowd, wearing his sweatshirt, is Robert Keith Packer.
Go here to see the original:
Historian: Holocaust Comparisons Are Frequent In US Politics - Texas A&M University Today
- Austrian group asks to place Holocaust exhibit at Hitler birth site - The Times of Israel - September 14th, 2023
- One Life Review: James Hawes Holocaust Savior Story is Heroism Simply Told and Thats the Point | Toronto - AwardsWatch - September 14th, 2023
- Could the Holocaust have been prevented, along with WWII? - The Jewish Chronicle - September 14th, 2023
- America and the Holocaust exhibit comes to Colorado Springs - KOAA News 5 - September 14th, 2023
- Tell Me, Inge Embassy partners with Meta on Holocaust ... - US Embassy & Consulates in Germany - September 14th, 2023
- Former NY professor, survivor honored for efforts to educate on Holocaust - WCAX - September 14th, 2023
- Palestinian leader's comments on Holocaust draw accusations of antisemitism from US and Europe - The Associated Press - September 10th, 2023
- The Holocaust and the Politics of Memory - Al Jazeera English - September 10th, 2023
- Nabokov, Religion, and the Holocaust - Tablet Magazine - September 10th, 2023
- Last living Bielski brother shares Holocaust survival story to combat antisemitism through education - WPEC - September 10th, 2023
- Raymond J. de Souza: Bright embers from the ashes of the Holocaust - National Post - September 10th, 2023
- Time's Echo music as witness to the Holocaust and history - Financial Times - September 10th, 2023
- After minister joked about Nazis, Finland moves to criminalize Holocaust denial - The Times of Israel - September 1st, 2023
- An Effort to Focus on Long Overlooked Roma Suffering in the Holocaust - The New York Times - September 1st, 2023
- Trump says he prevented a nuclear holocaust as president - The Times of Israel - September 1st, 2023
- Trump Says He Was Too Busy Averting 'Nuclear Holocaust' to Commit Fraud - The Daily Beast - September 1st, 2023
- Frank Bright, one of the last Jewish Holocaust survivors remaining in Britain, dies aged 94 - The Jewish Chronicle - September 1st, 2023
- Imagining what could have been | BrandeisNOW - Brandeis University - September 1st, 2023
- Ken Burns and colleagues turn their lens on the Holocaust - Los Angeles Times - August 19th, 2023
- Nechama Tec, scholar and survivor of the Holocaust, dies at 92 - The Washington Post - August 19th, 2023
- Office that manages Holocaust memorial sites in Germany has windows shattered - The Times of Israel - August 19th, 2023
- Wisconsin's progress on Holocaust education comes with chilling fear - Milwaukee Journal Sentinel - August 19th, 2023
- Holocaust survivor spreads message of peace, happiness, and forgiveness to thousands of Alaskans - Alaska's News Source - August 19th, 2023
- Extremist fight club; hate in the algorithm; Fortnite Holocaust museum - USA TODAY - August 19th, 2023
- Teaching about Nazis and the Holocaust in German schools - DW (English) - August 19th, 2023
- A freak pickleball accident left him paralyzed. He found meaning thanks to parents who survived the Holocaust. - UCHealth Today - August 19th, 2023
- Governor Abbott Appoints Zeidman To Holocaust, Genocide, And ... - Office of the Texas Governor - August 19th, 2023
- U.S. And the Holocaust: Insight and Understanding - AZPM - AZPM - August 19th, 2023
- How Roma and Jews went from familiar strangers to partners in Holocaust memory - The Times of Israel - August 14th, 2023
- Bollywood film "Bawaal" accused of trivialising the Holocaust - FRANCE 24 English - August 14th, 2023
- Funded by the Polish Government, This Film Downplays Poland's Role in the Holocaust - Jewish World - Haaretz - August 14th, 2023
- Ken Burns At 70 Turns His Spotlight On The U.S. And The Holocaust, Says I Wont Work On A More Important Film - Deadline - August 14th, 2023
- He was killed in the Holocaust. His family just got back his book of ... - The Washington Post - August 14th, 2023
- Holocaust Center Sponsors Teachers Trip to Jewish Heritage Museum - Stockton University - August 14th, 2023
- Fortnite Has A Museum Dedicated To Teaching About The Holocaust - Yahoo Finance - August 4th, 2023
- Virtual Holocaust museum to be launched in Fortnite - The Jewish Chronicle - August 4th, 2023
- Seeking the Truth About Bosnian Roma Suffering in the Holocaust - Balkan Insight - August 4th, 2023
- Local high school teacher spent the summer touring the sites of the ... - WUWF - August 4th, 2023
- 'Eva's Promise' tells the story of a young girl who survived the ... - Spectrum News 1 - August 4th, 2023
- Inside the Holocaust Museum coming to the video game Fortnite - Euronews - August 3rd, 2023
- Why Is Gutfeld Silent About His Holocaust Comments On-Air? - The Daily Beast - August 3rd, 2023
- Final synagogue shooting witness says shooter's grandfather served Holocaust survivors - 90.5 WESA - August 3rd, 2023
- Bawaal movie on Amazon Prime: Holocaust memorials and Auschwitz aren't the way to fix your marriage. - Slate - August 3rd, 2023
- Why doesn't Austria, birthplace of Hitler, have a Holocaust Museum? | Opinion - Haaretz - August 3rd, 2023
- Governor Abbott Appoints Nober To Holocaust, Genocide, And ... - Office of the Texas Governor - August 3rd, 2023
- USI Rechnic Holocaust Series to feature award-winning author ... - University of Southern Indiana - August 3rd, 2023
- UConn to Award 2023 Dodd Prize to Ukraine's Babyn Yar Holocaust ... - University of Connecticut - August 3rd, 2023
- The Tucson Jewish Museum and Holocaust Center - A source of ... - AZPM - August 3rd, 2023
- Florida woman sentenced to 4 years in romance scam that stole Holocaust survivors savings - NBC News - August 3rd, 2023
- Holocaust (miniseries) - Wikipedia - July 28th, 2023
- Florida woman who stole nearly $3 million from Holocaust survivor gets ... - July 28th, 2023
- The Holocaust: Fox News Greg Gutfeld receives backlash for Holocaust ... - July 28th, 2023
- Bollywood film accused of trivialising Holocaust with Auschwitz scenes ... - July 28th, 2023
- Bollywood film accused of trivialising Holocaust with Auschwitz scenes - The Guardian - July 28th, 2023
- 6 Holocaust survivors living in Broward continue telling their stories in Davie - WPLG Local 10 - July 28th, 2023
- Bollywood film Bawaal accused of trivializing Holocaust and demeaning victims - CNN - July 28th, 2023
- Landmark exhibits shed light on post-Holocaust life in German displaced person camps - The Times of Israel - July 22nd, 2023
- How Caves That Have Sheltered People for 6,000 Years Saved Jews From the Holocaust - Archaeology - Haaretz - July 22nd, 2023
- Churchill: Yes, we really do need the Holocaust memorial - Times Union - July 22nd, 2023
- Bawaal review: Hitler and the Holocaust save a marriage - Mint Lounge - July 22nd, 2023
- We Survived the Holocaust presented at Richland Library on Thursday - WIS News 10 - July 22nd, 2023
- No more cover-up: Nazi concentration camps on UK soil finally to be officially investigated - The Guardian - July 22nd, 2023
- Medical students from OUWB head to Poland for Study Trip to ... - News at OU - July 22nd, 2023
- Special Exhibition on Black Citizenship in the Jim Crow Era ... - PR Newswire - July 22nd, 2023
- Timeline of the Holocaust - Wikipedia - July 5th, 2023
- Mystery of Holocaust escape girls solved after 84 years - BBC - July 5th, 2023
- Ed Asner plays a Holocaust survivor in film being released 2 years after his death - The Times of Israel - July 5th, 2023
- The Kissing Booth Producer Andrew Cole-Bulgin Boards Holocaust Feature Land Mine (EXCLUSIVE) - Variety - July 5th, 2023
- Opinion: Canada urgently needs to release its Holocaust-related records - The Globe and Mail - July 5th, 2023
- Sir David Adjaye: Architect removed from Holocaust Memorial role after sex allegations - BBC - July 5th, 2023
- Americans and the Holocaust Traveling Exhibition Coming to ... - Washoe Life - July 5th, 2023
- A pig farm that stood on the site of a Nazi-era Roma camp is finally demolished - KCRA Sacramento - July 5th, 2023
- Roseanne Re-Cancels Herself: 'Nobody Died in the Holocaust' - The Daily Beast - June 27th, 2023
- A Hulu horror movie influenced by the post-Holocaust pressure to have children - The Times of Israel - June 27th, 2023
- Germany's biggest Jewish educational and cultural complex since the Holocaust to open in Berlin - The Associated Press - June 23rd, 2023
- Ben Helfgott, Holocaust survivor and Olympic weightlifter, dies at 93 - The Washington Post - June 23rd, 2023
- Following criticism, Missouri school board votes not to ban Holocaust book Maus - The Times of Israel - June 23rd, 2023
- Ken Burns (The U.S. and the Holocaust): I will not work on a more important film than this one [Complete Interview transcript] - Gold Derby - June 23rd, 2023
- Putins Top Propagandist Attacks Israel for Betraying Memory of the Holocaust, Says Kyiv Will Destroy All the Jews in ... - Haaretz - June 23rd, 2023
- Germany's biggest Jewish educational and cultural complex since the Holocaust to open in Berlin - ABC News - June 23rd, 2023
Comments