The Holocaust Memorial Undone by Another War – The New Yorker
Posted By admin on April 16, 2022
That wall is beyond critique, Petrovsky-Shtern, the Northwestern history professor, said. Whatever is done there needs to be modest, a noninvasive way of connecting all these sorrows.
The difference between Khrzhanovskys showy approach and more conventional ways of memorializing the Holocaust goes beyond issues of dignity and taste. The primary purpose of most Holocaust memorials is to document the names and the fates of the victims, the customs and the traditions of the lost world, and to convey the scale of the tragedy. For Khrzhanovsky, this is only a part of the project. Early in his time in Kyiv, he shared a slide presentation with his staff and investors which leaked to Ukrainian media. It included references to building a labyrinth of narrow dark corridors with an interactive exhibit; it would be enhanced by facial-recognition technology that would chart a separate path for every visitor. The ideas were not wholly unrelated to existing Holocaust memorials: the main exhibit space of Yad Vashem is built to feel claustrophobic; the Memorial to the Murdered Jews of Europe, in Berlin, features rows of hundreds of concrete slabs that lean in, creating a narrowing and darkening path; and the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum, in Washington, D.C., encourages its youngest visitors to identify with a composite character named Daniel. But Khrzhanovskys leaked presentation gave rise to fears that he was going to create some kind of Holocaust theme park. (He later explained that the presentation contained results of a brainstorming session, and not anything near the final blueprint.)
Khrzhanovsky collaborated with Patrick Desbois, a French Catholic priest whose title at Georgetown University is professor of the practice of the forensic study of the Holocaust. Desbois, who wrote the book The Holocaust by Bullets, led the scientific committee for the Babyn Yar project, which he called a historical and anthropological revolutionthe first museum to mark the site of a genocidal massacre. Normally, we build countries on mass graves, he told me over Zoom from Georgetown. Where is the museum of the mass graves in Darfur? Who is going to visit the museum of the destruction of Native Americans in Costa Rica?
Desbois shared Khrzhanovskys commitment to re-creating the context and the circumstances of the Babyn Yar massacre in every possible detail, including the inhabitants of what Primo Levi called the gray zonethe unwilling or unthinking assistants to the perpetrators. (Desbois found testimony from a man who had delivered sandwiches to the executioners.) Most of all, Desbois wanted to identify all the perpetrators: The victims were not killed by a storm or a tsunami. Every one of them was shot by someone. The hangings of some of the executioners, in Kyiv in 1946, were followed by a few other trials and punishments. In 1951, Paul Blobel, who had directed the mass executions in Ukraine, was hanged in Germany. Eleven more executioners were tried in Germany in 1967; they had long since returned to civilian lifeone worked as a salesman and another as a bank director. A fourth trial, of three men, occurred in 1971. But most of the Babyn Yar executioners never faced justice.
I want to restablish the responsibility of humans for mass crimes, Desbois said. Unlike the annihilation of millions in death camps, mass murder by bullets still happens all the time, and usually goes unpunished.
When I told acquaintances in Kyiv that I was writing about the project at Babyn Yar, they sighed, rolled their eyes, or laughed uncomfortably. No one, it seemed, trusted the projectpartly because it was privately funded, partly because it was directed by Khrzhanovsky, but most of all because of Russia. The projects most outspoken opponent was Josef Zissels, a seventy-five-year-old former dissident and a leader of Ukraines Jewish community. I met with him in January at the Kyiv-Mohyla Academy, one of Ukraines largest and oldest universities, where he runs the Jewish-studies center. His primary objection to the project, he said, came from the sense that Putin and his imperial agenda were the forces behind it. Although all four of the rich men who were bankrolling the memorial were Jews who were born in Ukraine, they had benefitted from their connections to Russia, and three of them had carried Russian passports at some point. Its hybrid warfare, Zissels said. They are trying to foist memory thats not our memory.
He talked about what Ukrainians and some Russians call pobedobesiye (literally, victory mania), which forms the foundational historical myth and the central public ritual of Putins Russia. Every year, the Soviet victory in the Second World War is celebrated with greater fanfare and bigger fireworks, military parades, and renactments. For months leading up to May9th, when the country celebrates Victory Day, Russians wear orange-and-black commemorative ribbons on their clothes and bags. The especially zealous decorate their vehicles with slogans such as Onward to Berlin or 1941-1945. We could do it again. One popular decal features two stick figures in the act of anal intercourse; the top has a hammer and sickle for a head, the bottom a swastika.
The Russian memory project is explicitly anti-Western. What the world calls the Second World War, Russia calls the Great Patriotic War. What for most of the world began on September 1, 1939, for Russia started on June22, 1941, when the non-aggression pact between Hitler and Stalin ended and the war between the two countries began. The U.K., the U.S., France, and many other Allied countries look back on the war with a sense of both tragedy and victory, but the triumphalism in Russia is more pronounced. Now Russian leaders brand real or imagined challengers to their power as Nazis.
Some critics suspected that Khrzhanovskys project, in keeping with Russian propaganda that increasingly labelled Ukrainians as Nazis, would focus on local collaborators in war crimes. In 2021, Sergei Loznitsa, one of the best-known Ukrainian directors, made a documentary, Babi Yar. Context, under the auspices of the memorial center; other members of the Ukrainian film community charged that the movie was filled with the narrative accusing... the people of Ukraine of collaboration in the mass killings of the Jewish population. In fact, Babi Yar. Context, which employs footage shot by German and Soviet propagandists, does not address the question of collaborators.
I spent many days talking with members of the Babyn Yar Holocaust Memorial Center team and combing through the materials they had produced. I encountered occasional pockets of ignorance, primarily on matters of Soviet Jewish history, but didnt see any indication that the project or its funders were promoting a Russia-centric, much less a Putin-style, narrative. Few on the team had been educated in Russia or had lived there for a significant amount of time. Khrzhanovsky had spent the majority of the past two decades in Kharkiv and London.
Fridman told me, I expected that wed encounter resistance, but I never thought wed be called agents of the Kremlin. He was born in Lviv. Both of his grandmothers were from Kyiv and had been lucky to leave Ukraine in 1941 with their children. Fridmans great-grandparents perished in the Holocaust; Fuks, Khan, and Pinchuk had lost relatives, too. At least seven of Khans family members were killed at Babyn Yar. (Khrzhanovskys maternal grandmother, too, fled Ukraine in 1941.) Sure, the funders of the memorial had made their money in Russiait was a good place to do businessbut they had complicated relationships with the country. Several years ago, Fuks renounced his Russian citizenship.
I asked Zissels what aspects of Khrzhanovskys project reflected the Kremlins historical narrative. I cant prove it, he said. But I can feel it. The apprehension, it seems, was a fear of contagion. The problem with Putins revisionist history is not just the centrality of the Soviet Union and Soviet military glory; its that, like all Russian propaganda, it intentionally sows chaos. The effect is to produce a preferred historical narrative and a sense of nihilisma consensus that good and evil are indistinguishable, that nothing is true and everything is possible. This was what made it hard for so many Ukrainians to trust a project funded by people who still did business in Russia. Khrzhanovskys avowed obsession with the nature of evil, his willingness to examine it at close range, only fed the distrust.
Putin launched a full-scale invasion of Ukraine on February 24th. A few days later, Khrzhanovsky was on the phone with Anna Furman, who had been in charge of compiling the list of victims at Babyn Yar. Khrzhanovsky was begging: Anechka, you know how this goes. Please take your mother and leave. Furman and her mother ended up going to western Ukraine, as did a few other staff members; still others left for Poland. Shovenko, the artistic director, and Didenko, Khrzhanovskys assistant, surprised everyone by announcing that they were getting married. After a small ceremony (Khrzhanovsky attended via Zoom), Didenko went to Lviv, and Shovenko reported for duty with the Ukrainian Army.
Khrzhanovsky used to say, Babyn Yar is not in the pastit is now. But he didnt realize that now meant now. He is no longer surprised that so many Ukrainians were suspicious of his work on the memorial. When I came to Kyiv, I knew that Putin was a scumbag, that the Donbas was at war, that his troops were helping fight it, but I didnt realize the extent of it, and the Ukrainians did, he told me from London in March. The memorial center has reoriented itself toward helping Ukrainians flee to safety, starting with Holocaust survivors, other elderly people, and the disabled. Its clear that there wont be a Babyn Yar memorial the way we envisioned it, Pinchuk told me in late March, from his home in London.
Fridman was one of the super-rich Russians to be sanctioned in response to the war, initially by the European Union and then by the United Kingdom. He complained to the media that the sanctions were unfair, but he resigned from the memorial center. Days later, the E.U. sanctioned Khan, and he, too, resigned. That left Pinchuk. On my computer screen, a month into the war, he still looked and sounded shocked. This is just beyond, beyond, he said. It was impossible to imagine. Its genocide. He told me that he was focussing his time and money trying to get military equipment and humanitarian aid to Ukraine.
Desboiss Ukrainian team of six researchers of mass murder were now interviewing victims and witnesses of new Russian war crimes. By the first week of April, they had completed thirty-seven investigations in Bucha, Mariupol, Irpin, Kherson, and Kharkiv. The day before Desbois and I spoke, the team had interviewed a young Ukrainian man who had been tortured by Russian troops for three days. The Russians had demanded that he confess to being a Nazi.
See original here:
The Holocaust Memorial Undone by Another War - The New Yorker
- Jewish Population of the World - June 30th, 2022
- Good Within Bad - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - June 30th, 2022
- From Loneliness To Oneness: The Endless Expansion of Self - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - June 30th, 2022
- What's The Real Purpose Of Aleinu? (Part II) - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - June 30th, 2022
- Cambridge to mark Refugee Week and Holocaust Memorial Day at free civic event on Sunday 26 June - Cambridge City Council - June 26th, 2022
- Second Gentleman Douglas Emhoff Visits USC Shoah Foundation - University of Southern California - June 14th, 2022
- Opinion | Russia's Missiles Are Burning the History of Ukraine's Babyn Yar Ravine - The New York Times - June 14th, 2022
- Guildhall exhibitions focus on emigration and exile ahead of Refugee Week - Leicester News - June 14th, 2022
- 80 years ago Anne Frank started her diary, a landmark of world literature - FRANCE 24 English - June 13th, 2022
- About Us - A world that remembers the Holocaust | IHRA - June 8th, 2022
- Turning on the Light - UofSC News & Events - SC.edu - June 8th, 2022
- Dov Forman Wants You to Know His Great-Grandmothers Holocaust Story - The New York Times - June 8th, 2022
- Summer TV 2022: 27 Shows to Watch - The New York Times - June 4th, 2022
- www.mdjonline.com - May 25th, 2022
- Come to This Court and Cry by Linda Kinstler review when Holocaust memories fade - The Guardian - May 25th, 2022
- Three Brothers Bakery in Houston Is a Story of Survival - Texas Monthly - May 25th, 2022
- Lessons in hate from the Holocaust to Buffalo - Harvard Gazette - May 20th, 2022
- KY Rep. Thomas Massie voted 'no' on measure condemning antisemitism - Courier Journal - May 20th, 2022
- Professor's Portrait Captures the Resilience of a Holocaust Survivor - University of Denver Newsroom - May 16th, 2022
- The Holocaust | Holocaust and Genocide Studies | College ... - May 6th, 2022
- Holocaust Photos: 44 Heartrending Images Of Tragedy And ... - May 6th, 2022
- My Great-Uncle, The Holocaust's First Jewish Victim - The Atlantic - May 6th, 2022
- Days of Remembrance: Determination, Hope and Honor | Article | The United States Army - United States Army - May 6th, 2022
- What Happened at the 1941 Babi Yar Massacre? - History - May 6th, 2022
- UNESCO | Building peace in the minds of men and women - April 20th, 2022
- Holocaust Remembrance Day event set Sunday - Oakridger - April 20th, 2022
- Holocaust survivor freed from Auschwitz writes symphonic poem that will be performed Wednesday at Carnegie Hall - CBS New York - April 20th, 2022
- Ukrainian Holocaust survivors flee war again this time to Germany - NPR - April 16th, 2022
- Holocaust survivor Elizabeth Sandy will speak at URI on April 28, Holocaust Remembrance Day - University of Rhode Island - April 16th, 2022
- Marvin Chomsky, Director of Roots and Holocaust, Dies at 92 - The New York Times - April 16th, 2022
- Holocaust Awareness Week features talk by Holocaust survivor - Source - February 28th, 2022
- Alderwoman Coggs: On the reemergence of America's Black Holocaust Museum - WisPolitics.com - February 28th, 2022
- Invasion of Ukraine brings back memories of the Holocaust, VB rabbi says - WAVY.com - February 28th, 2022
- Traveling exhibit sheds light on the Holocaust during visit to north central Florida - WUFT - February 17th, 2022
- Holocaust victims opera stored for years in trunk gets premiere at last - The Guardian - February 17th, 2022
- We cheapen the grief of the Holocaust by conjuring Nazi tyranny it must stop | Opinion - NorthJersey.com - February 17th, 2022
- New York police investigating 2 alleged assaults against Jews - The Times of Israel - February 11th, 2022
- Teen Charged With Hate Crime In Attack On Man In Brooklyn - CBS New York - February 11th, 2022
- Jewish Documentary Film Series Begins Feb. 15 At The Jewish Cultural Center For 4 Consecutive Weeks - The Chattanoogan - February 11th, 2022
- Scary video: Duo forces way inside Coney Island apartment before robbing man - WPIX 11 New York - February 11th, 2022
- On International Holocaust Remembrance Day, revisit NPR's stories from survivors - NPR - January 30th, 2022
- A discovery of Holocaust-era photos helps a Jewish family connect with its past - NPR - January 30th, 2022
- First Person: The Holocaust, genocide, and war - UN News - January 30th, 2022
- Why is it political to ask Holocaust survivors about the state of U.S. democracy? - Los Angeles Times - January 30th, 2022
- The Holocaust: Families affected tell their stories - CBBC Newsround - January 30th, 2022
- The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas may fuel dangerous Holocaust fallacies - The Guardian - January 30th, 2022
- Survey reveals about one-third of North American students feel the Holocaust was fabricated or exaggerated - CTV News Atlantic - January 30th, 2022
- How three-quarters of French Jews survived the Holocaust, despite the Vichy regime - FRANCE 24 English - January 30th, 2022
- Cincinnati Holocaust & Humanity Center to revamp Institute on Teaching The Holocaust - ideastream - January 30th, 2022
- U of A Displays Pen Used to Sign Holocaust Education Legislation - University of Arkansas Newswire - January 30th, 2022
- The week in TV: The Responder; Trigger Point; The Gilded Age; Survivors: Portraits of the Holocaust - The Guardian - January 30th, 2022
- New Biographies of Stanisaw Lem, Reviewed - The New Yorker - January 14th, 2022
- The Nazis didnt win: 98-year-old Holocaust survivor amidst thousands of birthday cards - The Indian Express - January 1st, 2022
- The top 10 most-read medical ethics articles in 2021 - American Medical Association - December 30th, 2021
- Banks, credit unions urged to waive fees for Holocaust compensation - American Banker - December 24th, 2021
- Entertainment Weekly Staffer: Boss Joked About the Holocaust, Eating Disorders - TheWrap - December 24th, 2021
- For Aging New Yorkers, Help With Health Care - The New York Times - December 16th, 2021
- By the grace of the game: The Holocaust, a basketball legacy, and an unprecedented American dream - Yahoo Sports - December 1st, 2021
- The Krakow Family Who Survived the Holocaust | THIRTEEN - New York Public Media - MetroFocus - December 1st, 2021
- Holocaust Museum and Tolerance Center of Nassau County announces grand opening of Simon Wiesenthal Center's world-renowned 'Courage to Remember'... - November 30th, 2021
- Over 350000 Holocaust Survivors Are Still With Us. Who's Addressing Their Basic Needs? Inside Philanthropy - Inside Philanthropy - November 30th, 2021
- Prime Minister announces reappointment of Special Envoy on Preserving Holocaust Remembrance and Combatting Antisemitism - Prime Minister of Canada - November 30th, 2021
- The society of Holocaust victims: what was life inside a Nazi camp like? | OUPblog - OUPblog - November 30th, 2021
- Kansas anti-vaxxers condemned for comparing vaccine mandates to the Holocaust by wearing yellow stars - The Independent - November 14th, 2021
- Art, families and the Holocaust: An evening learning from Tomi Reichental - The Irish Times - November 14th, 2021
- www.northwestgeorgianews.com - November 10th, 2021
- Holocaust Timeline: The Rise of the Nazi Party - October 18th, 2021
- A Teacher's Guide to the Holocaust-Victims - October 18th, 2021
- Donate to Keep Holocaust Memory Alive | United States ... - October 18th, 2021
- Opinion | Stop comparing everything to the Holocaust - The Pitt News - October 18th, 2021
- What to make of the legacy of Holocaust survivors - News - The University of Sydney - October 18th, 2021
- The first major massacre in the Holocaust by bullets: Babi Yar, 80 years on - FRANCE 24 English - October 4th, 2021
- Holocaust survivors, a candy store and the mafia make for unusual family memoir - The San Diego Union-Tribune - October 4th, 2021
- Holocaust Education Initiative Offers Free, Trauma-Informed Teaching Seminar - bctv.org - October 4th, 2021
- The Lerner screens a film about a Goshen family's efforts to rescue Jews in the Holocaust - South Bend Tribune - September 22nd, 2021
- Clackamas County commissioner Mark Shull condemned after sharing post comparing COVID-19 restrictions to Holo - oregonlive.com - September 22nd, 2021
- French Holocaust survivor talks about her life during the Nazi occupation and her journey to Central Pa. - FOX43.com - September 22nd, 2021
- Consumer Alert: Holocaust Survivors of Luxembourg to Receive Compensation - DFS.NY.gov - September 22nd, 2021
- Holocaust historian speaks on the value of mutual assistance and maintaining human dignity in 13th annual Rev. Bernie Clark, C.S.C., Lecture - ND... - September 22nd, 2021
- New Course Explores How the Holocaust Continues to Affect Nearly Every Field and Person Today - University of Arkansas Newswire - September 22nd, 2021
Comments