After a Year in Office, What Has Israels Change Government Changed? – The New Yorker
Posted By admin on June 19, 2022
Israels improbable change government has been in power exactly one year this week, a landmark that is primarily a tribute to how its various leaders contempt for former Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu marginally exceeds their antipathy for one another. The government is a coalition of two blocs: three rightist parties, managed by Prime Minister Naftali Bennett, the leader of the Yamina party, representing Land of Israel hard-liners; and four center and left parties, managed by Foreign Minister Yair Lapid, the founder of the Yesh Atid party, which appeals to Tel Avivs bourgeois intelligentsia. The two blocs, with the support of a moderate conservative Islamist party led by Mansour Abbas, whose explicit aim was to increase investment in Arab-Israeli communities, initially held a bare majority of sixty-one seats in the Knesset, the Israeli parliament. According to an agreed-upon rotation plan, Bennett and Lapid were scheduled to switch jobs in the summer of 2023; all leaders had agreed to avoid tackling the most divisive issues, especially those dealing with the occupation of Palestine. But a vote in the Knesset on the night of June 6th suggests that division is inescapable and that the governments run may come to an end, in months, if not weeks. Israel would then face a fifth general election in three years and, once again, as the Haaretz editor, Aluf Benn, told me, the campaign will largely be about Bibi, who remains the dominant figure in our politics.
What has the change government changed? To judge from recent international headlines, not much. Hamas, which launched more than four thousand rockets at Israeli cities a year ago, still rules Gaza, which Israel has kept under siege. The World Bank worries that, despite signs of recovery last year, the Palestinian Authoritys fiscal situation remains highly challenging. The U.S. State Department offered to convene a summit with Jordan and Egypt, which would have bolstered the P.A.s diplomatic standing, but Israel reportedly rejected the idea. In East Jerusalem, during Ramadan, Israeli police forces and Palestinians clashed at the Al-Aqsa Mosque compound, known to Jews as the Temple Mount. After Ramadan ended, amid continued disturbances in the West Bank, the Al Jazeera journalist Shireen Abu Akleh was shot and killed, likely by an Israeli soldier, according to a Washington Post analysis. (The Israeli government walked back an initial statement that Abu Akleh had likely been killed by a Palestinian gunman.) The funeral compounded the horror: in an effort to keep pallbearers from carrying her casket into the street, presumably to keep the procession from turning into a mass demonstration, Israeli forces created a grotesque melee during which the casket was almost dropped. The United Nations data shows that from June, 2021, to May, 2022, seventy-nine West Bank Palestinians died in conflict-related confrontations with Israelis. The government is currently planning to move about thirteen hundred Palestinians from their homes in Masafer Yatta, in the South Hebron Hills, to make way for a military-training zone.
Netanyahus strategic policies live on, too. The government has continued a bombing campaign on Iranian convoys in Syria, and so to engage with Vladimir Putin, who backstops the Syrian regime, Bennett, turning aside direct appeals from Volodymyr Zelensky, has affected a kind of neutrality in the Ukraine war. The government has capitalized on Netanyahus Abraham Accords and concluded a ten-billion-dollar free-trade deal with the United Arab Emirates. Like Netanyahu, Bennett and Lapid have resisted, albeit more tactfully, Washingtons eagerness to renew the Iran nuclear deal, insisting, as the Likud leader has, on the need to find a good agreement, and there are still reports tying Israel to the assassination of Iranian military officers and nuclear scientists, and that it is preparing contingency plans for a premptive strike against Iranian nuclear installations. (Iran, for its part, is removing twenty-seven U.N. surveillance cameras from key nuclear facilities.) And Bennett and Lapid are still working with the U.S. to create a strategic alliance against Iran with Egypt and the Gulf states, implicitly aiming to include Saudi Arabia.
The change government has had its better moments. Netanyahu, furthering nakedly political ends, delayed the passage of a national budget for more than three years, depleting funds in the public sector. Last November, the change government passed a budget specifically allocating new funds for transportation, health care, law enforcement (especially in poorer Arab-Israeli cities, where crime rates are high), and education. It also nudged ultra-Orthodox schools for boys to teach core subjects, including English and math, which eighty-four per cent of the secondary students in those schools did not learn, according to a 2020 report. Economic growth surpassed eight per cent in 2021 and is expected to run at more than five per cent this year. And the government has raised the number of work permits for Gazans to twenty thousand, marginally improving conditions in the Strip.
Arguably, though, the change governments most transformational moment was its swearing-in: the sight of annexationists and two-staters saluting one another as the guardians of democratic citizenship, and sitting with an Arab-Israeli party that was wielding real power for the first time. The government could certainly take credit for a change of mood, at least in its early months, after two years of Netanyahus installing sycophants and relentlessly attacking the judiciary, the press, retired military leaders, and lites. This government has been a contraceptive, Amnon Abramovich, a TV commentator on Israels Channel 12, told me. It aimed to prevent a fifth, sixth, or seventh stalemate election, or one in which Bibi finally wins his sixty-one-plus seats and becomes Viktor Orbn the Second.
Meanwhile, Netanyahus trial, for fraud, bribery, and breach of trust, plods on; even more awkward for the former Prime Minister, a state commission will investigate alleged conflicts of interest, between 2009 and 2016, from procurement deals, under his government, for naval vessels and submarines with the German company Thyssenkrupp. (Netanyahus national-security adviser until 2011, Uzi Arad, told me that he had warned Netanyahu about an obvious conflict of interest.) Nevertheless, Netanyahu is hardly fading in a nation where, according to a 2018 study, sixty-four per cent of young Jews identify as right-wing. Netanyahus opposition bloc, the national camp, which draws support from ultra-Orthodox communities and settler zealots, among others, now has, by some estimates, fifty-four seats in the Knesset, and most recent polls have it creeping up to a projected sixty, if an election were to be held.
The change government, for its part, has been struggling to hold ranks. In early April, the coalition was reduced to sixty seats, when one of Bennetts allies defectedbecause, she complained, the left-wing Health Minister, Nitzan Horowitz, had refused to prohibit leavened bread from being brought into hospitals on Passover. (Another Yamina member had defected even before the government launched, which is why its majority was sixty-one in the first place, not sixty-two.) After the violence at Al-Aqsa, a number of Arab-Israeli coalition members announced an unwillingness to continue, but then relented. The loss of a majority left the balance of power in the Knesset in the hands of the Joint List, an alliance of three Arab parties, which has six seats, led by Ayman Odeh, a progressive strongly identified with Palestinian civil and national rights. Odeh told me that he would not want to hasten Netanyahus return, and would potentially act as a coalition ally on social issues. But his alliance would certainly not act to support the current government, which, Odeh believes, undermines Palestinian Arab standingin Israel or the occupied territories.
Which brings us to last weeks vote in the Knesset. The issue, though hardly inconsequential, initially seemed routine: the rightist Justice Minister, Gideon Saar, sought to pass legislation to extend Israeli criminal and some civil law to settlers in occupied territory, provisions that were first included in emergency legislation after the 1967 war and have been renewed every five years since. They mean that settlers, unlike Palestinian residents under occupation, pay income tax and qualify for public-health insurance and subsidized mortgages. And, unlike the Palestinians, the settlers are patrolled by the police, not the Army. The police, it must be noted, regularly fail to properly investigate Palestinian residents complaints of harassment by settlers; the human-rights organization Yesh Din reports that more than thirteen hundred such complaints have been filed since 2005, and that more than twelve hundred of these were closed without an indictment being filed.
Arab-Israeli coalition members could hardly be expected to back the renewal, but that is what Saar demanded. He may have anticipated that Netanyahu would urge his bloc to vote against the renewal, preferring to see the settlers, who will always return to him, be left temporarily unprotected, if this meant that the government might fall. Yet Saar warned that the vote, on what for years had been a routine measure, would determine whether the coalition will exist or not. The vote was predictable: the two Yamina defectors would not support it, effectively joining Netanyahus bid to topple the government. The Joint List also voted against. And so, finally, did two Arab-Israeli coalition members, including one from Abbass party, the rest of whom absented themselves. The measure failed, fifty-eight to fifty-two, after which yet another Yamina member announced that he was headed out the door.
The coalition can, and apparently will, bring up the measure for a second vote. Saar emphasized that the current renewal runs until the end of June. Nevertheless, the contradictions within the change government are showing. Saar is one of the rightist leaders who joined it not necessarily because they disagreed with national-camp principles; he has a complicated history with Netanyahu, and he made it clear last year that an indicted person should not become Prime Minister. It wasnt business, it was personal. Saar now seems to be signalling that he wants to get back to business.
He has reportedly been in negotiations with Netanyahus party to serve in a national-camp government, possibly as the Prime Minister in a rotation agreement like the one Bennett and Lapid made. Saar adamantly denies the reports, yet his warning that the coalitions existence may be in doubt should be taken as a self-fulfilling prophecy. Before the vote, a Jerusalem Post poll found that sixty-nine per cent of Israelis do not want an Arab party in the government next time. Saar is simply scapegoating Arab members of the coalition to try to position himself for whats next, Aluf Benn told me. Indeed, the Justice Ministers speculated gambit reflects how mainstream national-camp ideas have become. In March, the Knesset resurrected a law denying Israelis the right to naturalize Palestinian spouses from the West Bank. Meanwhile, the government approved more than four thousand previously planned settlement housing units in the West Bank.
Read more here:
After a Year in Office, What Has Israels Change Government Changed? - The New Yorker
- "Israel and Turkey are leading the Middle East gaming industry" - CTech - September 14th, 2023
- Smoking Rooms to Return to Israel's International Airport, Bucking ... - Haaretz - September 14th, 2023
- Rifts in Israel's coalition as Ben-Gvir withholds support - The New Arab - September 14th, 2023
- Home - Israel | The Netherlands and Israel - The Netherlands and You - September 14th, 2023
- Noa's Arc: How Noa Tishby went from actress to Israel activist - The Jewish Chronicle - September 14th, 2023
- Moody's likely won't lower Israel's credit rating but outlook could ... - Ynetnews - September 14th, 2023
- Turkey frees Israeli held over ornamental bell it claimed was artifact - The Times of Israel - September 14th, 2023
- Congregation Beth Israel to Host 'Rosh Hashanah in the Park' - http://www.we-ha.com - September 14th, 2023
- US should help win the freedom of Israeli scholar missing in Iraq, her sister says - The Times of Israel - September 14th, 2023
- Foreign Secretary travels to Israel and the Occupied Palestinian ... - GOV.UK - September 14th, 2023
- Israel says it will reopen the main cargo crossing to Gaza on Sunday, a relief for Gazan producers - ABC News - September 14th, 2023
- Mossad chief vows to target Irans highest echelon if Israelis, Jews hurt in terror - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- Israeli delegation makes first open visit to Saudi Arabia - FRANCE 24 English - September 12th, 2023
- Israel expects 30% of cars on its roads to be electric by 2030 - Reuters.com - September 12th, 2023
- We must reshape the Israel conversation on campus - opinion - The Jerusalem Post - September 12th, 2023
- Israel on edge as Supreme Court convenes for historic, crucial overhaul hearing - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- Leading protester in Israel speaks to CNN ahead of Supreme Court hearing - CNN - September 12th, 2023
- UK foreign secretary in Israel to talk Iran threats, Palestinian state - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- American Rabbis, Tell Your Congregants: The Israel You Knew Is a ... - Haaretz - September 12th, 2023
- Why Barcelona reversed its decision to cut ties with Israel - The New Arab - September 12th, 2023
- Israel ties Romania 1-1 as they fight to qualify for 2024 Euro soccer tourney - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- Earthquake preparedness exercise in northern Israel - Arutz Sheva - September 12th, 2023
- Here's What I Learned on My Trip to Israel | White Coat Investor - The White Coat Investor - September 12th, 2023
- 'It's Hard to Consider Abandoning Israel. But Leaving Is the Only ... - Haaretz - September 12th, 2023
- Israel imposing apartheid on Palestinians, says former Mossad chief - The Guardian - September 12th, 2023
- Four 1,900-year-old Roman swords found in cave in Israel - CNN - September 12th, 2023
- Citing God of Israel, Papua New Guinea becomes 5th nation to open Jerusalem embassy - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- US said to transfer armored vehicles, weapons to PA to clamp down on West Bank terror - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- Israel preparing to send search and rescue mission, assistance to quake-hit Morocco - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- NYC exhibit shows Israeli Hebrew didnt kill Yiddish, it gave it a new nest to live in - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- Rahat man suspected of killing wife, turning gun on self - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- Israel's toxic harvest in Africa - The Africa Report - September 12th, 2023
- Iran and Israel find common purpose: The subjugation of women - The Hill - August 28th, 2023
- Israel's foreign minister meets with Libyan counterpart in sign of ... - POLITICO - August 28th, 2023
- Imagine Dragons warmup band AJR tours Israel ahead of Tuesday show - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- Palestinian Mother Deported to Gaza After 30 Years in Israel ... - Haaretz - August 28th, 2023
- Citing Israeli example, Zelensky says Ukrainians need to learn to live with conflict - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- Israel says it foiled bid to smuggle Iran-made explosives over Jordan border - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- The politics of visiting Israel aren't stuck in the '90s - City & State - August 28th, 2023
- Israel's Dead End: We Don't Have the Luxury of Despair - Opinion - Haaretz - August 28th, 2023
- Israels cost of living the highest among OECD countries in 2022, data shows - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- In Israel, Adams Has Swagger in His Step and 'Hustle' on His Sleeve - The New York Times - August 28th, 2023
- A minister who hates Arabs will protect Arab children?: 100k at Tel Aviv protests - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- Israel uncovers massive section of Second Temple-era Jerusalem ... - The Jerusalem Post - August 28th, 2023
- One Voyage That Changed the Face of Jewish Culture in Israel ... - Haaretz - August 28th, 2023
- Inside the negotiations over Israels democracy - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- Vivek Ramaswamy Touched the Third Rail on Israel. He's Surely ... - Vanity Fair - August 28th, 2023
- Arab Israeli activist says he was assaulted at UAE airport over pro-Israel advocacy - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- Tantleff, Berkey and Hutter family to be honored by Israel Bonds at ... - ROI-NJ.com - August 28th, 2023
- Israel should build closer ties with Uganda - opinion - The Jerusalem Post - August 28th, 2023
- Israels Marhu Teferi wins silver in mens marathon at World Athletics Championships - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- 4 Palestinians attack army post near Jenin, are shot by troops - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- Israel Airports Authority: Serious delays in flights to and from UK - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- Libyans burn tyres in protest over Israel meeting video - The Guardian - August 28th, 2023
- Bringing Sundays to Israel: Is it time for the workweek to change? - The Jerusalem Post - August 28th, 2023
- Iran unveils armed drone resembling America's MQ-9 Reaper and says it could potentially reach Israel - The Associated Press - August 22nd, 2023
- Analysis | A Saudi-Israeli Peace Deal? Who Wants What and Why - The Washington Post - August 22nd, 2023
- In 2022, AIPAC opposed Shri Thanedar. This month he went to Israel with the group. - Jewish Insider - August 22nd, 2023
- Americans views of Israel, Netanyahu and U.S.-Israel relations - Pew Research Center - August 22nd, 2023
- Israeli forces nab 2 Palestinian suspects in deadly terror attack near Hebron - The Times of Israel - August 22nd, 2023
- 17-year-old Palestinian Killed During Israeli Military Raid in Northern West Bank - Israel News - Haaretz - August 22nd, 2023
- Iran unveils armed drone, claims it could reach Israel - The Times of Israel - August 22nd, 2023
- It's Public Enemy No.1 for Israel's nature. But what if we need it one ... - Haaretz - August 22nd, 2023
- Israel's Berlin Wall on the Border With Lebanon - Israel News - Haaretz - August 22nd, 2023
- Israel competition watchdog summons Strauss over price-fixing allegations - The Times of Israel - August 22nd, 2023
- Yaakov Nimrodi, Israels first military envoy to Iran, dies at 97 - The Times of Israel - August 22nd, 2023
- Guatemala elects progressive Arvalo, who studied in Israel, as president - The Times of Israel - August 22nd, 2023
- Quran Burnings and Terror Threats: Israel Warns Citizens to Avoid ... - Haaretz - August 22nd, 2023
- Egypt releases Israeli arrested in Sinai after brawling with locals - The Times of Israel - August 22nd, 2023
- Hungary to produce combat drones in cooperation with Israel and Germany - The Times of Israel - August 22nd, 2023
- Israel-Hezbollah tensions elevate risks of conflict | Reuters - August 20th, 2023
- Ukraine threatens to shut border to Uman pilgrims, citing Israeli deportations - The Times of Israel - August 20th, 2023
- Via modern medical Silk Road, Israeli doctors are saving the lives of Afghan kids - The Times of Israel - August 20th, 2023
- Israel dismisses Ukrainian threat to shut its border to Uman pilgrims report - The Times of Israel - August 20th, 2023
- Diaspora Jews: Time to take a stand - The Times of Israel - August 20th, 2023
- Israeli tourist arrested in Sinai after getting in fight with locals - The Times of Israel - August 20th, 2023
- Iron Dome downs drone flying from Gaza toward Israel IDF - The Times of Israel - August 20th, 2023
- We need to reexamine how we teach about Israel - opinion - The Jerusalem Post - August 20th, 2023
- I have long rejected claims that Israel is an apartheid state. Now I believe that is where it is heading - The Guardian - August 20th, 2023
- Protesters against judicial overhaul return to Israel's streets for the ... - Haaretz - August 20th, 2023
Comments