Hungary and Poland provide model for Israels assault on judiciary …
Posted By admin on April 16, 2023
At the height of the protests in Israel over Benjamin Netanyahus planned judicial changes early last month, a Polish minister gave a revealing radio interview in Warsaw.
Of course, we are talking with Israel, and to some extent we shared our experiences in this regard, said the deputy foreign minister, Pawe Jaboski, when asked for his views on the proposed Israeli laws.
Im telling the honest truth. Israel was interested in what was happening in Poland, he added.
The next day, Jaboski quickly walked back the comments, saying there had been no consultations with the Israeli side over the changes after all. But they were quickly seized on as a sign of something significant nonetheless.
Netanyahus assault on the judiciary reminds many of the first steps taken by illiberal governments in Hungary, Poland and elsewhere. Legal experts say targeting the judiciary is the natural first step for modern would-be autocrats who want to dismantle the broader democratic framework.
If you want to conduct a modern coup detat you no longer need to employ serious force and to kill people, you dont need the army and blood in the streets. The first institution to destroy is the judiciary. Everything else can come afterwards, said Eli Salzberger, the director of the Minerva Center for the Rule of Law under Extreme Conditions at the University of Haifa.
When Viktor Orbn was elected prime minister in Hungary in 2010, he quickly enacted a constitutional amendment to change the nomination and election procedure for constitutional court judges, as well as changing the number of judges on the court from 11 to 15.
Orbn is still in power, and in the intervening years has moved to dismantle much of Hungarys free media and make numerous other changes with the result that last year a group of European parliament members declared the country is no longer a full democracy.
This playbook was written in Budapest back in 2010, and later used by the Poles, by [President] Sisi in Egypt and others, said Gbor Halmai of the European University Institute in Florence.
Halmai noted that Israel and Hungary have no second chamber of parliament and no strong president who can act as a check to the executive, which makes the highest courts even more important.
The anger in response to the proposed changes in Israel has been much more coordinated than it was in Hungary or Poland, however.
We were much more prepared than the Hungarian and Polish civil society. Israel had a flawed democracy but a democracy for 75 years, said Salzberger.
Unlike in Hungary and Poland, where with a few exceptions the ruling parties have been able to ensure broad loyalty in the ranks, the protests in Israel include a lot of former ruling party Likud appointees and others who might have once been seen as loyal.
There is also a sense that the examples of Hungary and Poland have served as a warning of where the country might be heading. Parts of the crowd at the protest were chanting: Israel is not Hungary, Israel is not Poland, according to one Polish television correspondent attending the demonstrations in Tel Aviv.
The people in Poland and Hungary who were saying some years ago that this will go much further and have an impact on fundamental rights were considered to be fearmongers who were not giving the benefit of the doubt to these governments, said Anna Wjcik, a Polish legal scholar.
Israelis already know what has happened in other backsliding democracies its such a big theme already, she added.
Hungary and Poland are both EU members and the bloc has struggled to formulate a strategy for how to deal with democratic backsliding in the countries. Israel has no such body to answer to, but has faced stern criticism from its main economic and military partner in Washington.
Netanyahu totally underestimated the American response, said Salzberger. It has led to many, including people from his own party, realising something is wrong with his ability to see three or four moves ahead.
Alarmed by the strength of protest feeling, Netanyahu has promised to pause for consultations and put the changes on hold. Observers said, however, that a frequent tactic in Hungary and Poland was to present something outlandish, then water it down and portray it as a compromise solution after the fuss had died down.
Maybe what the Polish and Hungarian experiences teach others is that its important to hold out. Weather the first protests, find a different way to propose something less scary, and mould it all so its very difficult even for experts in the field to follow because its so complicated, said Wjcik.
Read more:
Hungary and Poland provide model for Israels assault on judiciary ...
- Saudi delegation to visit West Bank this week as Israel normalization talk increases - The Times of Israel - September 26th, 2023
- Israel Transferred Tens of Thousands of Shekels to Eritrean ... - Haaretz - September 26th, 2023
- Israel | General Assembly - General Assembly of the United Nations General Debate - September 26th, 2023
- Israel arrests 8 Palestinian students suspected of planning terror attack - The Times of Israel - September 26th, 2023
- Ghosts of the past: For Israel, war on UNESCO is an existential battle - Middle East Monitor - September 26th, 2023
- Israel's New Swedish Friends Are the Wrong Crowd - Opinion - Haaretz - September 26th, 2023
- Lebanon, Israel troops fire tear gas along tense border in a disputed area - Al Jazeera English - September 26th, 2023
- UK and Israel: Has the fightback against weaponised antisemitism ... - Middle East Eye - September 26th, 2023
- On Yom Kippur, Facing the Question: Where Is Israel Headed ... - Haaretz - September 26th, 2023
- 50 years after the Yom Kippur War, veterans see echoes in Israels current crisis - The Times of Israel - September 26th, 2023
- Iran claims: We have missiles that can hit Israel - Arutz Sheva - September 26th, 2023
- Israel's Covert War on Iran's Nuclear Program Is Impressive. But Is It ... - Mosaic - September 26th, 2023
- 'Can India's diplomatic spat with Canada be its Israel moment?' - Times of India - September 26th, 2023
- Peace and good neighborliness: Israel congratulates Saudis on their National Day - The Times of Israel - September 26th, 2023
- Everything We Know About Israel's New Robotic Drone Tank (And ... - SlashGear - September 26th, 2023
- Israels Cyberstarts closes $480m fund for cybersecurity investments - The Times of Israel - September 26th, 2023
- Israel is cursed from within, but it could be turned into a blessing - The Jerusalem Post - September 26th, 2023
- An economic corridor, the Israel link and the geopolitics - The Hindu - September 26th, 2023
- Israel and US conduct joint training on air defenses - The Jerusalem Post - September 26th, 2023
- Rare 3800-year-old passageway and vault found in northern Israel - The Jerusalem Post - September 26th, 2023
- Iran unveils longest-range drone in the world, threatens Israel at military parade - The Times of Israel - September 26th, 2023
- Canadas parliament, Trudeau and Zelensky give inadvertent ovation to Nazi war veteran - The Times of Israel - September 26th, 2023
- Israel Premier Tech wrap up successful week at the Tour de ... - Israel - Premier Tech - September 26th, 2023
- "Israel and Turkey are leading the Middle East gaming industry" - CTech - September 14th, 2023
- Smoking Rooms to Return to Israel's International Airport, Bucking ... - Haaretz - September 14th, 2023
- Rifts in Israel's coalition as Ben-Gvir withholds support - The New Arab - September 14th, 2023
- Home - Israel | The Netherlands and Israel - The Netherlands and You - September 14th, 2023
- Noa's Arc: How Noa Tishby went from actress to Israel activist - The Jewish Chronicle - September 14th, 2023
- Moody's likely won't lower Israel's credit rating but outlook could ... - Ynetnews - September 14th, 2023
- Turkey frees Israeli held over ornamental bell it claimed was artifact - The Times of Israel - September 14th, 2023
- Congregation Beth Israel to Host 'Rosh Hashanah in the Park' - http://www.we-ha.com - September 14th, 2023
- US should help win the freedom of Israeli scholar missing in Iraq, her sister says - The Times of Israel - September 14th, 2023
- Foreign Secretary travels to Israel and the Occupied Palestinian ... - GOV.UK - September 14th, 2023
- Israel says it will reopen the main cargo crossing to Gaza on Sunday, a relief for Gazan producers - ABC News - September 14th, 2023
- Mossad chief vows to target Irans highest echelon if Israelis, Jews hurt in terror - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- Israeli delegation makes first open visit to Saudi Arabia - FRANCE 24 English - September 12th, 2023
- Israel expects 30% of cars on its roads to be electric by 2030 - Reuters.com - September 12th, 2023
- We must reshape the Israel conversation on campus - opinion - The Jerusalem Post - September 12th, 2023
- Israel on edge as Supreme Court convenes for historic, crucial overhaul hearing - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- Leading protester in Israel speaks to CNN ahead of Supreme Court hearing - CNN - September 12th, 2023
- UK foreign secretary in Israel to talk Iran threats, Palestinian state - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- American Rabbis, Tell Your Congregants: The Israel You Knew Is a ... - Haaretz - September 12th, 2023
- Why Barcelona reversed its decision to cut ties with Israel - The New Arab - September 12th, 2023
- Israel ties Romania 1-1 as they fight to qualify for 2024 Euro soccer tourney - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- Earthquake preparedness exercise in northern Israel - Arutz Sheva - September 12th, 2023
- Here's What I Learned on My Trip to Israel | White Coat Investor - The White Coat Investor - September 12th, 2023
- 'It's Hard to Consider Abandoning Israel. But Leaving Is the Only ... - Haaretz - September 12th, 2023
- Israel imposing apartheid on Palestinians, says former Mossad chief - The Guardian - September 12th, 2023
- Four 1,900-year-old Roman swords found in cave in Israel - CNN - September 12th, 2023
- Citing God of Israel, Papua New Guinea becomes 5th nation to open Jerusalem embassy - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- US said to transfer armored vehicles, weapons to PA to clamp down on West Bank terror - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- Israel preparing to send search and rescue mission, assistance to quake-hit Morocco - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- NYC exhibit shows Israeli Hebrew didnt kill Yiddish, it gave it a new nest to live in - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- Rahat man suspected of killing wife, turning gun on self - The Times of Israel - September 12th, 2023
- Israel's toxic harvest in Africa - The Africa Report - September 12th, 2023
- Iran and Israel find common purpose: The subjugation of women - The Hill - August 28th, 2023
- Israel's foreign minister meets with Libyan counterpart in sign of ... - POLITICO - August 28th, 2023
- Imagine Dragons warmup band AJR tours Israel ahead of Tuesday show - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- Palestinian Mother Deported to Gaza After 30 Years in Israel ... - Haaretz - August 28th, 2023
- Citing Israeli example, Zelensky says Ukrainians need to learn to live with conflict - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- Israel says it foiled bid to smuggle Iran-made explosives over Jordan border - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- The politics of visiting Israel aren't stuck in the '90s - City & State - August 28th, 2023
- Israel's Dead End: We Don't Have the Luxury of Despair - Opinion - Haaretz - August 28th, 2023
- Israels cost of living the highest among OECD countries in 2022, data shows - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- In Israel, Adams Has Swagger in His Step and 'Hustle' on His Sleeve - The New York Times - August 28th, 2023
- A minister who hates Arabs will protect Arab children?: 100k at Tel Aviv protests - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- Israel uncovers massive section of Second Temple-era Jerusalem ... - The Jerusalem Post - August 28th, 2023
- One Voyage That Changed the Face of Jewish Culture in Israel ... - Haaretz - August 28th, 2023
- Inside the negotiations over Israels democracy - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- Vivek Ramaswamy Touched the Third Rail on Israel. He's Surely ... - Vanity Fair - August 28th, 2023
- Arab Israeli activist says he was assaulted at UAE airport over pro-Israel advocacy - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- Tantleff, Berkey and Hutter family to be honored by Israel Bonds at ... - ROI-NJ.com - August 28th, 2023
- Israel should build closer ties with Uganda - opinion - The Jerusalem Post - August 28th, 2023
- Israels Marhu Teferi wins silver in mens marathon at World Athletics Championships - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- 4 Palestinians attack army post near Jenin, are shot by troops - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- Israel Airports Authority: Serious delays in flights to and from UK - The Times of Israel - August 28th, 2023
- Libyans burn tyres in protest over Israel meeting video - The Guardian - August 28th, 2023
- Bringing Sundays to Israel: Is it time for the workweek to change? - The Jerusalem Post - August 28th, 2023
- Iran unveils armed drone resembling America's MQ-9 Reaper and says it could potentially reach Israel - The Associated Press - August 22nd, 2023
- Analysis | A Saudi-Israeli Peace Deal? Who Wants What and Why - The Washington Post - August 22nd, 2023
Comments