Why a new program aiming to fight anti-Zionism among Reform Jews is bound to fail – Mondoweiss
Posted By admin on October 19, 2022
For years, the once and possibly future Prime Minister of Israel, Benjamin Netanyahu, pursued a strategy of focusing on the right wing in Israel, around the world, and in the global Jewish community. His deep ties to the Republican party in the U.S. and his cozy relationship with figures as far right as Viktor Orban in Hungary led him to abandon Israels traditional strategy of maintaining broad support across the political spectrum.
So when Yair Lapid took power, Mainstream Democrats, who were desperately trying to maintain their lock-step and uncritical support for Israel even while the apartheid nature of Israels regime was becoming ever more apparent, were energized. They now no longer had to contend with an Israeli leader trying to undermine them domestically and it is no coincidence that, since Lapid ascended to power, the pro-Israel right wing of the Democratic Party has become increasingly assertive and groups like AIPAC have redoubled efforts to purge the party of pro-Israel liberals such as Andy Levin and discredit more vocal critics such as Rashida Tlaib and Bernie Sanders.
This dynamic has also inspired pro-Israel liberals to redouble their efforts to combat anti-Zionism in the Jewish community. One such effort is taking place in New York City, at the Stephen Wise Free Synagogue. There, Rabbi Ammiel Hirsch has launched a program called Amplify Israel. Heres how their web site describes the program: As American liberalism has become increasingly hostile to Jewish values and as anti-Israel animosity intensifies, Stephen Wise Free Synagogue has created an education and advocacy initiative aimed at healing the fractured relationship between American liberal Jews and Israel.
That description alone betrays a distorted view of why Israels image among American liberals has taken such a hit. It is certainly not the case that American liberalism has changed; it remains resistant to fundamental change, as is evidenced by its rush to elect Joe Biden, a man who promised that nothing would fundamentally change under his watch after the radical lurch rightward represented by Donald Trump.
No, what has changed is that Israel has become so brazen about its apartheid policies that more people realize how it maintains its iron-fisted control over millions of Palestinians, how it has dispossessed them for over 74 years, and how it has denied them the most basic rights for the past 55 years. More American liberals have seen the rampaging settlers, the violent soldiers, the closures, the killings of journalists and children, the strangulation of Gaza, and the many other crimes of Israeli apartheid. For all of Israels charges of antisemitism, there are many liberal Americans, and specifically American Jews, who know that Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and BTselem are not antisemitic, and when they find out that those groups are confirming what Palestinians have been saying for decades, are finding supporting such a regime impossible to reconcile with their values.
Hirsch understands this. He told The Times of Israel, The [Reform Jewish] movement is drifting in terms of how it speaks, what it speaks about, what it says and avoids saying. Its drifting from the centrality of the Jewish people and our Zionist principles. Were that to happen it would be catastrophic.
Theres a great deal to unpack in those words.
First, Hirsch is, understandably, overstating the case. Support for Israel, despite its apartheid policies, remains high among Reform Jews. 58% of Reform Jews say they are emotionally attached to Israel, which is exactly the same percentage as among Jews overall, according to a 2021 Pew Research poll. Another Reform and passionately pro-Israel rabbi, Rick Jacobs, said of the poll, I believe the big takeaway is that liberal Jews dont care less but rather care differently about Israel
By contrast to Hirsch, Jacobs is understating the reality; its certainly true that 58% represents a significant decline from the past. A 2016 poll of Reform Jews showed about 70% expressed an attachment to Israel, so there has been a notable decline in a relatively short time, even granting that these polls can be fuzzy.
But the issue of the centrality of the Jewish people and our Zionist principles is a stark example of historical revisionism. The dynamic of mythology distorting history and projecting a nationalist interpretation of a groups history back to the earliest days of that people is typical of nationalism, not at all unique to Zionism. But that historical revisionism has been a powerful force, in Jewish perceptions of our own history, and in the politics of Zionism as a force among Jews and against Palestinians.
Zionism is a modern, nationalist movement, one that quickly took on a settler-colonial character. It is not an ancient tenet of Judaism, something that is clear from any reading of Jewish history before World War II and from the fact that Zionists were a distinct minority among Jews before the Holocaust. This is a fact that is well known, most recently recounted again by Zachary Lockman, professor of Middle East Studies and History at New York University.
Indeed, even the constitution, in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, of Jews as a modern nation didnt depend on Zionism. Other Jewish nationalists, who did not tie their sense of Jewish nationhood to Palestine, were largely wiped out by the Nazis, such as the General Union of Jewish Workers, referred to often as The Bund, a class conscious, egalitarian, socialist Jewish movement that was quite popular among Eastern European Jews. Zionism has largely smothered the memory of the Bund and other, smaller, Jewish collective movements that were not interested in dispossessing another people and taking their land.
Rabbi Tracy Kaplowitz is heading up the effort to actualize the Amplify Israel program, and she makes little effort to hide the McCarthyist agenda at the root of it. The purpose is to ensure that our teens, long before they head off to college, have the language that they need to understand Israel, Kaplowitz told The Times of Israel. They can assess what they hear about Israel or even the ability to advocate and to say, The way youre presenting Israel to me seems inaccurate, its maybe bordering the line of antisemitism.
Its not hard to imagine what Kaplowitz means by understanding Israel. Given the ongoing and increasingly hostile debates on college campuses, this is about equipping new students with the requisite talking points on Israel. But more important is the clear intention to steer them toward specious and false accusations of antisemitism. As has been frequently noted, its really all Israel advocates have left.
The effort to turn the tide on liberal support for Israel is getting increasingly desperate, especially now that it appears more likely than not that Netanyahu will be returning as Israels prime minister in the upcoming election. Weve seen the large-scale, public efforts directed against politicians like Rashida Tlaib and media personalities like Katie Halper. Were likely to see more localized efforts like Amplify Israel as well.
But Hirsch himself ultimately explains the futility of the effort. Zionism is a liberal movement. Its about the self-determination of an oppressed people, he claims. Liberals support self-determination and freedom and libertyWe support coexistence. We do not support, when two peoples are in conflict, dismantling one of them. That is not liberal, thats reactionary.
Its this formulationone that tries to paint support for apartheid as liberal by omitting the massive crimes committed historically and on an ongoing basis against the Palestinians, individually and collectivelythat explains why liberal Jews are joining their more radical fellows in opposing Israeli apartheid.
Because Zionism is not a liberal movement. While a small minority of its earliest thinkersnone of whom supported Political Zionismmight not have wanted to see the imposition of a Jewish state that dispossessed, displaced, and discriminated against the existing Palestinian population, that has never been Zionisms political expression. It was intentionally designed to replace that Palestinian population.
Its easy to say you support coexistence when the form and function of that coexistence dictates that your group holds a superior position, whether through elevation by law, enforced and manipulated demographics, or, in this case, both.
The movement for Palestinian rights, which by definition must point out not only Israels crimes but the apartheid nature of the state that makes such crimes inevitable, demands equal rights for all. Hirsch defines that as dismantling not just Israel but Jews as a nation. That, my dear rabbi, is reactionary and deeply illiberal, not a call for equality.
BEFORE YOU GO: The Israeli government and its economic, cultural, and political backers here in the U.S. have made a decades-long investment in silencing and delegitimizing Palestinian voices and those who dare to call out Israels apartheid.
The movement needs independent media outlets that amplify Palestinian stories and hold space for those censored for voicing dissent.
We have revolutionized Mondoweiss coverage of Palestine and Israel by building a Palestine newsroom, thus helping to shape the American understanding of the Palestinian struggle.
Become a donor today and support our critical work.
Original post:
Why a new program aiming to fight anti-Zionism among Reform Jews is bound to fail - Mondoweiss
- Freehold Jewish Center - Wikipedia - May 29th, 2023
- Police: Michigan woman wanted to blame synagogue vandalism on Azov Regiment - UpNorthLive.com - May 29th, 2023
- Jury selection concludes in trial for Pittsburgh synagogue shooter who killed 11 - Fox News - May 29th, 2023
- Graphic crime scene and autopsy images will be part of synagogue ... - thejewishchronicle.net - May 29th, 2023
- Boston Synagogue to Host Boston's West End Lyric's 'The Joys of ... - OperaWire - May 29th, 2023
- Terrorist With A Knife Neutralized Near Synagogue In West Bank ... - i24NEWS - May 29th, 2023
- 22-year-old jailed for attempted arson attack on German synagogue - The Times of Israel - May 26th, 2023
- Jury selection wraps in Pittsburgh synagogue massacre with testimony expected Tuesday - ABC News - May 26th, 2023
- IDF: Palestinian killed after infiltrating West Bank settlement synagogue with knife - The Times of Israel - May 26th, 2023
- SYNAGOGUE - JewishEncyclopedia.com - May 24th, 2023
- Lit Explosive Tossed From Pickup Truck Near Synagogue - Newsweek - May 24th, 2023
- Shavuot: When Children Take Their Parents to Synagogue - Impact of Chabad Hebrew schools felt deeply at reading of ... - Chabad.org - May 24th, 2023
- Light unto the nations: How Kherson's synagogue became a massive outreach center - Ynetnews - May 24th, 2023
- Sim Shalom Online Synagogue Soars into the Summer with ... - Benzinga - May 24th, 2023
- Homepage | Park Avenue Synagogue - May 22nd, 2023
- Cherry Hill rabbi donates Torah to new synagogue in Idaho - CBS News - May 22nd, 2023
- Park East Synagogue is still searching for its next leader as another assistant rabbi exits - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - May 20th, 2023
- Synagogue massacre trial expected to start May 30 | The Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle - thejewishchronicle.net - May 20th, 2023
- Campaign to give Sons of Jacob Synagogue a fresh look - My North Bay Now - May 20th, 2023
- Sacred Art: The Hope of History at Dohny Street Synagogue - MutualArt.com - May 20th, 2023
- Revelers outside Jerusalem's Great Synagogue say they 'came to ... - The Times of Israel - May 20th, 2023
- Synagogues In Orlando | Jewish Family Community Center | Ohev Shalom ... - May 17th, 2023
- Meet our Clergy - Congregation of Reform Judaism - May 17th, 2023
- London synagogue catches heat for lighting indoor Lag BOmer bonfire - The Times of Israel - May 17th, 2023
- Jury selection in Tree of Life Pittsburgh synagogue shooting trial advances - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette - May 17th, 2023
- Ivanka Trump and her family were spotted going to synagogue - HOLA! USA - May 17th, 2023
- Wenatchee synagogue vandalized with swastikas | News ... - wenatcheeworld.com - May 17th, 2023
- Warsaw's Great Synagogue destroyed 80 years ago today The ... - The First News - May 17th, 2023
- Pittsburgh Jewish community tracks jump in hate speech amid synagogue massacre trial - The Times of Israel - May 13th, 2023
- Voice for Jewish community reflects on first week of jury selection in synagogue shooting trial - CBS News - April 29th, 2023
- Potential jurors' stance on death penalty gauged as jury selection in synagogue shooting trial continues - WTAE Pittsburgh - April 27th, 2023
- Pittsburgh Jews keep defying hate as synagogue trial nears - The Hill - April 22nd, 2023
- Capitol Hill synagogue vandalized on eve of Holocaust Remembrance Day - The Seattle Times - April 20th, 2023
- This gay Orthodox Jew was banned from his synagogue. Now hes fighting back. - Forward - April 20th, 2023
- Teen accused of posting bomb threat targeting Forsyth County synagogue, deputies say - WSB Atlanta - April 20th, 2023
- The Synagogue | The Pluralism Project - March 10th, 2023
- Jessica Seinfeld Calls For Non-Jews To Join Friends At Synagogue Tomorrow For Shabbat To Counter Day Of Hate With Love And Light - Deadline - February 27th, 2023
- Synagogue Facts & Features | What is a Synagogue? | Study.com - February 19th, 2023
- Arab worlds 1st purpose-built synagogue in century opens at UAE interfaith center - The Times of Israel - February 17th, 2023
- What Is the Purpose of the Synagogue? | Reform Judaism - February 16th, 2023
- Ancient Synagogues in Israel and the Diaspora - February 2nd, 2023
- Park Synagogue, Cory United to hold MLK Jr. Day commemoration - Cleveland Jewish News - January 6th, 2023
- Ice Cream Factory, The Court Hotel and The Old Synagogue set for thrilling New Years Eve celebrations - PerthNow - December 21st, 2022
- NJ Synagogue Threat: FBI Says Credible Information Developed NBC New York - December 11th, 2022
- Video shows man making bigoted remarks at Bloomfield Twp. synagogue - Detroit Free Press - December 11th, 2022
- Two men, one a descendant of Holocaust survivor, indicted in connection with threat to attack NYC synagogue - CNN - December 11th, 2022
- Michigan man charged after threatening synagogue-goers yelled antisemitic invective during arraignment - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - December 7th, 2022
- AA Synagogue - November 24th, 2022
- How One Jewish Groups Tweet Surveillance Uncovered a Synagogue Plot - The New York Times - November 24th, 2022
- Tree of Life - November 21st, 2022
- Jewish Community Security Organization in UK Says It Discovered N.Y. Synagogue Threats - HS Today - HSToday - November 21st, 2022
- Welcome to Edgware United Synagogue - November 16th, 2022
- New Jersey man accused of sending online threats to attack a synagogue and Jewish people, federal prosecutor says - CNN - November 11th, 2022
- I Let My Son Be an Extra on Maisel on the Holiest Day of the Jewish Year - Kveller.com - October 19th, 2022
- Reeling from the loss of her mom, this rabbi created an online community for healing - St. Louis Jewish Light - October 19th, 2022
- Slovak Who Attacked Gay Bar Credits Buffalo Shooter with Giving Him 'Final Nudge' - HS Today - HSToday - October 19th, 2022
- OPINION: Let's make this the year we end paid High Holiday tickets J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - October 15th, 2022
- Churches need to see more of the faithful - liherald.com - October 15th, 2022
- Jewish Community of Sedona and the Verde Valley: October 14-20, 2022 - Sedona.biz - October 15th, 2022
- Why Conspiracy Theorists Always Land on the Jews - The Atlantic - October 15th, 2022
- Religion: Clergy strive to reconcile politically divided congregations | Journal-Courier - Jacksonville Journal-Courier - October 8th, 2022
- Huntsville's Temple B'nai Sholom encourages the community to visit the historic synagogue - WZDX - September 29th, 2022
- The synagogue is in the street: On Yom Kippur, Tel Aviv shows another side of itself - Forward - September 29th, 2022
- A Long Island synagogues renovations uncover a massive work of art - Forward - September 29th, 2022
- Synagogues exit pandemic with reflection, determination and hope for the future - Ynetnews - September 29th, 2022
- For the Sin We Have Sinned by Making People Feel Unwelcome at Synagogues - Jewish Exponent - September 29th, 2022
- The tragedy of Jews who can't stand with Israel - JNS.org - September 29th, 2022
- Fellowship in Their Golden Years - International Fellowship of Christians and Jews - September 29th, 2022
- Aurora rabbi joins other faith leaders in call for peace and progress - Daily Herald - September 29th, 2022
- Worshiper stabbed to death outside Dimona synagogue after asking suspect to be quiet - The Times of Israel - September 27th, 2022
- Paxton Works to Safeguard First Amendment Protections for Religious Group Facing Illegal Discrimination - Texas Attorney General (.gov) - September 27th, 2022
- Date, fast times, meaning behind Yom Kippur and what celebrations involve - iNews - September 27th, 2022
- Finding Refuge from War and Persecution in Connecticut's Quiet Corner - UConn Today - University of Connecticut - September 27th, 2022
- 'Sense of accomplishment': Synagogue recruits 163 Torah readers from one Rosh Hashanah to another - Daily Herald - September 25th, 2022
- So, whats up with all that kissing in synagogue? (No, not the people the Torah!) - Forward - September 25th, 2022
- The Top 10 Secrets of the Eldridge Street Synagogue and Museum in NYC - Untapped New York - September 25th, 2022
- Police increase patrols at Long Island synagogues, temples ahead of High Holy Days - CBS New York - September 25th, 2022
- Pandemic's aftermath and economic crisis have some synagogues rethinking their membership fees - eJewish Philanthropy - September 25th, 2022
- 'Exactly the spiritual leader that we wanted': Rabbi Meeka Simerly to lead her first Rosh Hashana at Havre de Grace's Temple Adas Shalom - Baltimore... - September 25th, 2022
- After 30 years, Or Shalom of S.F. finally has a home of its own J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - September 25th, 2022
Comments