What Really Was the Sin of Sodom and Gomorrah? – Getting down to the core of evil – Chabad.org

Posted By on November 18, 2019

Joe the Sodomite

Sodom and Gomorrah have come to represent the epitome of evil. After all, Gd destroyed them with fire and brimstone. But, perhaps surprisingly, the Talmud does not associate Sodom principally with idolatry, murder, sexual impropriety, thievery or even corrupt business practices.

The Talmud uses term midat Sdom (roughly translated as a Sodomite attitude) to describe the person who cannot bear someone else benefiting from his property, even when it doesnt hurt him in the slightest.

Heres a classic example mentioned the Talmud:

Joe owns a large tract of land that is not in use and that he doesnt wish to lease, and discovers that some homeless individual is camping out on it. So he tells him to get off. We say to him, The other guy gains and you lose nothing, so whats your problem? And Joe answers, Its my property. I want him out.

Joe is infected with a Sodomite attitude. The Talmud even discusses whether the homeless camper can ask the court to prevent Joe from throwing him outbecause the Torah says, You must do that which is good and upright. What Joe is doing, from Talmudic eyes, is pure evil.

The final judgment is that we cant legally compel Joe in this case, since that would be limiting the statutes of property ownership. But there are cases in which property ownership is not diminished and no significant inconvenience is caused. In such instances, the court can indeed compel or restrain someone with a stubborn Sodomite attitude.

Theres another description in the Talmud of the Sodomite attitude: One who says, Whats mine is mine and whats yours is yours. Or, as Rabbi Obadiah Bartenura reads that, I dont want to give you anything, and I would appreciate if you dont give me anything.

Okay, so hes not the kind of guy you want on your baseball team, but is he really the core of evil? He hasnt ripped anyone off. He hasnt lied to anyone. In fact, hesTurns out that worse than running a corrupt business is having no business at all. brutally honest. He tells you his approach to life and sticks to it. Hes not running a corrupt business. He doesnt want to engage in any commerce at all. He desires total independence and isolation. He says, Let me be and Ill let you be.

Turns out that worse than running a corrupt business is having no business at all. But why is that?

A pinch of Lurianic Kabbalah could help us here. When the world was created, as Genesis says, it was at first tohu. Tohu, explains Rabbi Isaac Luria, is a state of isolated ideals.

A world of tohu is a world where no two things can work together. A world where the weather is either hot or cold but never warm, where people are either super-friendly or hostile but never just chill, where either I run things or you run things but we cant cooperate, where I dont need you and you dont need me and so no one has any business with the other.

Gd was not pleased with that world. But that was okay, because it rapidly erupted all on its own. Fragments of it fell and reorganized to become our world, a world where harmony, or tikun, is possible.

Now for some words from a more recent kabbalist and chassidic master, Rabbi Sholom Dovber of Lubavitch, writing in 1914:

The souls of the people of Sodom originated from the realm of Tohu. That explains why they were isolationistsneither wishing to benefit anyone nor to receive from The souls of the people of Sodom originated from the realm of Tohu.one anyone. In this way, their land was isolated from all other lands and they managed their own resources so that they didn't need to receive any goods from any foreign land. Even amongst themselves, each one was isolated and independent.

But when Gd made the earth, He did so with wisdom, so that all the world functions in a way of tikunthe diametric opposite of Sodom's isolationism. The world is made so that each region must receive its needs from some other region. Indeed, that is what trade is all aboutthat each land both receives from others and gives to others.

This is the meaning of the verse, "And He established His agudah upon the earth." An agudah is a collaboration of individuals, such as a collective, in which everyone works together and no one is complete without the other. This is how Gd created the world to operate.

But Sodom did not operate that way. No one would accept anything from anyone else. They said, Whats mine is mine and whats yours is yours.

How do we see that among the people of Sodom? Well, they werent hospitable. Not only did they not take in guests, they couldnt even allow others to have guests stay in their home. Thats the central point of the story with Lot, Abrahams nephew who lived in Sodom. When Lot, had some guests in his home, the people of Sodom staged a protest outside his door and threatened to harm the guests and their host.

The Talmud tells more stories about the people of Sodom and their nasty, even brutal treatment of visitors. You can read some of them here.

How did Sodom get this way? The Talmud explains that as well.

You see, Sodom, Gomorrah along with three other cities formed a large settlement at the terminus of the Jordan River. Its a deep valley and before these cities were overturned the Jordan branched out into a delta, watering the earth well and sprouting rich, lush greenery. The earth was rich in nutrients, as well as precious minerals. All in all, a virtual garden of Eden.

So the people who settled there decided, We dont need to trade with anyone. We have everything we need right here. And we dont want them coming here, either. Why should we share any of this with anyone else?

Next thing, they constructed a bridge at the gateway to their land and charged a toll to entereven if you would choose to swim across. They established laws prejudiced against visitors and found every way they could to discourage any passerby.

Things only got worse from there, until there was no friendship, no It all began with a need not to need anyone.camaraderie even amongst each other. Eventually, the peoples treatment of merchants, transients, the homeless, the downtrodden and the needy became heartless and viciously cruel.

And so the prophet Yechezkel (Ezekiel) describes the sin of Sodom as arrogance, saying She and her daughters had plenty of bread and untroubled tranquillity; yet she did not support the poor and the needy.

Certainly there were many detestable sins in Sodom and her daughter cities. But it all began with a need not to need anyone.

What we learn from the story of Sodom is that commerce is good. Just the fact that one person sold and the other bought is good. Because people needing people is good. Being insufficient is good. Good for the world, good for the community and good for the individual.

Self-sufficiency, on the other hand, is a bad deal all around. We all say we want to be perfectly self-sufficient, but deep down we recognize that would be a nightmare.

Ultimately, its our interpersonal needs and the commerce between us that bind all of humanity together as a single, healthy organism. Whats a healthy organism? A counter-entropic entity united by circulation of energy. And that is what makes a healthy human world as well: A world where people add value to life by discovering how much they need one another.

The ancient Midrash describes King David asking of Gd, Why couldnt You make everyone in Your world equal in means?

Gd replied, If I would do so, how would kindness and truth be sustained?

When someone wrote to the Rebbe, Rabbi Menachem M. Schneerson of righteous memory, that the final redemption cannot be complete until the needy disappear from the earth, the Rebbe responded that he did not concur. People must always need one another. There will always be poverty and inequality. Not poverty of basic meanswe will live in a prosperous world where delicacies will be as plentiful as the dust. Rather, there will always be a healthy imbalance of commodities that will require commerce for redistribution.

One person may be richly steeped in abstract knowledge but poor in application, while another does not fair well in abstractions but has a knack for putting ideas to work. One has water while the other has bread. One has a fire inside him while the other stays cool. All have in common one thing: They all need one another for their own wholeness.

And it must be that way because every person, every created being, indeed even the Creator and Manager of the universe at times in some way must act not only as a provider but also as a recipient. Neither role is less important than the other. Its that dynamic that makes a beautiful world.

Perhaps it was the Talmudic take on Sodom that inspired David Ricardo, the great Jewish economist, to come up with his highly influential theory of competitive advantage which explains why specializing and trading is beneficial not only for individuals but for nations as well.

People need to need each other, not only in commerce, Make yourself a person who is needed and you will acquire at least one true friend.but in every aspect of life. Thats perhaps the most ignored but vital need of the human being: the need to be needed. Yet deeperand even more vitalthe need to need others.

Acquire yourself a friend! our sages taught. People ask, Why use the word acquire? That makes it sound like you have to buy friends. Why not just make friends?

But now it makes sense. People are friends and stay friends because they need one another. Even with all the love in the world, they are only truly bonded when they find a need for one another in their hearts. Make yourself a person who is needed and you will acquire at least one true friend.

And allow yourself to need that friend. Really need.

Read more:

What Really Was the Sin of Sodom and Gomorrah? - Getting down to the core of evil - Chabad.org

Related Post

Comments

Comments are closed.