You Take Christmas, I’ll Take Hanukkah | Michael Harvey | The Blogs – The Times of Israel
Posted By admin on December 11, 2020
An unfortunate side-effect of Hanukkah approaching is the all too familiar flurry of posts by Christians on social media which include posting Hanukkah Menorahs with Christian messages, adding Yeshua and other messianic themes to Hanukkah items, and articles about why Christians should also celebrate the festival of lights. Regarding the latter, the most notable arguments from Christians is their idea of 400 years of silence, summed up perfectly by a tweet and blogpost authored by Michelle Van Loon:
Ive heard preachers say there were 400 years of silence between the last Old Testament prophet and the advent of Jesus as recorded in the N.T. gospels. Chanukah, which begins this Thursday at sundown, reminds us that this is stinkin thinkin.
Van Loon surmises, as do many Christians, that the salvation narrative is that and then there was 400 years of silence from God between the conclusion of the Old Testament prophet Malachis ministry until the birth of Jesus.
Van Loon argues that the silence was actually broken by the story of Hanukkah, within the books of Maccabees and discussed later in John10:22. However, Van Loon makes a critical error, as do any Christians that embrace this salvation narrative. The distinction between the Hebrew Bible (Tanakh) and Old Testament is paramount, and lost among far too many of our Christian colleagues. Straight to the point, Malachi is not the last book of the Hebrew Bible. Indeed, the final books of the Tanakh are 1st and 2nd Chronicles. When the Old Testament was translated from a Hebrew manuscript to Greek, the Church leaders rearranged the books of the Bible to fit their theological message, meaning that the prophets were moved to the end to create a smooth transition to their new prophet, Jesus. However, rearranging books does not change history. If we suppose that Malachi was written sometime in the 5th century BCE, and that Jesus was born in beginning of the 1st century CE, that does leave roughly 600 years of silence. Except, of course, that a great deal occurred between the 5th century BCE and the 1st century CE, including Ezra, Nehemiah, Esther, and Daniel, to name a few.
While it is also true that the books of Maccabees were written in between these years of silence, the book itself carries with it no stories of miracles, most notably the miracle of the oil lasting 8 days. The imagery of the Hanukkiah, the Hanukkah menorah, was invented by the sages of the Talmud, Shabbat 21b, as the story of Hanukkah within Maccabees (a book not included in the Hebrew Bible canon) was not Godly enough. One should then remember that the Talmud was deemed anti-Christian and burned by Christians after the 5th century. It seems questionable, then, why Christians would seek to embrace a story written in a book they condemn, in order to connect to a story about Jews fighting against assimilation.
In this holiday season when Christmas is all anyone can see, with Hanukkah nativity scenes, Hanukkah Christmas ornaments, messianic invasions and co-opting, it would be wonderful if Christians could focus on their holiday of joy, Christmas, rather than our minor holiday of Hanukkah. The story of the rebellion against the Seleucids and the victory of the Hasmoneans has nothing to do with Jesus, Christmas, or prophets. It is yet another story of Jews fighting off those who would seek to convert us. Unfortunately, the irony is lost upon the Christians who wish to take our side and find themselves in the story of the Maccabees, considering the first 1600 years of Christianitys existence was filled with genocide, torture, forced conversions, and exile for Jews.
For all these reasons, and more, I urge our Christian friends to just let Hanukkah be. You take Christmas, well take Hanukkah. Theres plenty of presents and food to go around.
Rabbi Michael Harvey was ordained by the Hebrew Union College Jewish Institute of Religion (HUC-JIR) in 2015, and earned a Masters degree in Hebrew Letters from Hebrew Union College Jewish Institute of Religion and a Bachelors degree in psychology from Boston University. Enrolled at Spertus Institute for Jewish Learning and Leadership, within the Doctor of Science in Jewish Studies program. Founder of "Teach Me Judaism": educational and animated Jewish lessons on scholarship: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC4vNAB0lVE4munW_znGdEtQ
Originally posted here:
You Take Christmas, I'll Take Hanukkah | Michael Harvey | The Blogs - The Times of Israel
- Is it kosher to smoke weed for Purim? - Forward - March 3rd, 2021
- New Haggadah brings big-screen superheroes to the Passover seder - Jewish Insider - March 3rd, 2021
- Your Shabbat table is magic. No, really. The rabbis said so. - The Jewish News of Northern California - March 3rd, 2021
- Jewish History Proves Jews Are Indigenous to Israel - Algemeiner - March 3rd, 2021
- The Jewish Education Night of Networking Yeshiva University News - Yu News - March 3rd, 2021
- Searching Jewish wisdom for guidance on vaccination | Ohr Chadash | stljewishlight.com - St. Louis Jewish Light - March 3rd, 2021
- Rabbi Megan Doherty on the Heartbeat Bill The Oberlin Review - The Oberlin Review - March 3rd, 2021
- Jonah Sanderson Successfully Navigates His Disability, Aims to Make Jewish Community More Inclusive - Jewish Journal - March 3rd, 2021
- Death Is Nothing to Celebrate - The Atlantic - February 23rd, 2021
- Leadership Lessons from Shushan | Charles E. Savenor | The Blogs - The Times of Israel - February 23rd, 2021
- Procrastination, Colors, And The IKEA Effect - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - February 21st, 2021
- CLERGY CORNER: Is there a blessing for the COVID-19 vaccine? - newportri.com - February 21st, 2021
- What kind of Jew are you? - comment - The Jerusalem Post - February 21st, 2021
- Commentary: Looking for 'blind spots' when it comes to race - Canton Repository - February 21st, 2021
- Time to shift attitude to one of belonging - Cleveland Jewish News - February 19th, 2021
- Adam Grant and The Case for Nuance in Jewish Education - Jewish Journal - February 19th, 2021
- A rabbis open letter to his haredi brethren - The Jerusalem Post - February 19th, 2021
- Terumah: Elevating our intentions - The Jewish Standard - February 19th, 2021
- Limmud AZ set for its first virtual event - Jewish News of Greater Phoenix - February 19th, 2021
- My son, Mohammed El Halabi, is innocent of funding Hamas - opinion - The Jerusalem Post - February 19th, 2021
- Yiddish professor goes viral in town hall with President Biden - Forward - February 19th, 2021
- The power and the mystery of the cherubim, explained J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - February 19th, 2021
- ASTROLOJEW Month of Adar: Milk the magic for all it's worth - The Jewish News of Northern California - February 19th, 2021
- At one JCC, new classes make it easy for adults with disabilities to tune in - Forward - February 19th, 2021
- Guest Opinion: America can heal when it works to become righteous - GoErie.com - February 16th, 2021
- Angry at discrimination, a rabbi creates a shul, and seminary, serving the Deaf community - Forward - February 16th, 2021
- Comments on: Drinking on Purim (or not)? Read This First - Jewish Journal - February 16th, 2021
- Parashat Mishpatim: The soul and the law - The Jerusalem Post - February 12th, 2021
- The Bigness of Little Things - Jewish Exponent - February 12th, 2021
- Parshat Mishpatim: Voices in the Gates - Jewish Week - February 12th, 2021
- Hershey Felder Creates a Grand Celebration of Sholem Aleichem and a Seductive Fiddler - WTTW News - February 12th, 2021
- PEARRELL: Stay true to the core of Christianity - Rockdale Newton Citizen - February 12th, 2021
- The Rebbe Everyone Is Talking About! - Yeshiva World News - February 12th, 2021
- Prince of the Torah - Arkansas Online - February 12th, 2021
- Soldiering on for the Jews and Israel - JNS.org - February 12th, 2021
- Israeli President Reuven Rivlin: In an era of divisons, Jews must emphasize our ties to one another - Forward - February 12th, 2021
- Karen Lewis and Rahm Emanuel: Rocky relationship started in one place and ended in another - Chicago Sun-Times - February 12th, 2021
- Chabad course explores life, death and the afterlife in the age of COVID-19 - The Columbus Dispatch - February 1st, 2021
- How did the letter ayin become a vowel in Yiddish? - Forward - February 1st, 2021
- The tragedy for haredim from COVID has created a crisis for Judaism itself - JNS.org - February 1st, 2021
- Rabbi Dr. Abraham J. Twerski, 90, Leading Authority on Substance Abuse - Author of more than 60 popular books and founder of Gateway Rehabilitation... - February 1st, 2021
- A Rabbi's Message on Coping With Covid | Jewish & Israel News Algemeiner.com - Algemeiner - February 1st, 2021
- New Class on the Jewish Perspective of the Afterlife Detroit Jewish News - The Jewish News - February 1st, 2021
- Youve probably never heard about the worlds first female rabbi. Sigal Samuel wants to change that - Forward - February 1st, 2021
- Free Will Astrology | Astrology - North Coast Journal - February 1st, 2021
- Worlds 1st female rabbi led a 16th century Mosul yeshiva for Kurdish Jewry - The Times of Israel - February 1st, 2021
- Andrew Yangs $1000-a-month stipend reminds me of a time-honored Jewish tradition - Forward - February 1st, 2021
- Tu B'Shvat connects us to the beautiful world outside - Jewish Community Voice - January 28th, 2021
- Rewinding Jimi Hendrixs National Anthem - The New Yorker - January 28th, 2021
- Individual Consciousness, Lengthy Biographies and Other Letters to the Editor - The New York Times - January 28th, 2021
- Israel's ultra-Orthodox and the future of the state - The Jerusalem Post - January 28th, 2021
- Parashat Bo: The Miracle of Mixed Multitudes - My Jewish Learning - January 28th, 2021
- 52 years ago, 9 Jews were hanged in Baghdad. Today, their descendants risk losing everything they left behind. - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - January 28th, 2021
- Is It Proper? Is it ever appropriate to get drunk? - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - January 28th, 2021
- Tu B'Shevat: An annual reminder to appreciate the beauty of the land of Israel - Jewish News of Greater Phoenix - January 28th, 2021
- Tu B'Shevat the original Arbor Day: And a recipe for fruitcake that will never get re-gifted - Worcester Telegram - January 28th, 2021
- Three Ladies, Three Lattes: Still coffee-ing after all these years - The Jerusalem Post - January 28th, 2021
- Live Intentionally This Shevat - Atlanta Jewish Times - January 28th, 2021
- Free Will Astrology: Week of January 28, 2021 - Newcity - January 28th, 2021
- JUF News | Jewish Women's Foundation allocates $413000 in grants supporting women and girls - Jewish United Fund - January 22nd, 2021
- Israel tops 4,000 coronavirus deaths since the start of the pandemic - The Jerusalem Post - January 22nd, 2021
- I resisted the call to include non-male voices every time I taught Torah. Then I tried it. - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - January 4th, 2021
- Law professor Ray Bernstein, 56, dies in bike accident - The Jewish News of Northern California - January 4th, 2021
- Let's head into the new year in a new frame of mind - The Jewish News of Northern California - January 4th, 2021
- The Purpose Of Chassidus In The Alter Rebbe's Own Words - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - January 4th, 2021
- Opinion/Keep the Faith: Hanukkah reminds us of light and hope, even in dark times - Worcester Telegram - December 19th, 2020
- Opinion: The true meaning of Hanukkah (hint, it's not about joy) - The Detroit News - December 19th, 2020
- Is the Temple Menorah Hidden in the Vatican? - Questions & Answers - Chabad.org - December 19th, 2020
- Circumcision, Berzerkeley, and the Power of Five Minutes - Chabad.org - December 19th, 2020
- He Flew in From London for Reasons He'd Never Imagined - Chabad.org - December 19th, 2020
- Rabbis and Jewish ethicists hail vaccine for COVID-19, encourage its use - Jewish News of Greater Phoenix - December 19th, 2020
- Why it's kosher to go a little wild with the Hanukkah swag - Los Angeles Times - December 16th, 2020
- Increasing the Light of Allyship This Hanukkah - Jewish Journal - December 16th, 2020
- Why it's kosher to bring a little zing to the Hanukkah celebration - Bangor Daily News - December 16th, 2020
- Is the Menorah Hidden in the Vatican? - Chabad.org - December 16th, 2020
- Community mourns the passing of former CJC president Goldie Hershon - The Suburban Newspaper - December 16th, 2020
- Perseverence Vs. Perfection - An Essay on Vayigash - Kabbalah, Chassidism and Jewish Mysticism - Chabad.org - December 16th, 2020
- The New Generation of LGBTQ Jews and Tattoos - jewishboston.com - December 16th, 2020
- Men have dominated Jewish texts for most of history. These women are trying to change that. - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - December 11th, 2020
- I knew Hanukkah celebrated defeating the Greeks. Then I moved to Athens and the story got complicated. - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - December 11th, 2020
Comments