Anti-Zionism Is Anti-Semitism – HuffPost
Posted By simmons on August 17, 2017
I spent the last week in Basel, Switzerland where in 1897 Theodor Herzl officially inaugurated the Zionist movement when he convened the First Zionist Congress. One of the first places I visited was the Three Kings Hotel. It was Herzls home while in Basel and I wanted to see the balcony from where he posed looking over the Rhine, ostensibly thinking about the millions of Jews suffering under pogroms in Europe and who would need the refuge he would describe in his manifesto, called (in German) Der Judenstaat or the Jewish State.
Herzls goal was unambiguous: it was to establish a Jewish state somewhere (the ancient Jewish homeland of Palestine, preferably, but elsewhere if Palestine was beyond reach) to which European Jews could escape to avoid the continuation or (as he correctly expected) the radical intensification of the physical attacks on Jews that was commonplace in Europe since the conversion of Europeans from paganism to Christianity. Although he could not have imagined the Holocaust, he anticipated it anyway.
His message to Jews was to get out of Europe before it was too late. But time ran out.
Of course, Herzls thesis was proven right. Had Jews managed to acquire a homeland in Palestine or East Africa or Latin America (the last two were Herzls proposed alternatives to Palestine), the slaughter of six million Jews might not have happened. But it did happen and the Jewish state of Israel was established as a response, in theory so it could never happen again.
Herzl never imagined the nakba (the displacement and expulsion of Palestinians) that occurred as a result of the Jews establishing their state in Palestine. Given his willingness to accept even a small part of Africa or Latin America as an alternative to Palestine, he never would have demanded for a Jewish state (he often spoke as a mere homeland in Palestine, not a state in all of it) as has been the goal of rightist Israeli prime ministers like Binyamin Netanyahu.
As for the transformation of Palestinians into second class citizens or occupied non-citizens, he was on record of favoring full equality as described in his futuristic novel Old New Land which envisioned a quasi-socialist homeland for all the people of Palestine. An assimilated and utterly non-religious Jew, he was appalled by Jewish exclusivity or claims to a special status as conferred by a God he did not believe in.
Herzl died in 1904 so he never saw the realization of his dream. Hence we have no way of knowing what he would think of Israel today. One thing that is clear: he would have opposed the occupation. He would have been so ecstatic that Israel existed within what we now call the pre-67 lines that he would have been repelled at the idea of jeopardizing that state in favor of pursuing some divinely inspired manifest destiny in the West Bank. Again, he was an assimilated non- (even anti-) religious Jew. He would cherish Tel Aviv and secular Israel, not Arab-inhabited West Bank lands because Jews walked there 3000 years ago. He wanted a refuge for Jews, not some place to worship rocks and ruins.
Zionism is not about holding the West Bank and Arab East Jerusalem even if Netanyahu and the Israel lobby here want it to be. It is about Jews having sovereignty in a parcel of land where they can live in security and to which they can welcome future Jewish refugees if worst comes to worst again, an eventuality not hard to imagine in the era of Trump and the alt-right.
To argue that Jews are not entitled to that right is anti-semitic.
After all, why (especially given their history) are Jews the only people in the world who dont have it. I suppose opposing Zionism is not bigotry if one also opposes the rights of other stateless people, like the Palestinians and the Tibetans to a state or if one argues that no people really needs sovereignty.
But the very people who call themselves anti-Zionist are those who demand all of Israel and all of the occupied territories for the Palestinians. Anti-Zionists oppose even an inch of the land for Jewish sovereignty, while a sizable percentage of Israelis and their supporters favor sharing the land with the Palestinians.
After all, it was only in 1995 that Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin was murdered for beginning the process of negotiating the dividing of the land between Israelis and Palestinians. Only the Jewish right favors Jews keeping all the land and they are quite rightly defined as rightists and bigots, the Jewish alt-right. Why doesnt the same opprobrium apply to those who proudly call themselves anti-Zionists and whose motto could be not one inch for the Jews. Add to that the animus toward Jews in general that emanate from websites that carry the anti-Zionist banner like Mondoweiss, the most prominent one. Its writers and editors continually blur the line between Zionists and Jews because, in modern parlance, there isnt one.
The bottom line is this. Calling out Israel for its policies (many of which are abominable) is legitimate and more than legitimate. It is right. Demand the end to the illegal, immoral occupation and every settlement. Boycott or dont boycott (BDS is NOT intrinsically anti-semitic). But stop attacking Zionists when you just mean Jews. After all, if you believe that every other people on the planet have the right to a place in the sun where they will not be persecuted, where their children are safe, but that Jews or Israelis dont, then you are an anti-semite. My only advice to you is to stop saying you oppose Zionism when what you really oppose are historys favorite scapegoat: the Jews.
The Morning Email
Wake up to the day's most important news.
Follow this link:
Anti-Zionism Is Anti-Semitism - HuffPost
- Anti-Zionism equals Anti-Semitism? Macron fuels debate on how ... - February 21st, 2019
- Nobody knows what Zionism means anymore. Two historians help ... - February 21st, 2019
- 02/13 Links Pt2: Antisemitism and anti-Zionism. Performing ... - February 15th, 2019
- Zionism | Definition, History, Examples, & Facts ... - February 7th, 2019
- Anti-Zionism is a rejection of racism and imperialism, not ... - February 2nd, 2019
- Books and DVDs on Zionism - nkusa.org - January 29th, 2019
- What is Zionism? | Torah Jews - January 26th, 2019
- Zionism - Kids | Britannica Kids | Homework Help - January 26th, 2019
- Martin Luther King and Zionism | The Jewish Press ... - January 23rd, 2019
- Zionists synonyms, Zionists antonyms - FreeThesaurus.com - January 19th, 2019
- JVPs Approach to Zionism - January 15th, 2019
- Yes, Anti-Zionism Is The Same As Anti-Semitism - January 10th, 2019
- Zionism | Wikipedia audio article - January 10th, 2019
- Haredim and Zionism | Religion-wiki | FANDOM powered by Wikia - January 8th, 2019
- Zionism and Anti-Semitism: Argument / Counter-Argument - December 30th, 2018
- Rethinking Mizra Him | Zionism | Jews - scribd.com - December 23rd, 2018
- Israel, Zionism, and the (((Jews))) - December 23rd, 2018
- Category:Zionism - Wikimedia Commons - December 23rd, 2018
- Opinion | When Anti-Zionism Tunnels Under Your House - The ... - December 17th, 2018
- Zionism | Zionism | Jews - December 14th, 2018
- Opinion | Anti-Zionism Isnt the Same as Anti-Semitism - The ... - December 9th, 2018
- Zionism: Cycles of Trauma and Aggression in the Service of ... - December 5th, 2018
- Zionism :: essays research papers - November 11th, 2018
- What Is Zionism? - October 6th, 2018
- The Zionist Story. (Full Documentary) - October 6th, 2018
- Zionism - HISTORY - September 24th, 2018
- Zionism: The Real Enemy of the Jews, Vol. 1: The False ... - September 15th, 2018
- Zionism - Conservapedia - September 14th, 2018
- The Crisis of Zionism: Peter Beinart: 9781250026736 ... - September 4th, 2018
- Overcoming Zionism: Creating a Single Democratic State in ... - August 20th, 2018
- Zionism | Encyclopedia.com - August 5th, 2018
- Allies for Armageddon: The Rise of Christian Zionism ... - August 3rd, 2018
- The Zionist Story. (Full Documentary) - YouTube - July 23rd, 2018
- Christian Zionism Examined: A Review of Ideas on Israel ... - July 14th, 2018
- The New Christian Zionism: Fresh Perspectives on Israel ... - June 26th, 2018
- Zionism: Is Zionism Racism? - Jewish Virtual Library - June 4th, 2018
- Zionism - adl.org - May 14th, 2018
- Fundamentalism | religious movement | Britannica.com - May 13th, 2018
- Anti-Zionism does not equal anti-Semitism Labour Party ... - March 28th, 2018
- What is Zionism? | Lasse Wilhelmson - February 21st, 2018
- THE SATANIC VERSES OF THE JEWISH TALMUD AND ZIONISM ... - February 10th, 2018
- Rothschild Zionism - YouTube - February 10th, 2018
- United Nations General Assembly Resolution 3379 - Wikipedia - February 7th, 2018
- Zionism: Christian Zionism - Jewish Virtual Library - January 29th, 2018
- When Zionism is the essence of life, a break has huge ... - January 12th, 2018
- Is Liberal Zionism Dead? - The New York Times - January 11th, 2018
- The never-ending crisis of Zionism - December 31st, 2017
- Mizrachi (religious Zionism) - Wikipedia - December 20th, 2017
- The Black Magick Masonic Control of Zionism ... - Cutting Edge - December 16th, 2017
- Zionism in the Light of Jerusalem - counterpunch.org - December 13th, 2017
- They Live : John Carpenter World Message of Zionism [film ... - December 12th, 2017
- What is Zionism? - Everything you need to know about Israel ... - December 7th, 2017
- Zionism - mobile Wiki - December 7th, 2017
- The Inevitable Apartheid Nation: Where is Zionism Taking Us? - December 2nd, 2017
- The shocking alliance between Zionism and Anti-Semitism ... - November 29th, 2017
- What Is Zionism? - YouTube - November 27th, 2017
- Zionism 101 | My Jewish Learning - November 24th, 2017
- Zionism - Facts & Summary - HISTORY.com - October 23rd, 2017
- Everything About the Rothschild Zionism | Humans Are Free - October 19th, 2017
- What is Zionism? - True Torah Jews | Against Zionism - October 3rd, 2017
- What is Zionism and Who Are the Zionists | Zionism | Israel - September 20th, 2017
- Anti-Israel Extremists Target ADL in New Online Campaign Equating Zionism With Racism - Algemeiner - August 25th, 2017
- Zionism Cannot Be Compared To Nazism Even If Richard Spencer And JVP Say So - Forward - August 25th, 2017
- Birds of a feather: White supremacy and Zionism - Middle East Eye - August 24th, 2017
- Casting Zionism As 'White Nationalism' Is Anti-Semitism ... - August 24th, 2017
- Christian Zionism and a positive relationship with Jews and Judaism - The Jerusalem Post mobile website - August 24th, 2017
- Jews argue whether Zionism is racism in the Forward! - Mondoweiss - August 23rd, 2017
- Zionism, terrorism pose major threats to Islamic World - Mehr News Agency - English Version - August 23rd, 2017
- Sorry, Richard Spencer: Comparing Zionism to White Nationalism Is ... - Forward - August 22nd, 2017
- Why This Druze Israeli Identifies As A Zionist - Forward - August 22nd, 2017
- Watch: Why there is no such thing as white Zionism - Arutz Sheva - August 21st, 2017
- On Wednesday, in an interview with Israel's Channel 2, alt-right luminary Richard Spencer declared himself to be a ... - Tablet Magazine - August 19th, 2017
- Zionism Is Nothing Like White Supremacy, No Matter What Richard Spencer Says - Forward - August 19th, 2017
- Is Zionism "Creepy"? The Question at the Heart of a Social-Media Controversy Deserves an Answer - Council on Foreign Relations (blog) - August 19th, 2017
- The strength of modern Zionism 120 years after first WZC - New Jersey Jewish News - August 18th, 2017
- Charlottesville is moment of truth for empowered US Zionists (who name their children after Israeli generals) - Mondoweiss - August 18th, 2017
- Richard Spencer compares his white supremacy to Zionism - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - August 18th, 2017
- Zionism - Scripture Catholic - August 17th, 2017
- My Journey to Zionism - Algemeiner - August 17th, 2017
- Taking back the power to define Zionism - Jewish News (blog) - August 16th, 2017
Comments