BDS and its critics – Middle East Monitor
Posted By admin on June 24, 2020
No civil society group in the United States has undergone as much censorious repression as the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions movement better known simply as BDS and the most radical critic of Israeli policy in Gaza and the West Bank. Twenty-eight states have passed anti-boycott legislation condemning BDS. Israel has published a blacklist of groups whose members will be denied entry into the country. With an air of paranoia, mainstream Jewish and Zionist organisations have condemned BDS. And why not? It helps justify their existence.
Campus after campus has made BDS unwelcome, although it is true that support for the movement has grown among young student radicals, and it has prompted offshoots and allied groupings in Europe. However, it is also true that BDS has made little headway in American political life. Perhaps 35 out of 435 members of Congress supported a tepid resolution in defence of Palestinian Human Rights, but the House of Representatives also passed a resolution condemning BDS overwhelmingly. Whats more, there was strong bipartisan support for President Donald Trumps decision to move the US Embassy to Jerusalem and for a peace plan that any sane Palestinian would find unacceptable. Meanwhile, punishment for criticising Israel on US campuses occurs so often that the Centre for Constitutional Rights has spoken caustically about a Palestinian exception to free speech. Needless to say, Trump has described BDS as a terrorist organisation.
READ: European court ruling backs BDS freedom of expression
A number of my very close friends are supporters of BDS, and I trust their intelligence and integrity implicitly. The majority of BDS supporters are neither anti-Semites nor self-hating Jews, but rather radicals seeking justice for a colonised people denied the right of national self-determination. Their outraged backing for the Palestinians is, in principle, no different than what rebels of an earlier time extended to the North Vietnamese against the United States or the Algerians against France. Initially, those white critics supporting people of colour against Western imperialism were a minority; ultimately, of course, that changed. BDS is hoping for more of the same.
Existing alongside these radicals of goodwill, almost inevitably there are blatant ant-Semites involved in the BDS movement who speak about driving the Jews into the sea, abolishing Israel and possible deportations. They actually get more press coverage than they deserve and it is true that too many excuses are still being made on their behalf.
Moreover, there are reasons why the Palestinian Authority in Ramallah keeps its distance from BDS; only Hamas offers it ideological support. For better or worse, Israel remains Palestines primary economic partner while Egypt as well as Jordan, which have peace treaties with Israel, have little use for BDS.
I am not a member of BDS, nor is my co-director of the International Council for Diplomacy and Dialogue, Eric Gozlan. That decision is rooted in our principles and interests.
BDS calls upon Israel to retreat beyond its 1967 borders; provide equal rights for Israeli Arabs and Palestinians; acknowledge the right of return; knock down the odious border controls; and essentially allow for free intercourse between Arabs and Israelis. On the question of one-state or two, BDS is coy; it has no objection to an Israeli state, but not on Palestinian land. BDS thus draws the distinction between Jews and Zionists as if that helps explain the future treatment of Israeli citizens who might be Jews and Zionists, or neither, or one of the two. It is also not clear whether the right of return is meant as a symbolic demand or a practical one; symbolically, and legitimately, it calls for compensating the Palestinian community, not individuals. As a practical political demand, however, BDS has offered no ideas about how to repatriate millions of individuals into a new state with what will surely prove to be a fragile economy. Given the bureaucratic problems associated with constituting a unified state, the lack of trust or empathy between Israelis and Palestinians, the transformation of Jews from a majority into a minority, and the lack of clarity concerning the government that the Palestinians wish to introduce, there is little serious incentive for either side to support the BDS agenda.
READ: BDS Spain anti-racism course cancelled following pressure from pro-Israel groups
Admittedly, these are mostly long-term strategic considerations, but the short-term tactics of BDS are also problematic. Just as the Zionist right wing ignores Palestinian interests, BDS ignores Israeli security issues and has no constructive ideas about what to do with the hundreds of thousands of mostly reactionary settlers or the orthodox part of the Jewish community that together might well take up arms against the Israeli government in the face of any transformative political project. Without support from Ramallah, moreover, BDS would leave Israel in the position of having to negotiate with two partners thus projecting the self-defeating prospect not of one state, or two states, but three.
Israel has no sympathy for BDS, and even Meretz, a genuinely left-wing party, rejects it. Perhaps this is because there is even a lack of clarity about the meaning of boycott, divestment and sanctions. Depending on who one asks, boycott and divestment are meant to target companies with direct ties to the Israeli occupation; all companies doing business with Israel, but not universities; all corporations and all universities but not progressive academics and artists; or all of the above. Furthermore, anyone with even a cursory knowledge about sanctions knows that they mostly have an impact on working people, the poor, and the most vulnerable. There is also no reason why Israel as against a litany of far more repressive and genocidal states should alone be the subject of boycott, divestment, and sanctions.
BDS has put no meaningful proposals on the table, but its existence has pressured other, sometimes liberal and Zionist organisations like J-Street, to endorse boycotting and divesting from companies that are engaged actively in the occupation of Palestine. That is a genuine contribution. Raising awareness about the conflict among the young is another. And presenting the radical Palestinian standpoint is still another. However, the movements critics acknowledge none of this. They know it all, there is nothing to be learned, so shut down BDS, and liberal principles be damned.
It is high time for both sides to show a little humility. Engage in symbolic protests if you like, turn your backs on speakers, or even walk out of an assembly; but protest against their ideas (and tackle them seriously) not their right to speak.
READ: US state of Missouri passes incredibly dangerous anti-BDS bill
Kant knew that freedom of speech is the foundation for all other political freedoms. And there is that famous line attributed (falsely) to Voltaire: I disapprove of what you say but I will defend to the death your right to say it. The hysteria surrounding BDS in the US and now in Europe is deplorable. The far-right can do what it wishes, but when liberals, socialists and people of the left start mimicking its calls for censorship and the denial of free assembly, things never turn out well. Israel has not divulged which groups supporting BDS have been banned, and this, my friends, is a dangerous precedent.
Censoring the far left has traditionally been the first step on the road to censoring others. The self-righteous critics of BDS generally surrender to the paranoia, intolerance, and extremism that they otherwise denounce. Of course, similar criticisms apply to those in BDS who ignore the enlightenment values upon which their project should be based. Such attitudes lead only to political practices that increase the visibility, publicity, and martyr-like status of their target. When Jews proclaim support for Trump or Frances Marine Le Pen, because such leaders are good for the Jews or because of the venom they spout against Arabs and people of colour generally, these opportunists are not being realistic or pragmatic. They are just being short-sighted in swallowing ideological nonsense, abandoning their principles, isolating Israel still further, and fomenting anti-Semitic resentment, while forgetting that their new right-wing allies can (and probably will) change policies in the blink of an eye.
No less than the folks in BDS, the movements reactionary critics also lack a positive vision for the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Palestinian concerns simply dont matter to them. By implicitly or explicitly endorsing Israeli settlement expansion, balkanising the West Bank, and boycotting Gaza, their stubborn arrogance contributes to a politics of stasis that has become ever more odious and frustrating.
Its almost as if BDS and its right-wing critics have become mirror images of one another: les extremes se touchent. Supporters of BDS seem congenitally incapable of admitting that Palestinian leaders ever made a mistake. Palestinians are victims pure and simple; memories of the brutal Palestinian expulsion from their lands, pride and honour prevented their leaders from adapting tactics and demands to an ever-greater imbalance of power, and all this while their future state began to shrink and turn from a viable into a non-contiguous entity.
As for the right-wing critics of BDS, the situation is no different: lack of peace is always the fault of the Palestinians; atrocities committed against them during the expulsion from the new state of Israel were not really that bad, not compared to what the Jews suffered in the Holocaust; and Biblical claims to Judea and Samaria justify any Israeli use of excessive force and any of its imperialist ambitions. Like Israel, for whom it claims to speak, the extremist right is also a victim, actually a greater victim, though very few are still alive who ever experienced a concentration camp; only necessity has forced these victims into the role of conquerors.
Intransigence and self-righteousness have led both BDS and its reactionary critics to consider anything except uncritical support as what communists used to call an objective apology for the enemy. Dialogue has broken down and political positions have hardened on both sides. Hope and humanist sentiments are about all that remain for the reasonable. But there are also intelligent activists with goodwill on both sides of the barricades, and perhaps there is something simmering beneath the verbiage: ideas to rekindle negotiations, reformulate demands, change tactics and actually contribute to the prospects for peace that are growing dimmer by the day.
The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.
Read more here:
BDS and its critics - Middle East Monitor
- Here's a course in anti-Zionist musicology - Slipped Disc - January 18th, 2021
- US-Zionist axis trying to disintegrate Islamic nations - Mehr News Agency - English Version - January 18th, 2021
- The Battle Over Jewish Students and the IHRA Definition of Antisemitism - Algemeiner - January 18th, 2021
- Pompeo accused Iran to gain Zionists support in 2024 election - Mehr News Agency - English Version - January 18th, 2021
- Trump's parting gift to Israel - Middle East Monitor - January 18th, 2021
- This week in history: January 18-24 - WSWS - January 18th, 2021
- Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Was A Zionist - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - January 18th, 2021
- Report: New bleak forecast says Israel could see large new COVID wave in March - The Times of Israel - January 18th, 2021
- A Conversation on A Critical Political Economy of the Middle East and North Africa (14 Jan) - Jadaliyya - January 18th, 2021
- Moroccan Islamist groups reject normalizing ties with Israel - Reuters - December 16th, 2020
- At US Jewish anti-Zionist group anti-Semitism panel, speakers say they love Jews - The Times of Israel - December 16th, 2020
- Opinion | The real lesson in the Roald Dahl apology? Anti-Zionists hate Jews. - Forward - December 16th, 2020
- The fulfilment of the Zionist vision - Australian Jewish News - December 16th, 2020
- Turkish media vows to take over Tel Aviv, calls opposition terrorists - The Jerusalem Post - December 16th, 2020
- Hanukkahs lesson about antisemitism on the Left - Forward - December 16th, 2020
- Equating Zionism With White Supremacy in the Age of Trump - The Jewish Voice - December 16th, 2020
- Doha, Muscat oppose tie normalization with Zionist Regime - Mehr News Agency - English Version - December 16th, 2020
- The People of Israel's Hanukkah Gift to themselves - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - December 16th, 2020
- Zionist regime has no place in future of region - Mehr News Agency - English Version - December 16th, 2020
- The Trump Administration is Cracking Down Against a Global Movement to Boycott Israel. Heres What You Need to Know About BDS - TIME - December 5th, 2020
- Christian Zionists leaving their legacy on the way out - People's World - December 5th, 2020
- The terrifying marriage of convenience between Israel and evangelical Zionists - Forward - December 5th, 2020
- A Young John F. Kennedy's Unimpressive Musings on Nazi Germany and Zionism - Mosaic - December 5th, 2020
- Progressive Zionists warn of 'grave challenges' for the left in Israel - Jewish News - December 5th, 2020
- Zionist Heroine Hannah Senesh's Archives Get Home in Israel's National Library - The Media Line - December 5th, 2020
- UK Labour leadership tells Zionist meeting that thousands of party members face expulsion - WSWS - December 5th, 2020
- What Stands in the Way of Closer Ties between Brazil and Israel? - Mosaic - December 5th, 2020
- The First Agudat Yisrael Knessiah Gedolah And The Introduction Of The Daf Yomi - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - December 5th, 2020
- Philippines Honored for Aiding Jews in Holocaust and Support for Creation of Israel - Algemeiner - December 5th, 2020
- Labour antisemitism must be confronted with nuance, clarity and empathy - LabourList - December 5th, 2020
- MAGA Weaponized Rev. Jeremiah Wright And Zionism Against Rev. Raphael Warnock: Its Not Working - Moguldom - December 5th, 2020
- A Brief History of Israel's Ambassadors to Washington, Their Successes, and Their Troubles - Mosaic - December 5th, 2020
- Podcast: Richard Goldberg on the Future of Israeli-Saudi Relations - Mosaic - December 5th, 2020
- Are Universities Producing the Anti-Israel Foot Soldiers? - The Times of Israel - December 5th, 2020
- An assassination has made a dark Mideast darker than ever - Tehran Times - December 5th, 2020
- Temple Emanu-El Presents 'The History and Ideas of Zionism' Over Two Sessions - WHAV News - November 28th, 2020
- Pentecostal Zionists and their support for the illegal Israeli occupation - Middle East Monitor - November 28th, 2020
- Czechia and Israel: Together in the past and future - The Jerusalem Post - November 28th, 2020
- The Dark Shadows of Shared Exceptionalism Between the US and Israel - The Citizen - November 28th, 2020
- JUF News | University of Illinois commits to address antisemitism - Jewish United Fund - November 28th, 2020
- Pakistan will never establish relations with Zionist state, says Imran - Pakistan Today - November 28th, 2020
- Not just about Crown Heights: A Zionist, an educator and an activist pay tribute to David Dinkins - Forward - November 28th, 2020
- Antisemitism is alive and well at Sydney Uni - Australian Jewish News - November 28th, 2020
- Dont give Pollard a heros welcome or Trump a heros send-off opinion - The Jerusalem Post - November 28th, 2020
- There are far more dangerous people around than actors who party with Israelis - Middle East Monitor - November 28th, 2020
- The Tragedy of Jeremy Corbyn - Jewish Currents - November 28th, 2020
- Iranian Response Would Be Destructive: Israeli Report Says Army Hasn't Been Instructed to Prepare for Scenarios of US Strike on Iran - Al-Manar TV - November 28th, 2020
- US Dept. Of Education Opens Investigation Into Alleged Anti-Semitism At U Of I - - Illinois Newsroom - November 21st, 2020
- For the Jewish state, the Holocaust is a tool to be manipulated - +972 Magazine - November 21st, 2020
- Rouhani: "Trump Has Almost Carried Out Dictates Of The Zionist Regime" - Yeshiva World News - November 21st, 2020
- The anniversary of Rabin's assassination and its significance - Mondoweiss - November 21st, 2020
- Zionism 3.0: Time to step it up on Israel-diaspora issues J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - November 19th, 2020
- Ice Cube to speak at Zionist Organization of America gala - New York Post - November 19th, 2020
- Beware Of Anti-Zionism Is Not Anti-Semitism From The Left - Jewish Journal - November 19th, 2020
- Zionist Movement Announced In India - JNS.org - November 19th, 2020
- A Tale Of Two Morgenthaus: Zionist And Anti-Zionist - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - November 19th, 2020
- Podcast: Matti Friedman on the Russian AliyahThirty Years Later - Mosaic - November 19th, 2020
- Iran Is Trying to Expand Its Presence in Syria, and Israel Has Struck Back - Mosaic - November 19th, 2020
- Israeli university to give credits to students who work with far-right group - Haaretz.com - November 19th, 2020
- The Middle East Is Ripe for Peacemaking Effortsbut Not for Repeating the Mistakes of the Past - Mosaic - November 19th, 2020
- The Israeli Scientist Investigating a New Way to Fight the Coronavirus with the Help of a Llama - Mosaic - November 19th, 2020
- Rouhani: Trump administration 'almost carried out the dictates of US extremists, Zionist regime' - Cleveland Jewish News - November 17th, 2020
- Mourning the Loss of Four Great Scholars of Jewish Ideas - Mosaic - November 17th, 2020
- Ice Cube Set to Speak at the Zionist Organization of Americas Virtual Gala - Vulture - November 17th, 2020
- Pakistan's Prime Minister Says He'll Never Establish Ties With 'Zionists,' After Facing Pressure to Recognize Israel - Algemeiner - November 17th, 2020
- Ice Cube Will Speak At A Zionist Gala Following His Antisemitic Tweet - UPROXX - November 17th, 2020
- Zionists to build new 1,257 houses in occupied lands - Mehr News Agency - English Version - November 17th, 2020
- Qatari Journalist: Normalization With Israel Furthers Zionist Goal Of World Domination - Middle East Media Research Institute - November 17th, 2020
- Zionist Left and the PLO Flag: A Troubling Episode - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - November 17th, 2020
- Unity, Mizrachi, and the legacy of Rabbi Sacks - The Jerusalem Post - November 17th, 2020
- The Hebrew-Based Judaism And Zionism Of Eliezer Ben Yehuda - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - November 17th, 2020
- Pakistan PM Imran Khan Says Under Pressure to Recognise Israel, Insists on No Ties with 'Zionists' - News18 - November 17th, 2020
- Macron wants to identify himself with the American Zionism: Lebanese cleric - Tehran Times - November 17th, 2020
- Iran Denies That Al Qaeda Leader Was Killed in Tehran - The New York Times - November 17th, 2020
- The Assassination of al-Qaeda's Second-in-Command Was a Message to a Iran - Mosaic - November 17th, 2020
- Zionist Occupation Planned to Kill Arafat by Blowing up Beirut Stadium: Report - Al-Manar TV - November 17th, 2020
- Niger Reportedly Engaged in Secret Talks to Normalize Ties with Zionist Regime - IQNA (International Quran News Agency) - November 17th, 2020
- Sitting at the WZO table from the perspective of an Orthodox Jew - The Jerusalem Post - November 17th, 2020
- Normalization with Egypt Should Be Israel's Next Peacemaking Goal - Mosaic - November 17th, 2020
- Proud Boys leader trying to rebrand the group as explicitly antisemitic - The Jerusalem Post - November 17th, 2020
Comments