Can a new word ‘Zionophobia’ clarify the debate over Israel? J. – The Jewish News of Northern California
Posted By admin on December 14, 2021
This piece first appeared at the Forward.
Israel sits in the center of the roiling debate over what is and isnt antisemitic.
Top Jewish establishment leaders have twisted themselves into knots trying to explain precisely when and how criticism of Israel crosses the line into antisemitism. And even when they draw what seems to be a red line, there are caveats.
Meanwhile, many progressive Jews and Palestinians balk at what they see as frivolous accusations of antisemitism leveled at those trying to stand up for Palestinians suffering under Israeli rule.
Now, a new term has entered the debate, one promoted by pro-Israel advocates who say it can bring clarity to the confusing feud over the definition of antisemitism. Zionophobia an obsessive animosity toward the idea of a homeland for the Jewish people represents the idea that discriminating against Jewish Zionists is a form of bigotry distinct from antisemitism.
Zionophobia, however, seems to have touched off more wrangling between those who deem it yet another way to delegitimize any criticism of Israel, and those who say it captures the discrimination they experience for supporting the Jewish state.
Judea Pearl, a computer scientist at the University of California, Los Angeles who is active in the campus debates over Israel, appears to haveoriginally coined the term in 2018. But it only drew widespread attention earlier this month after it was used in a letterfrom University of Southern California faculty concerned about statements made by an engineering student on campus.
More than 65 professors wrote that they were not only concerned with the continuing instances of anti-Semitism and Zionophobia on our campus.
The terms appearance in the letter and asocial media postfrom the controversial pro-Israel group Canary Mission quickly drew a mix of mockery and condemnation from pro-Palestinian activists online. Critics seized on the idea that embracing a political ideology like Zionism could make one a member of a group that should be shielded from discrimination.
An Open Letter to @USC & @USCViterbi signed by 64 professors including Andrew Viterbi himself!
"We, the undersigned faculty, wish to register our dismay about ongoing open expressions of anti-Semitism and Zionophobia on our campus that go unrebuked."https://t.co/dMW2Egu1EF pic.twitter.com/tdrwu4RABB
Canary Mission (@canarymission) December 2, 2021
We are absolutely NOT making zionophobia a thing, novelist Rebecca Podoswrote on Twitter. Zionists are not an oppressed or marginalized class of people. Others were more flip: They keep creating new ridiculous terms, another user wrote. Yeah, Im definitely apartheidphobic.
new phobia just dropped https://t.co/BGYbBASMzn
(@Axolotl_pragmat) December 2, 2021
But Pearl argued that discriminating against Zionists is a form of religious bigotry aimed at Jews, even if those attacking the movement are not otherwise antisemitic.
Zionism (The eventual return to Zion) is at the core of Jewish identity, more fundamental even than divine supervision, Pearl wrote in an email. Hence discrimination on the basis of Zionist beliefs amounts to racism discrimination on the basis of an immutable quality.
Despite this, Pearl said that claims of antisemitism leveled against anti-Zionists are too blunt to capture this form of discrimination because many of those who oppose Zionism are either Jewish themselves or friendly toward Jews outside the context of Israel.
I see hordes of BDS cronies volunteering to fight for the right of Jewish students to have a Kosher cafeteria, to pray three times a day, and to wear Yarmulke in public, Pearlwrote in a 2018 blogoutlining the term. And they truly mean it, as long as the Yarmulke is not decorated with blue and white Magen David.
The term has other proponents, including Jewish Journal editor David Suissa who lamented that Zionists on college campuses lacked the protections given to gay, Muslim and transgender students.
All societal phobias from homophobia to Islamophobia to transphobia are unacceptable, except, apparently, for Zionophobia, Suissa wrote in a columnlast year.
And while the term has been slow to catch on outside of southern California, other Israel advocates have floated similar arguments about how what is traditionally called anti-Zionism can effectively discriminate against Jews even if not all Jews believe in Zionism or support Israel.
Misha Galperin, chief of the National Museum of American Jewish Heritage, has compared Zionism to Shabbat observance. While Jews may differ in their approach to both concepts, Galperin said, demonizing either one strikes at the heart of an important religious belief for many Jews.
If somebody denies you the belief in observing Shabbat because its part of the Jewish religion, nobody has any doubt thats antisemitic, Galerpin said. And if somebody denies you the fact that you are identified with a state which is also part of our religion that is also antisemitic.
Still, Pearls promotion of Zionophobia runs counter to the way most major Jewish organizations focused on both antisemitism and advocating for Israel have treated anti-Zionism. The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliancesworking definition of antisemitism, which has been adopted and aggressively promoted by much of the Jewish establishment, states that denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination in Israel may be antisemitic but that it depends on the context.
In recent months, both the American Jewish Committee and Anti-Defamation League took what appeared to be more unequivocal approaches to the question of whether opposition to Israels existence as a Jewish-majority state is antisemitic.
We as an organization certainly believe that anti-Zionist rhetoric and speech should be treated as antisemitic in every respect, Avi Mayer, the American Jewish Committees senior spokesperson,told Forward opinion editorLaura Adkins in October.
Similarly, ADL chief Jonathan Greenblatt responded to the controversy over Sunrise D.C.s boycott of three pro-Israel Jewish groups in October bystating on Twitter: To be clear: excluding groups solely because they support Israel is antisemitic.
However, we remain concerned that these litmus tests targeting Jewish groups are becoming increasingly common.To be clear:excluding groups solely because they support Israel is antisemitic.
Jonathan Greenblatt (@JGreenblattADL) October 22, 2021
But others in these organizations subsequently qualified those bold declarations.
Kenneth Bandler, director of media relations for the AJC, said that the organization believed anti-Zionist hate speech, as opposed to all expressions of anti-Zionism, should presumptively be treated as antisemitic.
And a spokesman for the ADL shared with the Forward a definition that the organization uses, which noted that anti-Zionism was not inherently antisemitic, although it became so if it was used to disparage Jews who feel a connection to Israel.
Pearl prefers to sidestep the messiness these definitions can foster.
Every time we label an attack against Israel anti-Semitic we lose the high moral ground and the conversation drifts to where we cannot win, he wrote in the 2018 article titled, Zionophobia our only fighting word.
If Pearl hopes that his new word will free the debate over Israel from a back-and-forth over the definition of antisemitism, he may be disappointed. Alon Confino, who helped organize theJerusalem Declaration on Antisemitismover concerns that too many institutions were treating anti-Zionism as antisemitism, said the invention of Zionophobia seemed like an attempt to stifle political speech.
Zionism is a national political movement, said Confino, a Holocaust scholar at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst. National political movements are always debatable.
Original post:
Can a new word 'Zionophobia' clarify the debate over Israel? J. - The Jewish News of Northern California
- Zionism - ADL - December 29th, 2022
- Split of Religious Zionism, Otzma Yehudit, Noam parties approved ... - December 29th, 2022
- Netanyahu government reconnects with "revisionist Zionism" - December 29th, 2022
- Bezalel Smotrich, the Leader of the Nationalist Religious Zionism Party, is Poised to ... - Latest Tweet by - LatestLY - December 29th, 2022
- Book review: Zionism During the Holocaust: The Weaponisation of ... - Middle East Monitor - December 25th, 2022
- Hundreds of US rabbis pledge to block extremists in Israeli government from speaking in their communities - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - December 25th, 2022
- Why well fight Israels new extremist political agenda with the determination of the Maccabees - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - December 25th, 2022
- Israels Election Empowers a More Muscular Religious Zionism - December 18th, 2022
- The Noahide Laws :: Zionism Exposed - December 15th, 2022
- Georgia Guidestones - Wikipedia - October 27th, 2022
- Ephesians, CHAPTER 2 | USCCB - October 27th, 2022
- Knesset - Wikipedia - October 27th, 2022
- Changing Attitudes towards Zionism among American JewsAn Interview with Zachary Lockman - MERIP - October 17th, 2022
- Berkeley Law Faculty Condemn Refusing Zionist Speakers - Inside Higher Ed - October 17th, 2022
- Kanye West's Twitter account locked for anti-Semitic tweet - KCRA Sacramento - October 10th, 2022
- Lead role in play about antisemitism for leading light of anti-Zionism - The Times of Israel - October 10th, 2022
- Why the US congress and Canadian Parliament ordered Twitter to erase Laith Marouf from Virtual existence - Al Mayadeen English - October 10th, 2022
- Zionism During the Holocaust: The Weaponization of Memory in the Service of State and Nation - Book Review - Palestine Chronicle - October 6th, 2022
- What is a Zionist? Liz Truss calls herself a 'huge Zionist' as she pledges support to Israel - The Scotsman - October 6th, 2022
- The worst college story you'll read all year - Religion News Service - September 16th, 2022
- Jewish teen advocacy: What is it and how does it lead to the new American Jew? - eJewish Philanthropy - September 13th, 2022
- Your Daily Phil: GatherDC expands to West Coast + Nourishment for the Jewish soul - eJewish Philanthropy - September 13th, 2022
- 'The New York Times,' Zionism and Israel - JNS.org - September 13th, 2022
- DOE opens investigation into antisemitic incidents at the University of Vermont - Jewish Insider - September 13th, 2022
- Lebanese Expert: U.S. and Zionism Are Behind Hitler, ISIS - Middle East Media Research Institute - September 13th, 2022
- An anti-Semitism expert says that progressives 'have the right to exclude Zionists' - Middle East Monitor - September 11th, 2022
- Biden Said it Best: You Don't Have to Be Jewish to Be a Zionist - Jewish Journal - August 6th, 2022
- ED launches Title VI investigation into USC - Inside Higher Ed - August 1st, 2022
- 'I Solemnly Demand That Anti-Zionism Be Banned in France,' Parliamentary Deputy Declares - Algemeiner - August 1st, 2022
- Editor Who Pushed Anti-Zionism Gets a Promotion at New York Times - Algemeiner - August 1st, 2022
- Zionism And The Power To Rule Over Others - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - August 1st, 2022
- In The Zionist Megiddo Prison - Countercurrents.org - August 1st, 2022
- An idea of inclusive India - Business Standard - July 10th, 2022
- Roadmap from critics of Israel sends chill through Jewish community - The Boston Globe - June 26th, 2022
- I am a Jewish Crimson Editor, and I See the Writing on the Wallof Resistance | Opinion - Harvard Crimson - June 26th, 2022
- Review of Judaism 3.0: Judaism's Transformation To Zionism - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - June 26th, 2022
- BDS-promoted mapping project is antisemitic and must be condemned - The Boston Globe - June 14th, 2022
- A Journey to June 1967 and Back: On the Fabricated Narratives of Zionism - Palestine Chronicle - June 14th, 2022
- Were Early Zionists Terrorists? - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - June 14th, 2022
- 100 years ago this month: When Congress embraced Zionismunanimously - JNS.org - June 10th, 2022
- The Soviet origins of left-wing anti-Zionism - JNS.org - June 10th, 2022
- Israel's Destruction Is Championed at the University of Chicago - Algemeiner - June 10th, 2022
- Anti-Zionism is a genocidal ideology | Eyal Bitton | The Blogs - June 4th, 2022
- The Silver Platter - (Silver Salver) Nathan Alterman - Poem - June 4th, 2022
- Zionism, Policing and Empire: A dispatch from the Mapping Project - Mondoweiss - June 4th, 2022
- Review of Legacy of Empire: Britain, Zionism and the Creation of Israel - Middle East Forum - June 2nd, 2022
- Zionism of Strength and Humility | Andy Blumenthal | The Blogs - The Times of Israel - June 2nd, 2022
- First Zionist Congress - Wikipedia - May 27th, 2022
- Statement in Support of The Harvard Crimson and Palestinian Liberation | Opinion - Harvard Crimson - May 27th, 2022
- New book: A 'Queer, Disabled' early Zionist illustrates 'roads not taken' J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - May 25th, 2022
- Group reports record tally of antisemitic incidents in 2021 - ABC News - April 29th, 2022
- Why Did an Antisemitic Christian Zionist Have the Chutzpah to Declare That He'd Be Leading a Holocaust March? - Religion Dispatches - April 29th, 2022
- The Babylonian Talmud - Zionism Exposed - April 20th, 2022
- LIVE EVENT - War, Conflict, and Academic Freedom (21 April) - Jadaliyya - April 20th, 2022
- The cause, and the goal, of Israeli violence - Al Jazeera English - April 20th, 2022
- 67 years after his death, Albert Einstein's true relationship to Judaism and Zionism - St. Louis Jewish Light - April 20th, 2022
- Antisemitism and Anti-Zionism on the College Campus - jewishboston.com - April 20th, 2022
- Why is this night and this year different than all other nights? - Wisconsin Examiner - April 16th, 2022
- Temple Israel series to focus on antisemitism, anti-Zionism - Cleveland Jewish News - April 16th, 2022
- Controversy Over Israel Studies At University Of Washington Did Not Have To Happen - Forbes - April 13th, 2022
- Wine-washing the Israeli occupation - Al Jazeera English - April 13th, 2022
- My Zionist Hagadah | Jeffrey Levine | The Blogs - The Times of Israel - April 13th, 2022
- Canary Mission Report Highlights Antisemitism Among Supporters of USC Student Senator Who Tweeted I Want to Kill Every Motherf---ing Zionist - Jewish... - March 29th, 2022
- Yet another 'apartheid' report builds pressure on liberal Zionists to recognize 'lived reality' of Palestinians - Mondoweiss - March 26th, 2022
- Students For Justice In Palestine: J Street Is The Gateway For Jewish Anti-Zionists - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - March 26th, 2022
- How Owen Jones learned to stop worrying and love Zionism - The Electronic Intifada - March 24th, 2022
- Judaic Studies begins Zionism lecture series with guest ... - March 8th, 2022
- Foreign Fighters and Fellow Travelers: Right-Wing Extremism in Australia and the United States - Lawfare - March 8th, 2022
- The crisis in Ukraine exposes the hypocrisy of Israel and its Zionist allies - Middle East Monitor - February 26th, 2022
- Iran: Believers To Begin Prison Sentences For spreading ... - February 24th, 2022
- New Historians - Wikipedia - February 24th, 2022
- 'We Can't Shut Off One of Our Identities': Jewish SUNY Students Decry 'Exclusion' From Sexual Assault Awareness Group Over Zionism - Algemeiner - February 24th, 2022
- Inside the Unraveling of American Zionism - The New York Times - February 11th, 2022
- How Judaism and Zionism Helped Me Find Myself - The Times of Israel - February 11th, 2022
- A view from the ground in Ukraine | Paul Anticoni | The Blogs - Jewish News - February 11th, 2022
- 'I am exhausted by Israel' hear Sylvain Cypel on the risk to Jews of supporting the 'thug nation' - Mondoweiss - February 11th, 2022
- Opinion: Dont be fooled. Zionism is an Indigenous rights movement and being anti-Zionist is antisemitic. - The San Diego Union-Tribune - December 14th, 2021
- 'Toxic atmosphere of hatred.' USC faculty outraged over response to student's tweets - Los Angeles Times - December 14th, 2021
- Product of Zionism is 'Apartheid, plain and simple', says Israeli publisher - Middle East Monitor - December 14th, 2021
- When battling 'progressive madness' is more important than saving lives - Haaretz - December 14th, 2021
Comments