Labour antisemitism must be confronted with nuance, clarity and empathy – LabourList
Posted By admin on December 5, 2020
The recent publication of the Equality and Human Rights Commission investigation reconfirmed what many of us have been arguing for some time: that antisemitism is a real issue in the Labour Party, that requires serious confrontation.
Antisemitism in left-wing and radical movements is not new, dating back to at least the mid-19th century. One of the oldest themes of antisemitism, the conflation of Jews with money and finance, was incorporated into some early critiques of capitalism. Since the 2008 financial crash, conspiracy-based critiques of capitalism, which often demonise particular Jewish figures, have had a resurgence.
This has happened most prominently on the far right, including via Hungarian Prime Minister ViktorOrbns promotion of conspiracy theories about George Soros, and Donald Trumps campaign ads that overlaid footage of Jewish figures from the financial sector with narration about global special interest groups but also on the left, including in sections of movements such as Occupy.
Antisemitism on the left has also manifested in certain critiques of Israel and Zionism, which radically overstate Israels role and power, and allege a powerful or even controlling Zionist influence on world affairs. The late Moishe Postone, a Marxist academic who wrote extensively about antisemitism on the left, called this form of anti-Zionism the anti-imperialism of fools: a version of anti-imperialism that makes Zionism central to, and synonymous with, world imperialism.
The presence of these ideas on the left significantly predates Jeremy Corbyns leadership of the Labour Party, and there is not one quick fix to uproot them. The publication of the EHRC report could have been an opportunity to discuss these issues and turn the page on how antisemitism in the Labour Party is dealt with. However, so far this necessary process has been obstructed by vicious infighting.
Jeremys statement on the day of the EHRC report was ill-advised. But the decision to suspend him and remove the whip was, I believe, unjust and lacking due process. When we should be coming together to tackle antisemitism and reach out to Jewish communities who of course are not monolithic, and contain lots of different experiences and opinions we again end up fighting each other instead.
Party members feel strongly and want to do something about the situation. Many are putting motions to their Constituency Labour Party (CLPs). I support the right of party members to express concerns about due process and natural justice, and to express solidarity with Jeremy and I believe a blanket ban is wrong for this reason. Neither do I support the threat of suspending CLPs for hearing such motions.
However, it is also the case that officers of the party have legal duties with regard to the EHRC report. It is important that, when we discuss the situation, we separate the issue of fairness for Jeremy from those of the general issues of the EHRC report and wider problem of antisemitism.
When this separation does not take place, I am concerned that many Jewish members feel unwelcome and, yes, unsafe as a result of the way that debates relating to antisemitism are often conducted and handled at CLP level. We have a duty to protect the wellbeing of all Jewish members and ensure they feel welcome and included in everything we do in our local parties. After all, how democratic can a debate or discussion be said to be if many Jewish members do not feel able or safe to attend in the first place?
Tackling antisemitism and implementing the EHRC recommendations must be at the forefront of our minds and form a bare minimum in terms of the basis for any further or related discussions. The position of our side of the party, or short-term accumulation of political capital, should not come into it.
I appreciate that this balance between democracy, freedom of expression and inclusivity is a difficult one for us all to navigate, and that we might not always get it right. I include myself in this. In any case, contributions that are antisemitic or deny or downplay the existence of antisemitism in the party can never be acceptable and must always be challenged, and we should all take responsibility for this. In particular, it is the responsibility of CLP chairs and other party agents to intervene and to ensure a safe space where all party members feel comfortable and welcome.
A transparent disciplinary and complaints process, that ensures due process for both complainant and accused, is essential for making the party a hospitable and accessible environment for all its members. However, disciplinary measures are in themselves an insufficient way of tackling antisemitism on the left, given that it often comes not from a place of hatred or conscious hostility towards all Jewish people, but ignorance about common tropes that have been used against Jews, and why they can be discriminatory or hurtful.
Confronting antisemitism in the party means mobilising a large cross-section of the membership in an effort of political education, and convincing members as yet unsure about the issues of a political common sense that rejects these tropes. This requires the ability of members to discuss these issues in an atmosphere of mutual respect, and it is a great shame that the current atmosphere in the party doesnt enable such conversations. Thats why a timetable of training, education and any changes to disciplinary measures needs to be communicated to CLPs as soon as possible.
Admirably, some local parties have taken it upon themselves, without national resources or support from party officials, to arrange training on antisemitism. As one of the organisers of Sheffield Heeley CLPs education series wrote on LabourList: In recent years, the party has waxed lyrical about political education but actually done very little Here, we have tried a more participatory and discursive approach. It has, we believe, allowed us to cut through the often fraught arguments about antisemitism on the left and grapple with the complexities of the issue on their own terms. While we would not claim to have all the answers, we are proud of what we have achieved and urge other comrades to follow suit.
The national party should support other local parties in rolling out similar programmes. Until the party makes a serious turn to consistent political education (and not only on this issue), we will be unable to establish the robust, critical, rational political culture one that rejects antisemitism, conspiracy theories, and bigotries of all types and ensures that we are effective in arguing for the democratic, internationalist, socialist policies our party should advance.
Its tempting in these emotive debates to pick a side and refuse to listen to one another, when what we need is nuance, clarity and empathy. Its not a contradiction to fully support the recommendations of the EHRC report, to believe Jeremys statement was ill-advised and to oppose the way he has been treated. Communicating the idea that more than one thing can be true at the same time is difficult to navigate particularly on social media platforms where there is a decided lack, and even deliberate removal of, any nuance.
I know I am not alone in my determination to move on from this period. We have a Tory government mishandling the coronavirus crisis, an economic recession that is about to bite hard and a new round of brutal public spending cuts to fight. I still believe that the left of the party, as well as the party as a whole, can come out of this dark episode stronger and more united, but only if we are willing to be crystal clear on the acceptance and implementation of the EHRC report in full and are determined to do the hard work to contribute to the party being a safe and welcoming place for all members.
Read more:
Labour antisemitism must be confronted with nuance, clarity and empathy - LabourList
- Facebook warned against making Zionism protected category 8min - PRESSTV - February 26th, 2021
- Revisiting the Jewish Question | New Voices - New Voices - February 26th, 2021
- At Zionist hero's memorial, Netanyahu invokes Purim to threaten Iran - Cleveland Jewish News - February 26th, 2021
- Zionist regime to pay price for its miscalculations: Cmdr. - Mehr News Agency - English Version - February 26th, 2021
- Action urged over Bristol academic who called to 'end Zionism as an ideology' - Jewish News - February 19th, 2021
- Anti-Semitism accusations used in attempt to prevent Ken Loach speaking at Oxford University - WSWS - February 19th, 2021
- Attack on the Synagogue in Spokane and the rise of Anti-Semitism - Bulletin - February 19th, 2021
- MPs tell Bristol it is giving 'green light to anti-Jewish incitement' - The Tab - February 19th, 2021
- Pressure mounts on Bristol Uni over academic accused of 'antisemitic tropes' - Jewish News - February 19th, 2021
- The Charedi Rabbi Who Changed His Mind On Zionism: An Interview With Rabbi Moshe Lichtman - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - February 19th, 2021
- I'm tired of waiting for my uni to act against conspiratorial hatred - Jewish News - February 19th, 2021
- LETTERS: Wise up, CA progressives; Hooray for Dr. Fauci; etc. - The Jewish News of Northern California - February 19th, 2021
- Canada should say no to racism at the United Nations - iPolitics.ca - February 19th, 2021
- IfNotNow smears IHRA definition as a 'threat' to progressivism - JNS.org - February 19th, 2021
- Facebook might censor criticism of Zionists. Thats dangerous - The Guardian - February 16th, 2021
- Lost letter on Zionism from Father of the Chinese Nation surfaces - The Jerusalem Post - February 16th, 2021
- California progressives get pushback on Zionism 'litmus test' J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - February 16th, 2021
- Why are Jewish groups fighting the IHRA antisemitism definition? -opinion - The Jerusalem Post - February 16th, 2021
- Why the success of Israel's strategy to silence critics is far from assured - Middle East Eye - February 16th, 2021
- Pro-Zionist letter by 'father of modern China' Sun Yat-Sen resurfaces in Israel - Cleveland Jewish News - February 16th, 2021
- Father of the Chinese nation supported Zionism | IJN - Intermountain Jewish News - February 16th, 2021
- Likud alliance with Religious Zionist party is unholy - editorial - The Jerusalem Post - February 16th, 2021
- Masorti Movement warns JNF move to buy West Bank land may endanger fund - The Times of Israel - February 16th, 2021
- Netanyahu: Kahanist wont be in my government - The Jerusalem Post - February 16th, 2021
- Reform threatens KKL-JNF with High Court petition over West Bank purchase - The Jerusalem Post - February 16th, 2021
- Activist Marc Lamont Hill Says Black Lives Matter Supports the 'Dismantling of the Zionist Project' - Algemeiner - February 16th, 2021
- Portugal hero of 1974 revolution shares antisemitic theories on Twitter - The Jerusalem Post - February 16th, 2021
- Iran may be more democratic than the U.S. nowadays - Tehran Times - February 16th, 2021
- The bad faith behind Zionist activists latest try to win the left - Forward - February 7th, 2021
- Bayit Yehudi is over - Does their public need a party anymore? - The Jerusalem Post - February 7th, 2021
- Israel and the Temple Mount's five Muslim rivals - JNS.org - February 7th, 2021
- Working With 28. Jun, A United Nations Consultant And Forbes Nonprofit Council Member - Severna Park Voice - February 6th, 2021
- The incredible life of David Carll and his five generations who've raised families on his property - KABC-TV - February 6th, 2021
- Civil Society and the Question of Palestine - NGO Action News 4 February 2021 - occupied Palestinian territory - ReliefWeb - February 6th, 2021
- Facebook is getting pulled into a fight about the politics of Israel - The Verge - February 6th, 2021
- The Threat of Linking Zionism with Christianity in Iraq - International Christian Concern - February 6th, 2021
- Facebook draws ire after employee says the site could police the term 'Zionists' - thejewishchronicle.net - February 6th, 2021
- Fatah: elections will be held in Jerusalem against the Zionist entity's will - Middle East Monitor - February 6th, 2021
- Farewell to Ezra Nawi, a Mizrahi Jew who refused to live by Zionism's rules - +972 Magazine - February 6th, 2021
- Far-right parties led by Smotrich and Ben Gvir, a Kahane disciple, join forces - The Times of Israel - February 6th, 2021
- Who raised $280 million at $1.4 billion valuation and is Zionist an offensive term? - CTech - February 6th, 2021
- Professor Pushing Conspiracy Theories at University of Leeds Has Got to Go - Jewish Journal - February 6th, 2021
- BDS Might Use 'Non-violent Means' Against Israel, But It Is 'Very Violent In Its Ends' - CBN News - February 6th, 2021
- 'Totalitarian' school renaming; Equating twerps with Nazis; Enjoy your plastic straws! J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - February 6th, 2021
- Club Z Summit Discusses Shifting the Zionist Narrative - Jewish Journal - January 26th, 2021
- Normalize this! | Susan M. George | The Blogs - The Times of Israel - January 26th, 2021
- Nathan Thrall calls out J St and other liberal Zionists for enabling apartheid Mondoweiss - Mondoweiss - January 26th, 2021
- With Biden, Israel has a true Zionist in the White House - Ynetnews - January 26th, 2021
- How the Israeli flag became a symbol for white nationalists - +972 Magazine - January 26th, 2021
- ASUCR tables bill aimed to have UCR adopt the IHRA definition of anti-Semitism - Highlander Newspaper - January 26th, 2021
- Banned Anti-Zionist Student Group at Fordham University Will Appeal Ruling to Highest Court in New York State - Algemeiner - January 26th, 2021
- Grapevine, January 24, 2021: What to expect in 2021 - The Jerusalem Post - January 26th, 2021
- UC Merced Professor Who Tweeted of 'IsraHell' and Zionist 'World Domination' Will Not Teach Spring Semester After Outcry - Algemeiner - January 26th, 2021
- Coming to terms with my year of Bashert - The Jerusalem Post - January 26th, 2021
- Here's a course in anti-Zionist musicology - Slipped Disc - January 18th, 2021
- US-Zionist axis trying to disintegrate Islamic nations - Mehr News Agency - English Version - January 18th, 2021
- The Battle Over Jewish Students and the IHRA Definition of Antisemitism - Algemeiner - January 18th, 2021
- Pompeo accused Iran to gain Zionists support in 2024 election - Mehr News Agency - English Version - January 18th, 2021
- Trump's parting gift to Israel - Middle East Monitor - January 18th, 2021
- This week in history: January 18-24 - WSWS - January 18th, 2021
- Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Was A Zionist - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - January 18th, 2021
- Report: New bleak forecast says Israel could see large new COVID wave in March - The Times of Israel - January 18th, 2021
- A Conversation on A Critical Political Economy of the Middle East and North Africa (14 Jan) - Jadaliyya - January 18th, 2021
- Moroccan Islamist groups reject normalizing ties with Israel - Reuters - December 16th, 2020
- At US Jewish anti-Zionist group anti-Semitism panel, speakers say they love Jews - The Times of Israel - December 16th, 2020
- Opinion | The real lesson in the Roald Dahl apology? Anti-Zionists hate Jews. - Forward - December 16th, 2020
- The fulfilment of the Zionist vision - Australian Jewish News - December 16th, 2020
- Turkish media vows to take over Tel Aviv, calls opposition terrorists - The Jerusalem Post - December 16th, 2020
- Hanukkahs lesson about antisemitism on the Left - Forward - December 16th, 2020
- Equating Zionism With White Supremacy in the Age of Trump - The Jewish Voice - December 16th, 2020
- Doha, Muscat oppose tie normalization with Zionist Regime - Mehr News Agency - English Version - December 16th, 2020
- The People of Israel's Hanukkah Gift to themselves - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - December 16th, 2020
- Zionist regime has no place in future of region - Mehr News Agency - English Version - December 16th, 2020
- The Trump Administration is Cracking Down Against a Global Movement to Boycott Israel. Heres What You Need to Know About BDS - TIME - December 5th, 2020
- Christian Zionists leaving their legacy on the way out - People's World - December 5th, 2020
- The terrifying marriage of convenience between Israel and evangelical Zionists - Forward - December 5th, 2020
- A Young John F. Kennedy's Unimpressive Musings on Nazi Germany and Zionism - Mosaic - December 5th, 2020
- Progressive Zionists warn of 'grave challenges' for the left in Israel - Jewish News - December 5th, 2020
- Zionist Heroine Hannah Senesh's Archives Get Home in Israel's National Library - The Media Line - December 5th, 2020
- UK Labour leadership tells Zionist meeting that thousands of party members face expulsion - WSWS - December 5th, 2020
Comments