Patriots Remember to Forget: Omri Boehm and the Collapse of Liberal Zionism – Dissident Voice
Posted By admin on October 7, 2021
Summer is over in Israel and so too the holiday season that includes Yom Kippur and Sukkot with their accompanying prayers of remembrance. Memory is integral to most Jewish holidays. The readings at Passover and the lighting of candles at Hanukkah are collective acts of remembrance. The importance of remembering has always been central to Jewish self-identity. As Jonathan Safran Foer would have it: Jews have six senses. Touch, taste, sight, smell, hearing memory.
But here there are also holidays specific to the State of Israel, traditions linked to Zionist history. These include Remembrance Day for Fallen Soldiers, Jerusalem Day which celebrates the reunification of Jerusalem, and Independence Day. This is not to mention other days marked in the calendar to honour Zionist icons such as Herzl, Ben Gurion, Jabotinsky, and Rabin. And, of course, there is Holocaust Remembrance Day. In Israel, collective remembrance linked to a sense of national identity and a dominant narrative of history is ritualised and institutionalised; the days are sacred milestones in the calendar year. Nakba Day, as commemorated by Palestinians, is not one of them.
Collective memory is key to the argument of Omri Boehms new book, Haifa Republic A Democratic Future for Israel (New York Review of Books), which applies the ideas of Ernst Renan concerning nationhood to the Israeli-Palestinian context. Boehms work explores memory and history but is also concerned with the future, hence the subtitle. It can be considered a significant contribution to an increasingly vocal but still marginal strand of thought on the Israeli/Jewish left. The likes of Peter Beinart, Avraham Burg and organisations like BTselem are looking beyond the illusion of the two-state solution. In the light of demographic reality, the Nation-State Law, and the permanency of occupation and oppression, the word apartheid is being used more openly, albeit within the echo chambers of liberal thought.
This shift is in part a response to what Boehm identifies as a Gramscian crisis of intellectual leadership on the left in Israel. He offers the likes of Amos Oz and David Grossman as examples of those guilty of ignoring de facto annexation in pursuing the intellectual cul-de-sac of Oslo and the two-state solution. Like the current political leadership of the left in Israel, they are complicit in allowing a political reality based on Jewish supremacy to come about. With its choice to designate the occupation as Israels original sin, a wrong turning made in 1967, liberal Zionism has supressed the Nakba, according to Boehm. His book is a rejection of a way of thinking that has led to apartheid and is, at the same time, an exploration of a possible way forward for Zionism.
An Israeli and a professor of philosophy at The New School in New York, Boehm puts forward a vision of a federal binational future for Israel-Palestine in Haifa Republic. There is nothing new here. In fact, Boehm emphasises that this has been a line of thought in Zionism from its beginnings. But Boehms interesting contribution is to foreground the role that memory plays in sustaining the current situation the reality of an apartheid where citizens of Israel can live and vote anywhere between the river and the sea (bar Gaza) whilst Palestinians are denied basic rights. Boehm references Spinozas ideas concerning memory as a divisive force an agent of myth, ideology, religion, and irrational thought. Memory, as Spinoza had it, is the origin of conflict, violence, and war, never of enlightenment, democracy, or peace. Boehms vision for a democratic future for Israel-Palestine entails the act of forgetting alongside remembering.
For Boehm, the notion of remembering to forget is key to the way forward. He recalls Renans idea of the nation as a daily plebiscite that membership of a nation is a matter of continually choosing to belong. That choice of belonging cannot happen without a willingness to forget those things which have the potential to divide citizens. Willingness to forget therefore becomes a patriotic duty. This forgetting, Boehm stresses, is not Stalinist airbrushing, nor erasure. Remembering to forget entails the act of recalling and recognising history so as to set aside those things that divide.
His analysis in terms of the context of Israel-Palestine is that Israelis remember to remember as in the annual days of remembrance above but forget to forget. If a Holocaust messianism that places Israel beyond universalist politics and moral critique is not forgotten in this sense, Israelis and Palestinians cannot escape the status quo. And if the Nakba is not remembered, it cannot be forgotten. Despite some modest steps in the right direction, that particular part of Israels history has no significant presence on the school curriculum, and Naftali Bennetts current policy of shrinking the conflict encourages a continued widespread lack of engagement with a history of conquest and occupation.
Boehms vision depends upon both sides adopting a dialectical politics of memory and forgetting in relation to both Holocaust and Nakba. This is not an argument for ahistoricism, nor a pointless debate about equivalency between the Nakba and the Holocaust. It is an argument for acknowledging and then looking beyond the suffering of Jews and Palestinians to find a way forward. Boehm cites a speech on Holocaust Memorial Day in 2010 by Knesset member Ahmad Tibi, a Palestinian and Israeli citizen. On that day, Tibi chose to stay silent about the Nakba to express solidarity, to remember together with Jews. Boehm presents this as an example of leadership in terms of remembering to forget.
Boehms position is avowedly neither anti- nor post-Zionist. In contrast to others, he has no wish to abandon Zionism. He instead attempts to reinvigorate the politics of a binational state as a Zionist program consistent with Israels founding fathers. Boehm recruits a number of these to the cause: Herzl, no less, but also Ahad HaAm, Jabotinsky, Begin, even a young Ben Gurion. There is a highly selective emphasis on early Zionist binationalism in Haifa Republic, but this is not completely without foundation. The influential pre-state Zionist thinker Ahad HaAm, as Palestinian historian Nur Masalha has pointed out, always acknowledged that Palestine was anything but an empty land and was critical of the ethnocentricity of early political Zionism. Boehms Haifa Republic vision is itself based on an autonomy proposal of Menachem Begin approved by the Knesset in 1977.
He draws a distinction between nationalism and patriotism in his attempt to rescue Zionism from its collapse into its hard-right Revisionist interpretation, seeking to link it to ideas of self-determination rather than sovereignty. Boehm envisions a transformation of Zionism into something greater than a commitment to a Jewish state. One might question the effort to rehabilitate something that many consider too toxic, beyond redemption. But if there is to be any realistic, volitional movement away from nationalism towards Jewish self-determination within a federal structure belonging to all its citizens, Zionism cannot be unmade, but only recast. People are not going to give up their flags and grand narratives easily. Haifa Republic is a passionate argument for a future for a Zionism that is otherwise doomed, as Boehm (referencing Begin) puts it, within a twenty-first-century Rhodesia.
Rather than Rhodesia, Boehm uses the mixed city of Haifa as a symbol of his binational vision. It is tempting to point out the fragility of current examples of coexistence as evidenced by the country-wide riots during this years Operation Guardian of the Walls. It could also be said that a single speech by Ahmad Tibi represents thin evidence for a willingness to remember to forget by public figures on both sides. But the point, I suppose, is the example set. And the vision. Boehm anticipates charges of deluded, leftist optimism and so his telling choice of epigraph for Haifa Republic is the Herzl mantra, If you will it, it is no dream. His vision of a liberal, democratic Haifa Republic of all its citizens is, he argues, not messianic but utopian. As increasing numbers are recognising, the status quo is the unsustainable illusion. Ignoring this fact, Boehm writes, is akin to denying global warming.
The Hebrew word meaning remember, zachor, appears almost two hundred times in the Bible. Memory is sacred to all who live between the Jordan and the Mediterranean. No-one has a monopoly. Haifa Republic recognises the importance of remembrance, but it also represents an injunction to wilfully forget. This act is envisioned as part of an individuals continually renewed contract with a future democratic state of all its citizens. Boehm refuses to give up on Zionism, but he is not preaching to the converted. In proposing a nation built on choosing to belong rather than culture, tradition, or blood, he is issuing a challenge to a broken ideology from within.
This article was posted on Wednesday, October 6th, 2021 at 9:33am and is filed under Book Review.
Follow this link:
Patriots Remember to Forget: Omri Boehm and the Collapse of Liberal Zionism - Dissident Voice
- Biden Said it Best: You Don't Have to Be Jewish to Be a Zionist - Jewish Journal - August 6th, 2022
- ED launches Title VI investigation into USC - Inside Higher Ed - August 1st, 2022
- 'I Solemnly Demand That Anti-Zionism Be Banned in France,' Parliamentary Deputy Declares - Algemeiner - August 1st, 2022
- Editor Who Pushed Anti-Zionism Gets a Promotion at New York Times - Algemeiner - August 1st, 2022
- Zionism And The Power To Rule Over Others - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - August 1st, 2022
- In The Zionist Megiddo Prison - Countercurrents.org - August 1st, 2022
- An idea of inclusive India - Business Standard - July 10th, 2022
- Roadmap from critics of Israel sends chill through Jewish community - The Boston Globe - June 26th, 2022
- I am a Jewish Crimson Editor, and I See the Writing on the Wallof Resistance | Opinion - Harvard Crimson - June 26th, 2022
- Review of Judaism 3.0: Judaism's Transformation To Zionism - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - June 26th, 2022
- BDS-promoted mapping project is antisemitic and must be condemned - The Boston Globe - June 14th, 2022
- A Journey to June 1967 and Back: On the Fabricated Narratives of Zionism - Palestine Chronicle - June 14th, 2022
- Were Early Zionists Terrorists? - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - June 14th, 2022
- 100 years ago this month: When Congress embraced Zionismunanimously - JNS.org - June 10th, 2022
- The Soviet origins of left-wing anti-Zionism - JNS.org - June 10th, 2022
- Israel's Destruction Is Championed at the University of Chicago - Algemeiner - June 10th, 2022
- Anti-Zionism is a genocidal ideology | Eyal Bitton | The Blogs - June 4th, 2022
- The Silver Platter - (Silver Salver) Nathan Alterman - Poem - June 4th, 2022
- Zionism, Policing and Empire: A dispatch from the Mapping Project - Mondoweiss - June 4th, 2022
- Review of Legacy of Empire: Britain, Zionism and the Creation of Israel - Middle East Forum - June 2nd, 2022
- Zionism of Strength and Humility | Andy Blumenthal | The Blogs - The Times of Israel - June 2nd, 2022
- First Zionist Congress - Wikipedia - May 27th, 2022
- Statement in Support of The Harvard Crimson and Palestinian Liberation | Opinion - Harvard Crimson - May 27th, 2022
- New book: A 'Queer, Disabled' early Zionist illustrates 'roads not taken' J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - May 25th, 2022
- Group reports record tally of antisemitic incidents in 2021 - ABC News - April 29th, 2022
- Why Did an Antisemitic Christian Zionist Have the Chutzpah to Declare That He'd Be Leading a Holocaust March? - Religion Dispatches - April 29th, 2022
- The Babylonian Talmud - Zionism Exposed - April 20th, 2022
- LIVE EVENT - War, Conflict, and Academic Freedom (21 April) - Jadaliyya - April 20th, 2022
- The cause, and the goal, of Israeli violence - Al Jazeera English - April 20th, 2022
- 67 years after his death, Albert Einstein's true relationship to Judaism and Zionism - St. Louis Jewish Light - April 20th, 2022
- Antisemitism and Anti-Zionism on the College Campus - jewishboston.com - April 20th, 2022
- Why is this night and this year different than all other nights? - Wisconsin Examiner - April 16th, 2022
- Temple Israel series to focus on antisemitism, anti-Zionism - Cleveland Jewish News - April 16th, 2022
- Controversy Over Israel Studies At University Of Washington Did Not Have To Happen - Forbes - April 13th, 2022
- Wine-washing the Israeli occupation - Al Jazeera English - April 13th, 2022
- My Zionist Hagadah | Jeffrey Levine | The Blogs - The Times of Israel - April 13th, 2022
- Canary Mission Report Highlights Antisemitism Among Supporters of USC Student Senator Who Tweeted I Want to Kill Every Motherf---ing Zionist - Jewish... - March 29th, 2022
- Yet another 'apartheid' report builds pressure on liberal Zionists to recognize 'lived reality' of Palestinians - Mondoweiss - March 26th, 2022
- Students For Justice In Palestine: J Street Is The Gateway For Jewish Anti-Zionists - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - March 26th, 2022
- How Owen Jones learned to stop worrying and love Zionism - The Electronic Intifada - March 24th, 2022
- Judaic Studies begins Zionism lecture series with guest ... - March 8th, 2022
- Foreign Fighters and Fellow Travelers: Right-Wing Extremism in Australia and the United States - Lawfare - March 8th, 2022
- The crisis in Ukraine exposes the hypocrisy of Israel and its Zionist allies - Middle East Monitor - February 26th, 2022
- Iran: Believers To Begin Prison Sentences For spreading ... - February 24th, 2022
- New Historians - Wikipedia - February 24th, 2022
- 'We Can't Shut Off One of Our Identities': Jewish SUNY Students Decry 'Exclusion' From Sexual Assault Awareness Group Over Zionism - Algemeiner - February 24th, 2022
- Inside the Unraveling of American Zionism - The New York Times - February 11th, 2022
- How Judaism and Zionism Helped Me Find Myself - The Times of Israel - February 11th, 2022
- A view from the ground in Ukraine | Paul Anticoni | The Blogs - Jewish News - February 11th, 2022
- 'I am exhausted by Israel' hear Sylvain Cypel on the risk to Jews of supporting the 'thug nation' - Mondoweiss - February 11th, 2022
- Opinion: Dont be fooled. Zionism is an Indigenous rights movement and being anti-Zionist is antisemitic. - The San Diego Union-Tribune - December 14th, 2021
- 'Toxic atmosphere of hatred.' USC faculty outraged over response to student's tweets - Los Angeles Times - December 14th, 2021
- Product of Zionism is 'Apartheid, plain and simple', says Israeli publisher - Middle East Monitor - December 14th, 2021
- Can a new word 'Zionophobia' clarify the debate over Israel? J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - December 14th, 2021
- When battling 'progressive madness' is more important than saving lives - Haaretz - December 14th, 2021
- Can religious Zionism overcome its addiction to state power? - November 30th, 2021
- Benzion Netanyahu - Wikipedia - November 30th, 2021
- The UK government is on the wrong side of history again - Aljazeera.com - November 27th, 2021
- Margins of History: On Shay Hazkani's Dear Palestine: A Social History of the 1948 War - lareviewofbooks - November 25th, 2021
- Proud Zionist Who Immigrated From South Africa Killed by Hamas Gunman in Jerusalem's Old City - Algemeiner - November 25th, 2021
- Readers Write: Elaborating on the significance of Great Neck adopting IHRA's definition of antisemitism - Readers Write - The Island Now - November 8th, 2021
- Hannah Arendt and Isaiah Berlin Review: Clash of the Titans - The Wall Street Journal - November 8th, 2021
- My Fellow Progressives Are Always Asking Me if Anti-Zionism is Antisemitic. Here's What I Tell Them - Jewish Exponent - November 8th, 2021
- Leaders of anti-Zionist cult Lev Tahor to stand trial in New York - The Jerusalem Post - November 8th, 2021
- Singer who performed at anti-Zionist event wants to represent Israel - The Jerusalem Post - November 8th, 2021
- There is no right or left in Israel, just Zionism and non-Zionism - Haaretz - October 18th, 2021
- Letters to the editor October 18, 2021: Can Israel learn from New York? - The Jerusalem Post - October 18th, 2021
- Lies Are Being Told About Sally Rooney Because She Refuses to Ignore Israeli Apartheid - The Intercept - October 18th, 2021
- Israel is approaching the next Nakba - Haaretz - October 18th, 2021
- Origins and Evolution of Zionism - Foreign Policy Research ... - October 15th, 2021
- What is Zionism? Meaning explained - The US Sun - October 15th, 2021
- Smotrich at Knesset: Ben-Gurion should have finished the job, thrown out Arabs - The Times of Israel - October 15th, 2021
- Thanking God for 50 years of living in Israel - The Jerusalem Post - October 15th, 2021
- Personal Letters by Rabbi Known as 'Hazon Ish' Come to National Library of Israel - Algemeiner - October 15th, 2021
- Beirut will leave behind 'Zionist-backed seditions' - Mehr News Agency - English Version - October 15th, 2021
- Why are Australia and its media so fearful of debate on Israels treatment of Palestinians? - The Guardian - October 13th, 2021
- An Open Letter to Sally Rooney RE: Boycotting Israel - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - October 13th, 2021
- What happened to Hamas rebrand? - The Jerusalem Post - October 13th, 2021
- Philanthropist Eitan Neishlos: 'Everyone here has something to give' - The Jerusalem Post - October 13th, 2021
- Activists, scholars call to end weaponising anti-Semitism ahead of Holocaust Remembrance event in Sweden - Middle East Monitor - October 13th, 2021
Comments