Failure in the Art Undermines any Reasonable Expectation of Success – JD Supra
Posted By admin on November 8, 2021
In University of Strathclyde v. Clear-Vu Lighting LLC,[2020-2243], (November 4, 2021) the Federal Circuit reversed the PTABs determination that held unpatentable as obvious claims 1-4 of U.S. Patent No. 9,839,706, directed to photoinactivation of Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) and other Gram-positive bacteria without using a photosensitizing agent.
The Board determined that claims 1 and 3 of the 706 patent would have been obvious over Ashkenazi in view of Nitzan, and that claims 2 and 4 would have been obvious in further view of Jones. (The names Ashkenazi, Nitzan, and Jones refer to scholarly articles.) The Board found that Ashkenazi and Nitzan teach or suggest all the limitations of claims 1 and 3, and that a person of ordinary skill in the art would have been motivated to combine these two references and would have had a reasonable expectation of successfully doing so.
On appeal, Strathclyde challenges the Boards obviousness determination, arguing that the Board erred in finding that the combination of Ashkenazi and Nitzan teaches inactivating one or more Gram-positive bacteria without using a photosensitizer. It also asserts that the Boards finding of a reasonable expectation of success is not supported by substantial evidence. Whether the prior art discloses a claim limitation, whether a skilled artisan would have been motivated to modify or combine teachings in the prior art, and whether she would have had a reasonable expectation of success in doing so are questions of fact.
The Federal Circuit said that both parties agreed that most of the limitations found in claims 1 and 3 are disclosed by Ashkenazi or Nitzan, and that the only dispute is whether these references teach inactivating one of the claimed Gram-positive bacteria without using a photosensitizer. The Federal Circuit found that the Boards finding that this was taught by the combination of Ashkenazi and Nitzan is not supported by substantial evidence. The Federal Circuit said that all of Ashkenazis P. acnes cultures were grown in the presence of a photosensitizereither riboflavin alone, or riboflavin together with ALA. The Federal Circuti found nothing in Ashkenazi that discloses or suggests inactivating P. acnes, or any other bacteria, without using a photosensitizer.
The Federal Circuit noted that while Nitzan provides an example in which MRSA and other bacteria were exposed to blue light without ALA or any other photosensitizer, there is no evidence that Nitzan successfully achieved inactivation under this condition. The Federal Circuit noted that in finding that Nitzan did not anticipate claims 1 and 3, the Board found Clear-Vu failed to establish that Nitzans non-ALA MRSA demonstrated inactivation as required by the claims.
The Federal Circuit said that given neither Ashkenazi nor Nitzan teaches or suggests inactivation of any bacteria without using a photosensitizer, it failed to see why a skilled artisan would opt to entirely omit a photosensitizer when combining these references. The Federal Circuit said that the Board articulated no rational basisand it could discern nonefor combining Ashkenazis P. acnes experiments, which at all times used a photosensitizer, with Nitzans non-ALA MRSA experiment, which did not achieve inactivation, to arrive at an embodiment in which MRSA is inactivated by exposing it to 407420 nm blue light withoutusing a photosensitizer.
On this record, the Federal Circuit concluded that no reasonable fact finder could have found that the combination of Ashkenazi and Nitzan discloses inactivating one or more Gram-positive bacteria without using a photosensitizer.
Regarding whether there was a reasonable expectation of success, the Federal Circuit disagreed with the Boards finding that a skilled artisan would have expected that MRSA could be inactivated by blue light without using a photosensitizer due to the presence of at least some amount of naturally produced porphyrin in the bacteria. The Federal Circuit said that the only support for the finding was pure conjecture coupled with hindsight reliance on the teachings in the [challenged patent].
The Federal Circuit said that the Board, relying on Ashkenazis teaching that blue light may inactivate other bacterial cells that produce porphyrins, reasoned that because light-activated porphyrin molecules were shown in Ashkenazi to cause inactivation for P. acnes (even though Ashkenazis experiments applied a photosensitizer), the fact that MRSA has some level of endogenous porphyrin suggests to a skilled artisan that MRSA, too, would exhibit some amount of inactivation after exposure to 407420 nm blue light. But, the Federal Circuit said that there is simply no evidence of record at the time of the 706 patent to support this assumption.
The Federal Circuit said that the evidence of record, Nitzan and an earlier publication by Nitzan, showed the opposite. The data Dr. Nitzan reported would have indicated to a person of ordinary skill in the art that those natural levels are insufficient to inactivate MRSA using 407420 nm blue light without also using a photosensitizer.
Thus, the Federal Circuit found, not only is there a complete lack of evidence in the record that any bacteria were inactivated after exposure to 407420 nm blue light without using a photosensitizer, there is also evidence showing that others had failed to inactivate MRSAone of the claimed Gram-positive bacteriawithout using a photosensitizer, despite experimenting with different light doses and different wavelength ranges of blue light.
The Federal Circuit reaffirmed that absolute predictability of success is not required, only a reasonable expectation. However in the present case, where the prior art evidences only failures to achieve that at which the inventors succeeded, no reasonable fact finder could find an expectation of success based on the teachings of that same prior art.
Visit link:
Failure in the Art Undermines any Reasonable Expectation of Success - JD Supra
- Kishke: Unraveling the Gut-Deep Culinary Traditions of Ashkenazi ... - Aish - June 6th, 2023
- B.C. initiative aims to expand genetic screening for Ashkenazi Jewish people at risk of hereditary cancers - CBC.ca - May 29th, 2023
- Medical genetics of Jews - Wikipedia - March 20th, 2023
- Ashkenazi Jews Must Stop Identifying As White/European - February 27th, 2023
- What does it mean to be genetically Jewish? - the Guardian - February 16th, 2023
- Ashkenazi Jews Are Not Khazars. Heres The Proof. - The Forward - December 31st, 2022
- Bones yielding insights about Ashkenazi DNA in a German town built atop ... - December 25th, 2022
- 9. Race, ethnicity, heritage and immigration among U.S. Jews - December 23rd, 2022
- Khazar hypothesis of Ashkenazi ancestry - Wikipedia - December 20th, 2022
- We Were The Lucky Ones: Robin Weigert, Lior Ashkenazi Join Cast ... - November 19th, 2022
- Y-chromosomal Aaron - Wikipedia - October 23rd, 2022
- Wanted for work in Israel: pimps and Ashkenazi cooks - Haaretz - October 23rd, 2022
- Ashkenazi Jewish Heritage and Genetic Risk | OncoLink - October 17th, 2022
- Israeli needle-free alternative to amnio can detect thousands of mutations - The Times of Israel - October 17th, 2022
- Jamaican Organizations and B'nai Brith to Work Together to Highlight Little-Known Chapter of the Holocaust - bnaibrith.ca - October 17th, 2022
- Work remains on Tay-Sachs and other Ashkenazi genetic disorders J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - September 19th, 2022
- Canada's oldest Ashkenazi congregation just recovered a 100-year-old time capsule on their milestone anniversary weekend - The Canadian Jewish News - September 19th, 2022
- How to Celebrate Rosh Hashanah With the Help of London Restaurants This Year - Eater London - September 19th, 2022
- Pope criticised over running 'supermarket of religions' - TVP World - September 19th, 2022
- Want to know more about breast cancer and genetics? This Q&A will have all the answers - HerCanberra - September 19th, 2022
- They have their secret. Now I have a secret too: The story behind SumiLicious, the only Scarborough restaurant to receive a Michelin award - Toronto... - September 19th, 2022
- Trip notebook: Papal critics, an ambassador for Italian and sitting on the same level - Crux Now - September 19th, 2022
- Netanyahu poised to lead most rightwing government in Israeli history - Mondoweiss - September 19th, 2022
- Recap: Recent Advances in the Treatment of Metastatic Castration-Sensitive Prostate Cancer - Cancer Network - September 19th, 2022
- $55 million gift to Penn is aimed at stopping breast cancer before it starts - The Philadelphia Inquirer - September 16th, 2022
- The Pope Addresses The Heart Of The Belt & Road Initiative In Kazakhstan - Silk Road Briefing - September 16th, 2022
- Who will / should win the Ophirs? - Blog - The Film Experience - September 16th, 2022
- Lox block: UWS congregation takes beloved salmon off the menu, citing environmental concerns - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - September 11th, 2022
- Meet the Rabbi Who Ended 1300 Years of Ritual Humiliation - aish.com - Aish.com - September 11th, 2022
- Playing with Fragments - The Jewish Standard - September 11th, 2022
- All the Rosh Hashanah Gifts You Need - Kveller.com - September 11th, 2022
- A tour of what it means to be Christian in multicultural Kazakhstan - Travel Tomorrow - September 11th, 2022
- This Rosh Hashanah, fill up on symbolic dips, bites and small plates J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - September 8th, 2022
- This Missouri bagel shop went viral for its Talmud-inspired effort to feed the needy - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - September 8th, 2022
- Missouri bagel shop goes viral for effort to feed the needy J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - September 8th, 2022
- Radiocarbon dating only works halfway we may have the solution - PiPa News - September 8th, 2022
- Congress of World and Traditional Religions Leaders to be held at Palace of Independence - inform.kz/en - September 8th, 2022
- Israeli Terror Victim Teens Gifted Tefillin and Shabbat Candlesticks on Canadian Trip - Lubavitch.com - September 6th, 2022
- Taking inspiration from the Talmud to feed the needy - Australian Jewish News - September 6th, 2022
- New book explores the insane career of Syrian Jewish hustler Crazy Eddie Antar - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - August 25th, 2022
- UK man who survived concentration camp as baby finally learns his familys identity - The Times of Israel - August 25th, 2022
- Japanese American National Museum premieres cancer-battling directors film on pains of WWII incarceration camps - Yahoo News - August 25th, 2022
- Licorice Pizza to Galaxy Quest: the seven best films to watch on TV this week - The Guardian - August 20th, 2022
- Fascinating Details of Judean Shepherd's Life 6000 Years Ago Revealed by New Tech - Ancient Origins - August 20th, 2022
- The Pletzel of Paris and The Bread That Shares Its Name - aish.com - Aish.com - August 18th, 2022
- Archaeologists discover mosaic with inscription to Peter that may point to location of his home - The Christian Post - August 18th, 2022
- Wolfgang Petersen another celebrity to succumb to pancreatic cancer - Calgary Herald - August 18th, 2022
- A Cry in the Wilderness: How Jewish Organizations Can Help With Jewish Genetic Diseases - Jewish Journal - August 12th, 2022
- Azerbaijan's Minister of Youth and Sports meets with Chief Rabbi of Ashkenazi Jewish community in country - AZERTAC News - August 12th, 2022
- Czerny as the new Lustiger, the 'Jewish cardinal' and papal contender - Crux Now - August 12th, 2022
- Honoring the Jews of Jamaica | Jewish & Israel News Algemeiner.com - Algemeiner - August 12th, 2022
- Anne Frank, Arab-Jewish relations, karaoke in focus at upcoming Israeli film awards - The Times of Israel - August 12th, 2022
- Metas new chatbot is already parroting users prejudice and misinformation - Popular Science - August 12th, 2022
- Meet the Jews of color exploring what it means to be Black, Asian, Latino and Jewish - Forward - August 12th, 2022
- Jewish wilderness wedding featured animal-skin ketubah, harvest altar J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - August 12th, 2022
- Ashkenazi Jewish Panel: What It May Reveal About Your Genes - July 23rd, 2022
- At SFJFF opening night, we're all just happy to be back at the Castro J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - July 23rd, 2022
- Verimatrix and Harmonic Partner to Enable Streaming Content Protection at SaaS Speed - StreetInsider.com - July 23rd, 2022
- Russian cuisine has evolved in light of scarcity and isolation - KCRW - July 23rd, 2022
- Tina Sacks on racial inequality in health and feeling 'Jewish enough' - The Jewish News of Northern California - July 23rd, 2022
- Who serves the best kosher pizza in NYC? We found out - Forward - July 23rd, 2022
- Fight Over Fear: Ayesha Khan on the importance of mammograms in fighting breast cancer - FOX 5 DC - July 14th, 2022
- I was named after my uncle who was shot and killed. His Hebrew name is a privilege I dont bear lightly - Forward - July 14th, 2022
- Groups Launched to Help Jewish Couples with IVF Face Uncertain Landscape After Roe Reversal - Jewish Exponent - July 14th, 2022
- Tipping Point: Israel on the Brink The Brooklyn Rail - Brooklyn Rail - July 14th, 2022
- World Premiere of ASHKENAZI SEANCE to be Presented at The Brick This Month - Broadway World - July 10th, 2022
- Lentils Make the Best Fake Minced Meat - Lifehacker - July 10th, 2022
- Liberal Pakistani Writer And Nuclear Scientist Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy: 'European Jews Fleeing Hitler Were Far Less Welcome Than Muslims Are In Today's... - July 10th, 2022
- Book Appreciation: AB Yehoshua's "Mr Mani" -- A Great Work of Fiction - artsfuse.org - July 10th, 2022
- The secret Plymouth graveyard unearthed behind this door with the aid of Google and a box of old keys - Plymouth Live - July 10th, 2022
- Bustle's Guide To Abortion Care - Bustle - June 26th, 2022
- Op-Ed: A notebook with family recipes reminds me of Ukraines strength - Los Angeles Times - June 26th, 2022
- Hey Pandas, Who Has An Unusual Ethnic Background That Has Everyone Wondering What You're Mixed With? - Bored Panda - June 26th, 2022
- Pompe Diseases Enzyme Replacement Therapy (ERT) Market is predicted to increase at a high 7% CAGR ov - PharmiWeb.com - June 26th, 2022
- A Rare Tanach And The Ladino Renaissance - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - June 17th, 2022
- I Never Met My Jewish Father. Converting to Judaism Helped Me Forgive Him. Kveller - Kveller.com - June 17th, 2022
- Failing to Silence the Jewish Fiddle - Jewish Journal - June 17th, 2022
- The ADL, Progressives and White Nationalists - City Watch - June 17th, 2022
- Verimatrix Threat Defense Technology Wins 2022 Global Infosec Award - TechDecisions - June 17th, 2022
- Obituary Bernard Allan Lublin - The Henrico Citizen - Henrico Citizen - June 17th, 2022
Comments