Mizrahi-washing: The new face of Israeli propaganda – +972 Magazine
Posted By admin on June 26, 2020
Mizrahi Jews have received growing global attention over the last few years. More and more people are finally recognizing that not all Jews in Israel are of European descent, that many arrived from Middle Eastern and Muslim countries where they were religious minorities, and that successive generations have faced discrimination since arriving in the country.
There is no overstating the importance of this increased recognition, the result of decades of dedicated work by Mizrahi activists and scholars. Discrimination against Mizrahim in Israel is an often denied and understudied phenomenon, and raising awareness of their unique experiences and circumstances is a crucial step in fighting against Mizrahi marginalization.
As international attention has increased, however, it has also brought with it a new wave of Mizrahi voices who insist on utilizing their identity for the purposes of hasbara, or PR for the Israeli government. According to these views, recognizing Mizrahi history inevitably leads one to understand that Palestinians err in casting Israelis as privileged oppressors. This argument is misguided and misleading.
If the past decade saw the rise of pinkwashing (the emphasis on limited LGBTQ rights in Israel to depict the country as a modern, enlightened democracy), these new Mizrahi voices provide a window onto an emerging trend of Mizrahi-washing: using the Mizrahi narrative to try and better Israels image around the world under the guise of authenticity. In so doing, these activists are attempting to distance the countrys image from that of the white European colonizer, while situating Mizrahi Jews as the ultimate racialized victim in the region and utilizing their past and present marginalization as the decisive argument against Palestinian demands.
The trend of Mizrahi-washing has accelerated over the last few years, most notably as Mizrahi hasbara activists have tried to combat cross-movement solidarity between Palestinians and Black Americans. Over the last half decade, the Black Lives Matter movement has expressed its solidarity with the Palestinian struggle for freedom and justice, while Palestinians have similarly expressed their commitment to the struggle for racial justice in the United States.
Israelis and Palestinians protest in Jerusalem against the killing of Iyad Halak by Israeli Border Police as well as the killing of George Floyd by Minneapolis police, May 30, 2020. (Oren Ziv)
Support and similarities between the two groups were galvanized by the recent shooting and killing of Iyad al-Hallaq, a 32-year-old Palestinian man with autism, by Israeli Border Police less than a week after the police killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis. In demonstrations protesting the killing of al-Hallaq, activists held signs referencing Floyd and the BLM movement.
In light of this display, Nave Dromi, the Israeli director of the Middle East Forum and Israel Victory Project a conservative initiative dedicated to backing an Israel Victory over the Palestinians as the way to resolve the Arab-Israel conflict used a recent op-ed to argue against drawing any possible parallels between the experiences of Black Americans and those of Palestinians. Any attempt to discuss the Israeli occupation and oppression of Palestinians through a racial lens, Dromi writes, misses one crucial aspect: the existence of Mizrahi Jews. Acknowledging that not all Jews are white Europeans, she argues, should undermine any effort to hijack the U.S. conversation about race and apply it to the Israeli context.
Dromi is not alone. Hen Mazzig, another prominent hasbara activist, who was paid by pro-Israeli groups to tour campuses around the U.S., argued last year that recognizing the existence of Mizrahim in Israel derails attempts to frame the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in terms of race. Those who seek to do so, Mazzig argues, tend to define Israelis as Ashkenazi Jews alone, despite the fact that the majority of the country is comprised of Mizrahi Jews, of whom many were persecuted, attacked, and marginalized in the Muslim world prior to their arrival to Israel.
Both Dromi and Mazzig are correct in stating that Mizrahi Jews have historically suffered violence and displacement as religious minorities in their countries of origin. However, this somehow leads Mazzig to deny the power Israel possesses with regard to Palestinians, and Dromi to make the baseless claim that Mizrahim sometimes see an Arab Muslim privilege in a somewhat similar way that a person of color might see a white person in the U.S.
Yemenite immigrants to Israel at the Beit Lid Transit Camp, near Netanya, July 27, 1950. (Seymour Katcoff/GPO)
It is no wonder that both writers fixate on the past. Had the two of them chosen to honestly grapple with the present state of Mizrahi Jews, they might have been shocked to discover that most of them no longer live as minorities in the Muslim world but rather in Israel a Jewish country that actively discriminates against other minority groups. Furthermore, they would have seen that despite ongoing discrimination against Mizrahi Jews in Israel today, they are nonetheless significantly better off under Israeli rule than are Palestinians.
Arguments that utilize events such as the Farhud the 1941 massacre against Jews in Iraq to diminish the Palestinian claim for justice weaponize Mizrahi Jewish history against the Palestinian struggle. Such arguments are based on the extremely problematic conflation of hundreds of millions of people living in countries as diverse as Iraq, Iran, and Morocco under the umbrella term of the Muslim world. Only through a paradigm that views all Middle Eastern and North African populations as identical can one offset the oppression of Palestinians by citing the harm committed against Jews in Iraq hundreds of miles away and decades earlier. And, only by assuming that Palestinians in 2020 are completely interchangeable with anti-Jewish Iraqi mobs from over 70 years ago can one seriously claim that Mizrahi Jews see Palestinians today as privileged or somehow equivalent to white Americans.
One could easily mistake Dromi and Mazzigs attempts to introduce Mizrahi experiences and history into the larger global conversation as genuine advocacy on behalf of Mizrahim. But the narrative they promote actually works directly against Mizrahi interests, because race is not only relevant to the Palestinian context it is also a useful lens through which we can understand the story of Mizrahi Jews in Israel, as well as that of Ethiopian Jews, African asylum seekers, and numerous other disadvantaged communities.
While Mazzig states that Israel isnt a country of privileged and powerful white Europeans, the state was indeed founded on white European ideals with the declared hope of bringing Europe to the Middle East.[1] Understanding the role that race has historically played in the Zionist movement allows us to recognize the efforts made by Israels founders to convince the world that Israel is indeed a country of white Europeans. According to their own narrative, Israel was to form a portion of a rampart of Europe against Asia, an outpost of civilization as opposed to barbarism, in the words of Theodor Herzl, considered the father of the modern Zionist movement.
Israeli Jews protest for the recognition and investigation of the systematic kidnapping of Yemenite Jewish children by Israeli hospitals and institutions in the 1950s, Jerusalem, June 21, 2017. (Shiraz Grinbaum/Activestills.org)
This narrative, which casts non-Europeans as barbaric, has since powered much of the treatment that non-Europeans both Palestinians and Mizrahi Jews have suffered under the Israeli state. Informed by this mindset, Israeli leaders sent many Mizrahi Jews to live in squalid transit camps upon arriving in Israel, sometimes for years on end, in the belief that they did not need or deserve better.[2] Mothers were deemed unqualified to raise their own children,[3] and many children were subsequently transferred to boarding schools or foster care.[4] In some cases, Mizrahi babies, particularly children of new immigrants from Yemen, were forcibly taken from their families and never heard from again.
Mizrahi attempts to resist their treatment were violently put down by police, and led to their being labeled as pathologically aggressive and violent.[5] Even today, data reveals persistent educational, income, and employment gaps.[6] In order to tell the story of Mizrahi marginalization, one need not go back to 1940s Iraq. This remains the story of many Mizrahi Jews in Israel today.
Adopting a racial lens to study police violence can help us recognize the racist dynamics that allowed two Israeli police officers to kill Iyad al-Hallaq, including the complete disregard for Palestinian life, the immediate presumption of guilt and the sense of threat associated with the Palestinian body, and the assumption that the officers would likely get away with the killing.
This same lens can also help us understand the killings of Shahar Maman and Shirel Habura, two Mizrahi men who were shot dead by Israeli police in incidents that need not have ended their lives. It may also help explain the killing of Solomon Teka, an unarmed Ethiopian Israeli teenager who was shot by an off-duty police officer last year, sparking mass protests across the country by the Ethiopian Israeli community.
Ethiopians and supporters take part in a protest against police violence following the death of 19-year-old Ethiopian Israeli Solomon Teka who was shot and killed by an off-duty police officer, Tel Aviv, July 8, 2019. (Tomer Neuberg/Flash90)
An examination conducted last year revealed that between 2014-2019 almost all Israeli citizens killed by police were people of color. Out of 14 killed, nine were Palestinian, three were identified as Mizrahi, one was of Russian origin, and one was Ethiopian.
All of these incidents and data not only demonstrate the dispensability of non-white bodies and the violence embedded in regimes that are built around whiteness, they also allow us to draw important parallels between the violence against Black Americans and the kind deployed against people of color in Israel-Palestine.
Perhaps that is exactly what is so terrifying about these parallels: recognizing the role race plays in Israel-Palestine could begin to knock down the walls of separation that have been built between Mizrahi Jews and Palestinians walls that make it easier to control both.
Voices that seek to Mizrahi-wash Israels accountability for its actions and rewrite reality by casting Palestinians into the role of white supremacists are using the very idea of race to sabotage any possibility for racial justice. Doing so is an appropriation of Black and Mizrahi voices for the continued subjugation of Palestinians. It should be recognized as the propaganda it is.
____________________________________________________________________________
[1] Dafna Hirsch, We Are Here to Bring the West: Hygiene Education and Culture Building in the Jewish Society of Mandate Palestine (2014) (Hebrew).
[2] Discussing the need to provide better housing for Polish immigrants, Yehuda Braginsky of the Absorption Department is quoted saying: [w]ell take those houses which we have already allocated to the North Africans and the Yemenites and give them to the Poles In that same discussion, Zionist leader Itzhak Greenbaum also stated that . . . Instead of putting the Polish Jews in this situation [of harsh living conditions], it would be best to do it with the Jews of Turkey and Libya. That wont be hard for them. Tom Segev, 1949: The First Israelis 178 (Arlen N. Weinstein tran., 1998).
[3] Dafna Hirsch, see footnote 1; Benny Nurieli, The Children Must Be Saved: OSE and the Jews of North Africa, in Zionism and Empire 269 (Yehouda Shenhav ed., 2015) (Hebrew).
[4] Tammy Razi, Forsaken Children: The Backyard of Mandate Tel-Aviv (2009). Bias in decisions regarding the removal of children by the child welfare system was also found in recent years, see Guy Enosh & Taki Bayer-Topilsky, Reasoning and Bias: Heuristics in Safety Assessments and Placement Decisions for Children at Risk, 45 British Journal of Social Work 771 (2015).
[5] Sami Shalom Chetrit, The Mizrahi Struggle in Israel: Between Oppression and Liberation, Identification and Alternative, 19482003 48 (2004) (Hebrew).
[6] Yinon Cohen, Noah Lewin-Epstein & Amit Lazarus, Mizrahi-Ashkenazi Educational Gaps in the Third Generation, 59 Research in Social Stratification and Mobility (Feb. 2019); Tamar Kricheli-Katz, Issi Rosen-Avi & Neta Ziv, Hierarchy and Stratification in the Israeli Legal Profession, 52(2) Law & Society Rev. (2018)
Get Our Weekly Newsletter
Continue reading here:
Mizrahi-washing: The new face of Israeli propaganda - +972 Magazine
- Is There a Jewish Link to Cancer? - Atlanta Jewish Times - January 18th, 2021
- Early elections increase indicators of an existential threat to Israel - Middle East Monitor - January 18th, 2021
- For the first time, a Jew of color will lead pathbreaking diversity group Be'chol Lashon - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - January 18th, 2021
- For the first time, a Jew of color will lead Jewish diversity org Be'chol Lashon - The Jewish News of Northern California - January 18th, 2021
- Being a Black Jewish woman in America on Jan. 6 - The Jewish News of Northern California - January 18th, 2021
- New South Philly Shop Pays Homage to Traditional Jewish 'Appetizing Stores,' Features Artisanal Smoked Fish - Jewish Exponent - January 18th, 2021
- Is a Jew Allowed to Eat Synthetic Meat & Then Drink a Dairy Coffee? - Yeshiva World News - January 18th, 2021
- Beyond Chopped Liver Cookbook Gives Jewish Food a Healthy Makeover - jewishboston.com - January 18th, 2021
- Foreign Minister Gabi Ashkenazi will not run in Gantz's party - Haaretz.com - December 30th, 2020
- MK Cotler-Wunsh quits Blue and White, says shes committed to continue serving - The Times of Israel - December 30th, 2020
- TV report: Gantz, Ashkenazi considering departing politics - The Times of Israel - December 29th, 2020
- Common and rare variant prediction and penetrance of IBD in a large, multi-ethnic, health system-based biobank cohort - DocWire News - December 29th, 2020
- Thoughts on the attack on North Shore Hebrew Academys website - The Jewish Standard - December 23rd, 2020
- How can Israels left-wing parties win more Mizrahi votes? - The Jerusalem Post - December 23rd, 2020
- What will Israel's next government look like? It depends on us! - The Jerusalem Post - December 23rd, 2020
- Jon Ossoffs Letter to the Jewish Community - Atlanta Jewish Times - December 23rd, 2020
- Jews of color exist and heres why it matters - The Jerusalem Post - December 23rd, 2020
- Is Pakistan seeking to normalise ties with Israel? Here`s what new report says - Zee News - December 23rd, 2020
- 'Esau' Puts New Twist on Biblical Brotherhood - Jewish Exponent - December 23rd, 2020
- Treasures of Judaica From the Sassoon Family Collection - The Wall Street Journal - December 12th, 2020
- TV chef brings Mexican latkes and jalapeno matzah ball soup north of border - The Times of Israel - December 12th, 2020
- What are the ties that unite Spain and Israel? - opinion - The Jerusalem Post - December 12th, 2020
- Rapid and ongoing evolution of repetitive sequence structures in human centromeres - Science Advances - December 12th, 2020
- Morocco agrees to normalize ties with Israel in exchange for U.S. recognition of Western Sahara sovereignty - Haaretz - December 11th, 2020
- Ehud Olmert to 'Post': Women need to take on leadership roles in Israel - The Jerusalem Post - December 11th, 2020
- Author Joseph A. Levy's new book Forbidden Love is a moving story about love, friendship, and family for two New York professionals from different... - December 11th, 2020
- Israeli, Jordanian foreign ministers meet, with plenty of issues on their agenda - Al-Monitor - December 11th, 2020
- Ashkenazi: Netanyahu didn't mention budget once in his remarks - The Times of Israel - December 5th, 2020
- What Does the Jewish Last Name Epstein Mean? - Chabad.org - December 5th, 2020
- Films From a Vanished World - The Wall Street Journal - December 5th, 2020
- Israel and Jordan aim to thaw relations with secret meeting - Axios - December 4th, 2020
- Chanukah Foods From Around the World - Jewish Exponent - December 4th, 2020
- Bahrain minister to visit Israel, meet Netanyahu, Ashkenazi - The Times of Israel - December 4th, 2020
- Looking to the future from Izmirs glorious Jewish past - The Jerusalem Post - December 4th, 2020
- It's time to end the farce of this government - The Jerusalem Post - December 4th, 2020
- Fear of peace - Daily Pioneer - December 4th, 2020
- Becky with the good hair: Colorism and power in the Jewish community - Campus Times - November 17th, 2020
- Israel's Netanyahu Scared Fellow Countrymen Will "Misbehave" in the United Arab Emirates - Paddle Your Own Kanoo - November 17th, 2020
- Israeli FM: Biden Will Sign Amended Nuclear Deal with Iran and We Must Be Involved - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - November 17th, 2020
- Researchers Suggest Breast Cancer Screening in Black Women be Initiated by Age 40 - Cancer Network - November 17th, 2020
- Malawi to be first African nation to open embassy in Jerusalem - Cleveland Jewish News - November 5th, 2020
- Malawi to be first African state with embassy in Jerusalem - The Jerusalem Post - November 5th, 2020
- Will a possible Biden win have an influence on EU-Israel relations ? - European Jewish Press - November 5th, 2020
- Great non-fiction on tap at upcoming Arts, Books & Culture Festival - Jewish Community Voice - November 5th, 2020
- Rabbis volunteering in Philadelphia encounter the unexpected: Peace and optimism - The Times of Israel - November 5th, 2020
- Comprehensive Genomic Analysis in Some Patients With Breast Cancer Reveals Rare, Pathogenic TP53 Variant in Families of Ashkenazi Jewish Descent -... - October 25th, 2020
- Spiced, stuffed, and skinless Jewish sausages - The Jewish Star - October 25th, 2020
- Jewish Organization Sharsheret Helps Women with Breast and Ovarian Cancer During Pandemic - Jewish Journal - October 25th, 2020
- Why Israel's anti-Netanyahu protests will not change the system - Middle East Eye - October 25th, 2020
- Cleopatra's Golden Rule - or, she who has the gold, makes the rules - Neos Kosmos - October 20th, 2020
- Maybe its true Israels Jews are incapable of sovereignty - Haaretz.com - October 20th, 2020
- In an Ashkenazi world, I'm struggling to connect to my Bukharian heritage - Cleveland Jewish News - October 18th, 2020
- Shtetl-inspired sweatshirts are creating controversy online but is shtreetwear really beyond the pale? - Forward - October 18th, 2020
- Redefining the Diaspora: The Jews of Latin America and Beyond - jewishboston.com - October 18th, 2020
- Vegetarian cholent and kishke with a side of Shabbat mysticism J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - October 18th, 2020
- Talking to Your Kids About Breast Cancer - Dan's Papers - October 18th, 2020
- HBO Max Swoops On Global Rights To Israels Most Expensive TV Series Valley Of Tears In Deal With WestEnd - Deadline - October 18th, 2020
- Is this the end of the Chief Rabbinate in Israel? - The Jerusalem Post - October 14th, 2020
- Germany would share Europe-only COVID vaccine with Israel, citing special relationship - Forward - October 14th, 2020
- Its not Gal Gadots ethnicity that's the problem - TRT World - October 14th, 2020
- Blue and White finally see red over cynical Netanyahu - Arab News - October 14th, 2020
- Israel's pact with the UAE is not about peace. It's a business deal - The Guardian - October 14th, 2020
- New exhibit in Germany highlights the Rhine's medieval Jewish history - The Jerusalem Post - October 14th, 2020
- Prince Andrew portrayed as a scarecrow but the reason for it isn't Timur Kulibayev and Goga Ashkenazi connection - EconomicInform - October 14th, 2020
- Gantz and Ashkenazi the former IDF chiefs who are politically AWOL - The Jerusalem Post - October 4th, 2020
- Pandemic Temporarily Silences Violins That Survived the Holocaust - Smithsonian Magazine - October 4th, 2020
- We dont know if rotation will happen says FM amid political tension - The Jerusalem Post - October 4th, 2020
- The Holocaust-Surviving Violins That Were Quarantined Beneath a California Stage - Atlas Obscura - October 4th, 2020
- 'The Chicken Soup Manifesto' features hundreds of recipes from around the world - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - October 4th, 2020
- Iran busts sanctions by using other nations to get WMD - German intel - The Jerusalem Post - October 4th, 2020
- Realizing his party is on verge of collapse, Gantz resorts to diversion tactic - Haaretz.com - October 4th, 2020
- Awaiting a Return to Israel, Hand in Hand - The New York Times - September 29th, 2020
- EGRMC: Breast Cancer Screenings Should Not Be Delayed Due to COVID-19 - All On Georgia - September 29th, 2020
- Jewish penicillin: This soup is the cure for what ails you - Gaston Gazette - September 29th, 2020
- Cancer 'previvor' Ali Rogin sets out to fill in the gaps for other women - Jewish Insider - September 29th, 2020
- Why are Haredim hated and envied? - Haaretz.com - September 29th, 2020
- Bruno Mars: Everything you need to know - Free Radio - September 29th, 2020
- Victor Center for the Prevention of Jewish Genetic Diseases Now Serving New York, New Jersey and Maryland - PRNewswire - September 23rd, 2020
- Likud, Blue and White spar over protests as infection soars - The Jerusalem Post - September 23rd, 2020
- FM Ashkenazi hails US declaration that UN sanctions on Iran in force - The Times of Israel - September 23rd, 2020
Comments