Orthodoxy in Israel and the Diaspora – Australian Jewish News
Posted By admin on June 26, 2022
Reference to communities in Yerushalayim in my recent column regarding changes in our local rabbinate resulted in my being questioned as to how Orthodox religious life in Israel especially that termed Charedi differs from its counterpart in Diaspora communities such as here in Australia.
Let me preface my answer by saying that certain segments of the local Orthodox community may well resemble their Israeli counterparts in regard to the intensity of much religious practice. The Orthodox Jewish world as it is represented in Australia as well as that which exists in Israel, is composed of a continuum of levels of religious involvement rather than a number of segmented communities. Nevertheless there clearly are differences between Israeli and Diaspora communities which will amaze, bewilder or simply concern the onlooker.
Firstly there is the issue of communal isolation. Whereas in the Diaspora Orthodox Jews live among the general community and inevitably absorb, at least by osmosis, aspects of the general way of life, most Israelis secular or religious have little contact with non-Jews in their daily lives. (The interrelationship/interaction in Israel between Jews and the Arab population is significantly different from the interaction between Diaspora Jews and their gentile neighours.)
But I have been amazed to find how many secular Israelis have literally never had anything to do with religious Jews or religion (perhaps other than a chance meeting with a Chabad shaliach stopping them in the street). And beyond that reality, many members of the Israeli Charedi community also have little regular contact with Israeli Jews outside their own community.
Charedi families tend to shun the regular media. I found it disturbing that in many religious neighbourhoods of Yerushalayim I couldnt even buy The Jerusalem Post let alone mainstream secular Hebrew dailies such as Maariv and Yediot Achronot. Israeli Charedim tend to read only Charedi newspapers; the content of those newspapers is strikingly different from that of the general press. Headlines regarding the movements and utterances of rabbis and rebbes often take precedence over current affairs even matters relating to Yerushalayim or Israel. Many listen only to religious radio stations and certainly do not watch television. As far as online electronic media are concerned, while there is serious opposition in principle (expressed on street posters and street demonstrations in Charedi neighbourhoods), inevitably cracks are appearing in practice.
Israeli Charedim are far more insular in this regard than their Diaspora counterparts. But the lack of Charedi interest in general media is reflected in media content and impacts on what others learn from media regarding Charedi life.
Of coursedespite what some would mistakenly seem to learn from themedia inside and outside Israel, Orthodoxy in Israel is not synonymouswith the Charedi community. Outside overtly insular Charedi communities, and especially outside Yerushalayim and other major Charedi centres, other segments of the Israeli Orthodox community tend to lifestyles whose religious content is more similar to those we know in Orthodox communities worldwide.
But at a different level, in an Orthodox neighbourhood of Jerusalem, there are few men who do not regularly attend services, as far as possible both in the morning and evening.
Thus so many shules do not only have one service each weekday morning and evening which is poorly attended by comparison with services on Shabbat and holidays the latter situation being that in most Diaspora communities and suburban Australian shules except the most Orthodox.
Many Jerusalem shules and shules elsewhere in Israel have multiple minyanim operating from before sunrise until three or four hours into each morning. Similarly minyanim for afternoon and evening services form continuously both inside and outside shules from some time before sunset until well into the night.
Compared to most Diaspora communities, there are also fewer men or women who do not devote fixed times in the day or week to shiurim. In almost all cases the shiurim involve intensive study of advanced texts, copies of which are a feature of every home. Yes, even some kibbutzim have a Daf Yomi shiur.
Regarding kashrut, practices also differ. A variety of Israeli kashrut authorities reflect differences between Ashkenazi and Sephardic custom; others reflect variants between the standards of the ultra-Orthodox community and those set by the official city rabbinate. Differences between different kashrut authorities in the Diaspora tend to be not as stark and often are rooted in communal historic and financial issues rather than such matters of halachic principle and custom.
In Jerusalem, despite inroads of Tzohar and the so called Kashrut Mehuderet facilitated by regulatory change instituted by the current government, the mehadrin (enhanced) standard rules an estab-lishment using anything less would exclude half of the local market.
As I also saw on my recent visit, differing attitudes to locally grown produce in the context of this year being a shmitah year are also significant in regard to hechsherim.
There are also different emphases in regard to dress. Traditional forms of Chassidic dress and the hat and jacket attire for men aside, there is much more emphasis on modest dress and head coverings for women ranging from the headscarf to the sheitel.
Even within Israel it can be quite a culture shock to make the one-hour ride from Jerusalem to Tel Aviv where modes of dress and general appearances are so different from those of Jerusalem even in its less Orthodox neighbourhoods.
Of course there are exceptions to these lifestyle emphases. Kibbutzim and other smaller communities have their own religious flavour. Inevitably Israeli communities with a stronger immigrant representation be they in Modiin, Raanana and portions of Beit Shemesh are less inward looking. The same is to be said of communities where many have had higher education and achieved professional qualifications, and who have broader professional and client networks. And as is the case in the Diaspora includingour own Australian community, there are many shades to what is broadly termed Modern Orthodoxy.
Diaspora communities could gain much from understanding Israeli Orthodox practice. A Netflix serial such as Shtisel may provide some insight to the Charedi world but is far from the be-all educative source of information for other elements of the Jewish (and even gentile) world.
Within Israel resolution of the lack of understanding and attendant prejudices is a task requiring urgent attention in the interests of the future of a united Israel.
A little more openness in this regard would be useful in the Diaspora as well.
Shabbat shalom,Yossi.
Yossi Aron OAM is The AJNs religious affairs editor.
Get The AJN Newsletter by email and never miss our top storiesFree Sign Up
Excerpt from:
Orthodoxy in Israel and the Diaspora - Australian Jewish News
- Israel is on the front line of the battle for Western civilisation, says diaspora minister - The Jewish Chronicle - November 20th, 2023
- Help Wanted: Cuba's government turns to growing diaspora for ... - Reuters - November 20th, 2023
- How Foods Of The African Diaspora Became Popular Choices For ... - Daily Meal - November 20th, 2023
- UGA hosts International Conference on Africa and its Diaspora - WGAU - November 20th, 2023
- Nigerian, African Diaspora win $20,000 Access Art X grants - The Nation Newspaper - November 20th, 2023
- Navigating diversity: ZEE5 Global masters the art of diaspora ... - Indiantelevision.com - November 20th, 2023
- The Torture and Hope of the Palestinian Diaspora in the US... - Jordan News - November 20th, 2023
- Diaspora should fully participate in economy - The Herald - November 20th, 2023
- What is Diwali, the Festival of Lights, and how is it celebrated in India and the diaspora? - Fox News - November 10th, 2023
- Love letters, gossip, prayers and poetry: the tapes that sustained the Somali diaspora - The Guardian - November 10th, 2023
- Saints and sinners of LA linked to Mexican diaspora - National Catholic Reporter - November 10th, 2023
- Bosnia and Herzegovina is still looking for an Answer as to how many People are part of Diaspora - Sarajevo Times - November 10th, 2023
- Director Gabriella A. Moses Breaks Down Tribeca Winner Boca Chica: Ill Always Have Stories to Tell That Center the Diaspora - Variety - November 10th, 2023
- NPP Germany Executives call on Bawumia; assure him of support from the diaspora - Modern Ghana - November 10th, 2023
- In light of antisemitism, some Diaspora Jews wonder whether to remove their mezuzahs - Arutz Sheva - November 8th, 2023
- Dear Brothers and Sisters in the Diaspora! - Arutz Sheva - November 8th, 2023
- Democratic forces are rallying the Belarusian diaspora, while ... - Belarus in Focus Information Office - November 8th, 2023
- Iranian diaspora and Gaza war, paying homage to the Zionist master - Tehran Times - November 8th, 2023
- Nigerians in Diaspora back Tinubu - The Nation Newspaper - November 8th, 2023
- Kenyans in the diaspora urged to recognise country's heroes - Capital FM Kenya - November 8th, 2023
- Diaspora - a horror short film by Tyler Mckenzie Evans - Short of the Week - November 4th, 2023
- How Africa Can Make the Most of Diaspora Finance by Tsitsi Masiyiwa - Project Syndicate - November 4th, 2023
- Dionne Irving delves into the diaspora and memories of shipping barrels 'back home' - CBC.ca - November 4th, 2023
- Connected Diaspora: U.S. Central American Visuality in the Age of ... - Brooklyn Rail - November 4th, 2023
- In 'Works and Process: Dance Theatre of Harlem Diaspora,' new ... - CU Columbia Spectator - November 4th, 2023
- Far from home, Israeli teen envoys in Diaspora show Israeli grit and resilience - The Times of Israel - November 4th, 2023
- Masks of the Diaspora Masquerade Ball - Hour Detroit Magazine - November 4th, 2023
- Africa and the diaspora on ACCES 2023 agenda - Music In Africa - November 4th, 2023
- BiH is committed to Strengthening the Ties of the Diaspora with the Homeland - Sarajevo Times - November 4th, 2023
- The Road to Nowhere celebrates the superpowers of diaspora ... - Dazed - November 4th, 2023
- Black Harvest: The Past, Future And Present Of Diaspora Film - Newcity Film - November 4th, 2023
- Pune-based Two Brothers Organic Farms reaches out to Indian diaspora in US - BusinessLine - November 4th, 2023
- Israels War and the Diaspora - The Times of Israel - November 4th, 2023
- Safety for Jews in the Diaspora | Aharon Gottlieb | The Blogs - The Times of Israel - November 4th, 2023
- Festival showcasing life of the Polish diaspora to launch on Saturday - TVP World - November 4th, 2023
- Still women are made to suffer in Diaspora - The Herald - November 4th, 2023
- Gathering of the Greek Diaspora at the feast of Saint Dimitrios in ... - Neos Kosmos - November 4th, 2023
- The multifaceted influence of the Indian diaspora in Qatar; bilateral and economic dynamics - The Financial Express - November 4th, 2023
- IDF spokesman to Jewish diaspora: We are all together, all Jews - Arutz Sheva - October 25th, 2023
- Indian diaspora body in US seeks flexibility in issuance of Employment Authorisation Card - The Tribune India - October 25th, 2023
- Migrants and Diaspora are Agents of Change for Climate Action ... - International Organization for Migration (IOM) - October 25th, 2023
- What is Behind Recent Clashes Among Eritrean Diaspora in the West? - Voice of America - VOA News - October 25th, 2023
- Pivot to Partnership: Australia-India and the Diaspora - Australian ... - Australian Institute of International Affairs - October 25th, 2023
- In the Hindu diaspora, dancers and feminists celebrate the modern ... - Religion News Service - October 25th, 2023
- India only nation with no history of antisemitism: Diaspora supports Israel - Business Standard - October 25th, 2023
- Night Bloomers, SBS review: bloody fables from the Korean diaspora - ScreenHub - October 25th, 2023
- Healthsend Africa launches in Kenya, addressing diaspora ... - Innovation Village - October 25th, 2023
- PM Holness calls on Jamaican diaspora to safeguard and expand ... - caribbeannationalweekly.com - October 25th, 2023
- Could Venezuelas diaspora hold the key to its opposition primary race? - Al Jazeera English - October 20th, 2023
- October 17 Captivity, Exile, and Diaspora What Is Jeremiah ... - VCY.org - October 20th, 2023
- Kasselakis ties the knot in NY, plans meeting with diaspora - Kathimerini English Edition - October 20th, 2023
- Observations on The Diaspora, Israel and Palestine - Oakridger - October 20th, 2023
- Brothers and sisters in the Diaspora: You are a vital part of our strength - The Jewish News - October 20th, 2023
- Exhibiting Africa: State of the Field in African Art and the Diaspora - Brooklyn Museum - October 20th, 2023
- Greek diaspora - Wikipedia - October 10th, 2023
- Jewish diaspora mourns attack on Israel, but carries on by celebrating ... - October 10th, 2023
- Jewish diaspora mourns attack on Israel, but carries on by celebrating holidays - The Associated Press - October 10th, 2023
- British MP is focusing on the Indian diaspora - Asia Times - October 10th, 2023
- Hamas Must Be Destroyed and How Diaspora Jewry can Help - Jewish Link of New Jersey - October 10th, 2023
- Haitian Diaspora and Civil Society strongly opposed to military ... - Stabroek News - October 10th, 2023
- Sanjaya Baru writes: Beyond Khalistan issue, BJPs politicisation of diaspora is against national interest - The Indian Express - October 10th, 2023
- Diasporas | Migration data portal - October 8th, 2023
- Diaspora | The Princeton Encyclopedia of Self-Determination - October 8th, 2023
- Jewish diaspora - Wikipedia - October 8th, 2023
- Diversity, Diaspora and Asian Film Identity Up for Discussion by Busan Festival Jury: We Have Rich Feelings, but Express Them With Difficulty -... - October 8th, 2023
- Were All Headed Towards An Immigrant Mentality: Steven Yeun, John Cho & Justin Chon On Why Korean Diaspora Stories Are Resonating Busan -... - October 8th, 2023
- Finding My Power Among the Diaspora - The Wilson Quarterly - October 8th, 2023
- 'Faces of the Diaspora: A Visual Journey' on display in Greenville - WYFF4 Greenville - October 8th, 2023
- Reviving the Greek diaspora - Kathimerini English Edition - October 3rd, 2023
- DIASPORA! Review: Delivers on its Big Dreams | Arts - Harvard Crimson - October 3rd, 2023
- Vanessa Bravo speaks on role of governments, diaspora groups in ... - Today at Elon - October 3rd, 2023
- Harnessing The Power Of The Global Italian Diaspora How To ... - www.lagazzettaitaliana.com - October 3rd, 2023
- Japa: Govt advised to use expertise, resources of diaspora to ... - Daily Trust - October 3rd, 2023
- Fall of Ethnic Armenian Enclave Stuns the Armenian Diaspora - NPR - October 2nd, 2023
- Sudans diaspora, from Virginia to Victoria, sends aid as other sources fall through - The Washington Post - October 2nd, 2023
- A new mural representing the Asian diaspora's reach in the West will be unveiled at the Auraria Campus this weekend - Denverite - October 2nd, 2023
- Govt rejects motion from diaspora conference in Washington - Stabroek News - October 2nd, 2023
- Modi's Hindu nationalism stokes tension in Indian diaspora - The Japan Times - October 2nd, 2023
- Top US officials laud growing strategic relations between India-US: credit diaspora, EAM Jaishankar - Times of India - October 2nd, 2023
- Thousand Of Indonesian Diaspora Enliven The Festive Atmosphere ... - Kementerian Luar Negeri - October 2nd, 2023
Comments