Manzanar To Palestine: Legacy Of Internment And Ethnic-Cleansing OpEd – Eurasia Review
Posted By admin on July 27, 2022
Last night, I watched a fascinating PBS documentary,Manzanar, Diverted: When Water Becomes Dust. We all know, or think we know aboutManzanar. It was the flagship incarceration camp for interned Japanese Americans during World War II (there were others in Arizona and Idaho). The World War II iInternment decreed by Pres. Rooselvelt, was the third worst human rights travesty in the history of the Republic (slavery and Native American genocide being the others). Manzanar was such a blight that it has become enshrined in our nations history as a supreme symbol of injustice.
This documentary expands our view of the camp and its place in a broader history of ethnic cleansing and genocide. While Japanese citizens were rounded up from their homes throughout California and forcibly removed to what were, in effect benign concentration camps, there was a much longer and equally troubling injustice surrounding Manzanar.
Namely, Native American Paiute and Shoshone tribes lived in the Owens Valley, and around its signature geographic feature,Owens Lake. The Lake was a huge saline sea, which captured all the water flowing down the eastern Sierras to the valley below. For 3,000 years, the tribes fished, hunted, and grew crops in the fertile soil and plentiful water resources available.
But in the 1860sconflict and trouble arosebetween the natives and white settlers:
[The] discovery of gold and silver in the Sierra Nevada and Inyo Mountains attracted a flood of prospectors. Ranchers and farmers followed, often utilizing Paiute irrigation systems and grasslands. A harsh winter and scarce food in 1861-1862 forced the Paiute and settlers into open conflict. The military intervened and, in 1863, forcibly removed 1,000 Paiute to Fort Tejon in the mountains south of Bakersfield.
The entire national history of relations between indigenous people and whites has entailed conflict over the land and its bounty. Whether the land had gold, silver, water, or other resources, once the white men came, they took it. If the native inhabitants resented or resisted, they were removed either by violence, trickery or outright theft. As but one example, nearly 1,000 tribal members met with US army officers and agreed to end hostilities in 1863. The army then forced them to march 200 miles south to Ft Tejon. Some died on the way and others escaped and returned to their ancestral home. Once they were dumped there they were provided little to sustain themselves. The food offered was little more than starvation rations.
In both the cases of the Paiute tribe and Japanese Americans, they were deemed a danger and menace to white people. In the case of the Paiute, the army response to raids by the Native Americans against settlers was either to kill or expel them. The Japanese Americans, on the other hand, put up no such resistance. Thus, they were treated somewhat better. Their internment lasted only three years. While the Paiute continue their battles with the government to this day.
In 1913, a new calamity befell the tribes. Los Angeles to the south, had become a burgeoning metropolis. With its mild climate and fertile agricultural lands, it became a beacon to Americans from the east and midwest. The population grew by leaps and bounds. The city fathers/power brokers determined that the one resource lacking for the growth they envisioned was water. There simply wasnt enough.
For that, they looked north to the Owens Valley and its Lake, which encompassed over 100 square miles of pure mountain runoff. The water engineers in Los Angeles, led by the infamous, William Mulholland immortalized in Roman PolanskisChinatown, coveted the resource and devised a method to divert it to Los Angeles, 200 miles south. The city water engineer led the effort to build the California aqueduct, which stole the water from the Valley and shipped it to the City of Angels.
Mulholland handled the engineering and left the issue of securing water rights to the citys power brokers, land agents, and lawyers. By legal means, if possible and by subterfuge if necessary, they secretly bought up the water rights held by all the farmers in the Valley. Most of them left after they no longer had access to the water needed for their farming operations.
But the tribes posed a more difficult obstacle. As indigenous inhabitants, they not only lived in the Valley for thousands of years, they had a primary right to the water that had nourished them over that whole period. Eventually, some of the tribal members agreed to a population transfer, which offered them land to resettle within the Los Angeles city limits. In return for the land, the tribes gave up most of their water rights in the Valley. Thus, the infamous Department of Water and Power assumed control of the Owens Valley water, enabling the creation of the sprawling urban monster Los Angeles eventually became.
By linking the Japanese internment in Manzanar to the Native American displacement, the PBS documentary offered a completely new perspective on these phenomena. California and the US trampled the rights of both the interneesandthe indigenous peoples. For the former, the injustice lasted three years. For the latter, it stretched all the way back to the 1860s, when the Native Americans were first ethnically-cleansed from the Valley.
The two groups have united over the past decade, both to preserve the Manzanar national monument which the federal government dedicated; and to defend the rights of the remaining indigenous residents of the Valley. Together, theyve lobbied the DWP to restore some of the diverted water back to the Lake, though the amounts are limited (the dry lakebed remains the greatest source of dust pollution in the country). Its moving to see the 2019 Manzanar ceremony in which scores of survivors returned, joined by the Native Americans and even hijab-wearing Muslim Americans. It is a dramatic example of the power of intersectionality.
The state-sponsored crimes committed in the Owens Valley are not one-off events. One could even say, with H. Rap Brown, that ethnic cleansing is as American as apple pie. American plantation owners were instrumental in the African slave trade, in which victims were kidnapped from their homes and forcibly transported across the sea to work as slaves. Later, when the abolition movement began, many liberal white Americans believed the best way of dealing with the race problem was byshipping the freed slavesbackto Africa, since they couldnt possibly be integrated into civilized society. This would have entailed yet another displacement from America. Ironically, the main driver of this project was theAmericanColonizationSociety. By its very name, it declared that the freed slaves would themsevles be part of a new colonization effort to bring enlightenment and civiliazation to the African natives via this new state, Liberia.
Over the course of human history, tribes have slaughtered, expelled, or in less traumatic instances intermingled with rivals. There have been huge migrations of populations around the globe based on economic or climate-related dislocations. Many of these disruptions also resulted from invasions, conquest, and pillage. We are a (human) race prone to mass violence and genocide.
In the 19th century, Europeans excelled at such rape and pillage of the resources and human capital of their colonies. In the Congo alone, Belgiums King Leopold was responsible for the death by disease and murder of 4-million indigenous inhabitants. In Latin America, Spain devastated the Natives with European diseases and worked the rest to death mining gold and silver, which was shipped back to the motherland.
Which brings us to Israel-Palestine: Herzl and the early Zionists saw their enterprise very much in a similar light. They saw themselves as Europeans bringing the values of western civilization to the natives, the indigenous Arabs in Palestine. They adopted the colonial attitude of uplift which persuaded them of the righteousness of their cause. But when push came to shove, when the Arabs stood in the way of Progress, they would later be tossed aside in much the same way the California tribes were.
From 1937, if not earlier, Ben Gurionwrotein a letter to his son, that the Palestinians would be swept away by the Zionist enterprise. Yes, there were other passages in which he slightly softened his rhetoric. But the message remained clear: Zionism demanded a Jewish state with a Jewish majority. To obtain this there was a two-pronged strategy: bringing Jewish immigrants as pioneers to the Zionist state to populate it with Jews; and suppressing the Arab population.
In 1948, Ben Gurion took advantage of the War he provoked, to implement a massive campaign of ethnic cleansing, the Nakba. As a result, nearly 1-million indigenous Arabs were forcibly expelled from their homeland. Only 250,000 remained after the 1948 War. Those who were expelled were prohibited from return, on pain of death. This was how he implemented his earlier vision of maintaining a Jewish majority. To this day, the Palestinian refugees and their descendants languish in camps spread throughout the Middle East. Nor have they assimilated into their host countries. They remain stateless after their homeland deprived them of their identity.
Like the Paiute in the 1880s, the Palestinians fled and resettled in many neighboring Arab states (primarily Jordan, Syria, and Lebanon). The camps are not unlike the reservations to which Native Americans were confined during westward expansion. and white settlement. But unlike the experience of indigenous American Natives, who enjoy special status, rights, and obligations from the federal government, Israel has adamantly refused any obligation to those it expelled. It refuses to even recognize that they are refugees. Nor has it attempted to normalize relations with the remaining Palestinians. Thus Nakba remains, like slavery for America, the Original Sin of the State of Israel. A blot and a stain on its nationhood. One which cannot be redeemed without Israeli recognition and repentance for the great affront it committed against the dignity of the indigenous Palestinian inhabitants of this land.
This article was published at Tikun Olam
Follow this link:
Manzanar To Palestine: Legacy Of Internment And Ethnic-Cleansing OpEd - Eurasia Review
- Israel-Palestine: How Netanyahu's Far-Right Government Is Quietly Annexing the West Bank - Foreign Policy - June 8th, 2023
- Why the world abandoned Palestine - Middle East Eye - June 8th, 2023
- The Tories can never be true friends of Palestine - Al Jazeera English - June 8th, 2023
- Displaced and distraught: East Palestine remains at risk and without answers - Environmental Health News - June 8th, 2023
- Palestine: Draft law on the right to information raises concerns over ... - International Federation of Journalists - June 8th, 2023
- Palestine and Wills Point Have 2 of the 12 Nude Resorts in Texas - knue.com - June 8th, 2023
- Sumud: Birth, Oral History and Persistence in Palestine - Middle East Monitor - May 29th, 2023
- EU envoy: No such thing as Area A and B, its all Palestine - European Jewish Press - May 29th, 2023
- Palestine: the revolutionary dies but the revolution lives on - Revolutionary Communist Group - May 29th, 2023
- US university condemned for removing pro-Palestine speech from ... - Middle East Eye - May 29th, 2023
- Why Karim Khan froze the Palestine file: The ICC and Israeli war ... - Middle East Monitor - May 29th, 2023
- Another Babylon Bee spoof of the Israel/Palestine conflict: - Why Evolution Is True - May 22nd, 2023
- 'Avenging the Free': Thousands of Palestinians Rally in Palestine ... - Palestine Chronicle - May 22nd, 2023
- Palestine and its religious importance | Britannica - May 20th, 2023
- The New Earth Grapples With a Family's Silence on Palestine - The New Republic - May 20th, 2023
- APWA Presents Palestine in My Heart Award to Samira Hussein ... - Washington Report on Middle East Affairs - May 20th, 2023
- New York City couple brings taste of Palestine to the city - Spectrum News NY1 - May 20th, 2023
- Palestine native inducted into New York Life's Dallas Hall of Fame - Palestine Herald Press - May 20th, 2023
- Times of Israel Removes Article Calling For Palestine to Be Obliterated - Mediaite - May 20th, 2023
- East Palestine residents were initially told Norfolk Southern train only contained 'malt liquor' - Daily Mail - May 20th, 2023
- Israel-Palestine: Reformist solutions and their discontents - Socialist Appeal - May 20th, 2023
- Expert expanding testing of air filters in East Palestine - NewsNation Now - May 20th, 2023
- On the ground in Palestine: Living under an Apartheid regime - JOE.ie - May 20th, 2023
- Israel-Palestine: UN envoy calls for greater effort towards ... - April 29th, 2023
- Truck carrying 40,000 pounds of toxic soil from East Palestine train derailment overturns on highway - NBC News - April 14th, 2023
- Norfolk Southern head sidesteps responsibility for preventing East Palestine derailment - USA TODAY - March 24th, 2023
- Ohio senators blast Norfolk Southern for train derailment - March 10th, 2023
- East Palestine train derailment site workers are getting sick, union ... - March 2nd, 2023
- East Palestine derailment: Timeline of key events in toxic train ... - March 2nd, 2023
- Palestinian territories - Wikipedia - March 2nd, 2023
- Heres the real reason the EPA doesnt want to test for toxins in East ... - March 2nd, 2023
- What is Palestine and who are Palestinians? | The US Sun - March 2nd, 2023
- Departments | Palestine, TX - March 2nd, 2023
- Palestine - History | Britannica - March 2nd, 2023
- United Nations in Palestine - March 2nd, 2023
- Ohio train derailment update: Waste from East Palestine to be shipped to Grafton - WKYC.com - March 2nd, 2023
- SNLs Trump Rants About Rihanna and Gay Buttigieg in East Palestine - Rolling Stone - March 2nd, 2023
- Ohio train derailment prompts water utility across state lines to take ... - February 17th, 2023
- East Palestine train derailment updates: Chemical plume moves toward ... - February 17th, 2023
- There were more toxic chemicals on train that derailed in Ohio than ... - February 17th, 2023
- Health concerns grow in East Palestine, Ohio, after train derailment - February 17th, 2023
- Ohio train derailment fact check: What's true and what's false? - USA TODAY - February 17th, 2023
- Ohio: After a train derailment, residents are living the plot of a movie they helped make - CNN - February 13th, 2023
- More chemicals found in East Palestine after train derailment as students return to school, and more: 3News Daily with Stephanie Haney - WKYC.com - February 13th, 2023
- UN seeks ICJ opinion on Israels illegal occupation of Palestine - Al Jazeera English - December 31st, 2022
- Israeli occupation of Palestinian territory illegal: UN rights commission - UN News - October 21st, 2022
- Is Palestine on the brink of a full-scale revolt? - The Electronic Intifada - October 17th, 2022
- Slaughter of the Innocents: Iran, Palestine, and Hypocrisy of 'Western' Media - Palestine Chronicle - October 17th, 2022
- From the River to the Sea: Join the Palestinian March for Return and Liberation - Palestine Chronicle - October 17th, 2022
- Letters To Barack Obama Short And Long , And Of United States Destruction Of The Palestinian People - Countercurrents.org - October 17th, 2022
- Man seeking Royal Ulster Rifles apology after civilians 'forced to drive over landmine' in Palestine - Belfast Telegraph - October 17th, 2022
- East Palestine record-holding runner named Student Athlete of Week - WKBN.com - October 17th, 2022
- The Arab world has failed Palestine, leaving it in limbo - Middle East Monitor - September 2nd, 2022
- Japan contributes US$ 1.5 million in food assistance for Palestine refugees in the Gaza Strip - occupied Palestinian territory - ReliefWeb - September 2nd, 2022
- For anyone with Palestinian roots like me, Netflixs sitcom Mo is groundbreaking TV - The Guardian - September 2nd, 2022
- Palestine man indicted in San Antonio smuggling incident to continue to be held without bond - KETK | FOX51 | EastTexasMatters.com - September 2nd, 2022
- Diplomatic Missions In Solidarity With Palestinian NGOs Active Accomplices Of Israels Apartheid - Countercurrents.org - September 2nd, 2022
- The South African solution will not work in Palestine Mondoweiss - Mondoweiss - August 30th, 2022
- Heatwave In Israel, Palestine: Residents Hit The Streets To Beat The Heat - Outlook India - August 30th, 2022
- Palestine bride in her wedding dress arrested by Israel police - Middle East Monitor - August 30th, 2022
- A Message to Canadian Leaders: There's No Room for Vanity in the Struggle for Palestinian Justice - Palestine Chronicle - August 30th, 2022
- Palestine Muay Thai fighter wins the Victory Road Championships - Middle East Monitor - August 30th, 2022
- Progressive candidate Maxwell Frost hit by pro-Palestinian group, accused of shifting stance on Israel - Fox News - August 30th, 2022
- Palestine wants to step up brotherhood ties, in Merdeka message - The Star Online - August 30th, 2022
- Israeli suppression of Palestinian rights organizations 'illegal and unacceptable' - UN News - August 27th, 2022
- Maxwell Frost abandoned Palestine on his way to Democratic primary victory - Mondoweiss - August 27th, 2022
- Palestine exposes the limits of free-speech and the morally bankrupt 'cancel culture' - Middle East Monitor - August 27th, 2022
- Can a Jew cook Palestinian food without getting all political? J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - August 27th, 2022
- Palestinian Family Forced to Self-Demolish Their House in East Jerusalem - Palestine Chronicle - August 27th, 2022
- India advocates resumption of peace talks between Israel and Palestine - Business Standard - August 27th, 2022
- An overgrown forest in Kansas City's Palestine East could be turned into a community resource - KCUR - August 27th, 2022
- The Palestinian Authority celebrates the Hebron murderers - JNS.org - August 16th, 2022
- I Studied With a Palestinian Terrorist Organization. This Is What I Learned. - Truthout - August 16th, 2022
- Islamic Jihad one of the most effective resistance groups in Palestine: speaker - Tehran Times - August 16th, 2022
- Students for Justice of Palestine: What do they stand for? - UTSA The Paisano - August 1st, 2022
- Chess Olympiad 2022: Meet Randa Sedar of Palestine - the youngest participant in the competition - myKhel - August 1st, 2022
- Washington is the Problem, Not the Solution: Why Mahmoud Abbas is Seeking New 'Powerful' Sponsors - Palestine Chronicle - August 1st, 2022
- UN Palestine relief agency forced to cut doctor visits to three minutes amid UK budget cuts - iNews - July 31st, 2022
- Palestinian Authority arrest campaign one of the worst in years - Al Jazeera English - July 31st, 2022
- Enough Is Enough: Palestine Accused Of Systematic Torture Before The International Criminal Court - Daily Caller - July 31st, 2022
Comments