Is this Russian rabbi fair game for sanctions, or being held to a double standard? – Forward
Posted By admin on August 22, 2022
Russia's President Vladimir Putin, right, with Rabbi Alexander Boroda, left, and Rabbi Berel Lazar, center, in a visit to the Jewish Museum and Tolerance Center in Moscow in 2013. Photo by Alexey Druzhinin/AFP via Getty Images
By Louis KeeneAugust 16, 2022
Rabbi Alexander Boroda, regarded as Russias second-most influential Jewish leader, feels misunderstood and worried for the nations Jews.
Boroda said the comments that prompted a leading pro-Ukraine group to add him to its list of people recommended for international sanctions were taken out of context, and that his inclusion puts Russias already vulnerable Jews at further risk.
Its not just me; its the whole organization, Boroda said last week in an interview, referring to his Federation of Jewish Communities of Russia, which serves more than 150,000 people in 180 communities.
Research all my official or not-official comments, interviews or everything, he added. You will not find anything about support of this war situation.
But since Rabbi Boroda was added on July 29 to a list of dozens of sellout opinion leaders by the Anti-Corruption Foundation, a group created by Russian dissident Alexei Navalny, two similar groups have put him in their sights as well.
A member of the National Agency on Corruption Prevention, a Ukrainian group compiling its own list of Vladimir Putin collaborators and supporters of the war in Ukraine, said that it was looking into Borodas case and would reach a determination in the next week on whether to add him.
And Jacob Nell, a member of the Yermak-McFaul Expert Group on Russian Sanctions, said: Having read his statements, I dont think Boroda has any defense.
About 7,000 individuals are, collectively, on the running lists compiled by these three groups, 1,000 of whom including the Russian Jewish oligarch Roman Abramovich and Lev Leviev have had sanctions actually leveled against them by governments including the United States and the European Union. Those sanctions generally ban the individuals from international travel and freeze their assets.
Looming over the dispute is the specter of an autocrat notorious for retaliating against dissenters and centuries of Jewish persecution in Eastern Europe. Boroda may be attempting to tread lightly in his public remarks, hoping to avoid the ire of Putin and the largely pro-war Russian public. A spokesperson for the Chabad movement, with which Boroda is affiliated, said adding the rabbi to the list was morally repugnant.
Russian Jews have been in a precarious situation since the war began. The Kremlin recently moved to shut down the Jewish Agency, which supports emigration to Israel. Rabbi Pinchas Goldschmidt, who was Moscows chief rabbi until the war began, is one of the thousands who have fled to Israel, leaving a position he held for 30 years. He told NPR last week that while before the war Russian Jewish leaders could keep a low profile, now the Kremlin is going to demand much more from everyone who is still in an official leadership position.
News reports have described Boroda as a Putin confidant, though the rabbi told the Forward he had not seen the Russian president since the beginning of the pandemic and that the two only speak about Judaism in Russia. He is also connected to Abramovich, who has historically been a major funder of Jewish causes in the country.
The comments that landed Boroda on the Anti-Corruption Foundations list were made March 4 in an interview with the Russian media outlet Interfax, in which he described a surge of neo-Nazism in Ukraine, seemingly propagating a claim Putin used as pretext for his Feb. 24 invasion.
He supported the main narrative of Russian propaganda that the aggression against Ukraine has a legitimate goal the denazification of Ukraine, a spokesperson for the group said. After that, no statements were made that would disavow pro-war statements.
Speaking via Zoom from his home in Moscow, Boroda said that his comments were similar to statements made by non-Russian Jewish leaders over many years. He said Interfax framed the comments in a misleading way, and that, at his behest, the news agency removed that question, as well as the preface about denazification, from its website some weeks later.
Interfax, an outlet that refers to the war in Ukraine as a special military operation, prefaced its article containing Borodas comments with the assertion that one of the goals of the war was the denazification of Ukraine a pretext that has been widely debunked outside of Russia.
The Jewish community of Russia has repeatedly condemned the episodes of neo-Nazism in Ukraine, the Interfax reporter said to Boroda. How do you characterize the nationalist movement of recent years?
Boroda responded by describing the surge of neo-Nazism in Ukraine at length and Ukraines failure to rein it in. He referred to a far-right Ukrainian party with neo-Nazi origins and to the monuments to Nazi collaborators that pock Ukrainian cities, before concluding: With a great deal of confidence, I believe that the majority of Ukrainian citizens do not support the ideology that has grown out of the criminal episodes of history.
These comments drew swift backlash from his Jewish counterparts in Ukraine.
Rabbi Moshe Reuven Azman, one of the countrys most prominent rabbis, told the Jerusalem Post that Boroda has a choice: either to be on the side of the light which is Ukraine or with the darkness: Russia.
Representatives from both the Anti-Corruption Federation and the National Agency said the timing of Borodas remarks and the fact that they were made to Interfax meant that the rabbi was tacitly throwing his weight behind a false Kremlin narrative justifying the war.
Antisemitism and neo-Nazism is at least as much of a problem in Russia, said Nell, of the McFaul group. So talking about it as if it is a problem in Ukraine and not in Russia is misleading and deliberately and intentionally misleading for somebody speaking in Borodas position.
Speaking to the Forward, Boroda said he never connected the question about neo-Nazi activity in Ukraine to the war. He noted that former Israeli President Reuven Rivlin had made similar comments in a 2016 address to the Ukrainian Parliament. And he clarified that he does not think Nazis are in power in Ukraine, but that a small quantity of people with fringe views who glorify historical Nazi collaborators has been growing gradually there in the last decade.
I answered exactly what they asked me, he said. They asked me whats my stance with the situation. I cannot say, Its OK. But its not a reason to enact war. Its not connected.
The National Agency researcher, however, said there were other parts of the interview that also made them suspicious about Borodas loyalties. For example, in discussing a Russian missile that landed at Babyn Yar, the site where Nazis executed tens of thousands of Jews in 1942, Boroda did not question the Interfax interviewers false assertion that the attack, as it turned out, did not take place.
As with the presence of neo-Nazism in Ukraine, the March 1 incident at Babyn Yar does not fit neatly into either sides narrative. Five people were killed in the missile attack, but it appeared to target a nearby telecommunications tower, not the memorial. Contrary to initial reports, most of the memorial, which is under construction, emerged unscathed.
Boroda was cryptic about it in the Interfax interview published the next day. You can not succumb to information hysteria, he said.
At the moment, media representatives from different countries confirm that the memorial is not damaged, he added. But, unfortunately, even the reports of publications with international authority can be unreliable.
Nell also raised questions about a statement Boroda sent to the Jewish community the day after the Russian invasion. While it mentioned respect for neighbors and their rights, Boroda also referenced the Ukrainian and Russian peoples shared history, and said that Jews in the Soviet Union never knew what separation and borders were, both echoes of Putins position that Ukraine is really just part of Russia.
Speaking with the Forward Aug. 8, Boroda said that he has never supported the war, even tacitly. He also avoided directly condemning it or even using the word war to directly describe the action, which Russia has made a crime punishable by 15 years in prison.
Throughout the 30-minute conversation, Boroda favored the term used by the Kremlin for the invasion of Ukraine a military operation instead, though he once referred to this war situation.
Speaking more broadly, though, he used the word freely and forcefully.
Theres never a reason to do war, because all problems could be solved and must be solved at the table, not by war and not by weapon, said Boroda, whose deputy was also present during the interview.
The rabbi said he had not been in contact with Putin since the war began, and chuckled when asked if he thought telling the Russian president to end it would have any effect.
Boroda described the sanctions against Abramovich as a huge problem for the federation and questioned whether sanctions had produced the pressure on Putin foreign governments had sought. Boroda had previously attributed 80% of the growth of Russian Jewish communities to Abramovich alone.
He said the sanctions on Jewish oligarchs were threatening the federations ability to keep community schools and synagogues open, and said that the orphans and elderly his organization feeds may suffer for it.
Some way I think we will have to close something, Boroda said.
And he downplayed the pressure against him that others have suggested, pointing out that Goldschmidt, the rabbi who fled Russia, told NPR that the government had not asked him directly to support the war.
Nobody pushed me to say something to support war, he said. And I dont know who was pushed to support it among the religious people. I dont know. For me, for sure not.
There are ways Russian religious leaders could stand to gain from toeing the line effectively. Lazar, the chief rabbi, said We must pray for peace, yet was visible in box seats at Russias Victory Day military parade this year.
According to Nell, who is also a senior research fellow at the Kyiv School of Economics, leaders who show fealty to Putin have access to a 0.1% lifestyle and their organizations may also benefit through the protections and perks that come with official state recognition.
When Goldschmidt was asked about Russian religious leaders who havent opposed the war as vehemently as he has, told the newspaper Israel Hayom that he doesnt judge leaders who dont come out against the war. The situation there is very difficult, he said. When you live in a country that isnt free, like Iran, you dont say everything thats on your mind.
Dietrich Brauer, who resigned as Archbishop of the Evangelical-Lutheran Church of Russia after leaving the country in March, said that the Kremlin issued a clear demand of all religious leaders to support the war, and most did.
The Jewish chief rabbi who also has American citizenship found clever words, Brauer said, referring to Berel Lazar, Russias chief rabbi who is considered the countrys most influential Jewish leader. He called on everyone to work for peace. We could have joined that. I wanted to write a joint statement with all religious communities, but the others didnt agree. Together we could have made a difference.
In an interview with the Jewish Telegraphic Agency a few weeks after the Interfax article was published, Boroda said, Its a complicated situation.
During times of war, people are not thinking rationally. Some think: Youre either with us or against us, he said then. We explain that bringing peace is the basis for any religious community, especially the Jewish one. But I cant say everyone understands. Some people from other faiths they expect us to support the military action.
A representative from Navalnys Anti-Corruption Federation said that Boroda was an open-and-shut case.
We believe that the statement was completely unambiguous and this is confirmed by the reaction of the Jewish community in Ukraine, outside observers in Israel, the assessment of these statements in Russia and our assessment of these words, the representative wrote in an email. We do not believe that the reproduction of the propaganda narrative leaves room for interpretation. On the contrary, attempts to disavow the statement do not contain any assessment of Russias aggression against Ukraine and are aimed not at clarifying the position, but at blurring it.
Rabbi Motti Seligson, a Chabad spokesperson in New York, said Boroda is focused on ensuring the wellbeing of the Russian Jews with whom he works. It is morally repugnant to suggest that Jewish communal leaders and rabbis in Russia who refuse to sacrifice their communities for the sake of some sort of pronouncement be punished, he said.
But Nell said good conscience would require Boroda taking a stand against Russias aggression.
Maybe he will find the moral courage to condemn the war now, before he gets sanctioned and cut off from the west, he said in a text message.
Louis Keene is a staff reporter at the Forward. He can be reached at keene@forward.com or on Twitter @thislouis.
Here is the original post:
Is this Russian rabbi fair game for sanctions, or being held to a double standard? - Forward
- What Matters Now to Rabbi Seth Farber: Hostages and mixed burials in Jewish law - The Times of Israel - November 24th, 2023
- Our Rabbi Barricaded the Class Door, Warning us to Play Dead - Newsweek - November 24th, 2023
- Rabbi Mark Gottlieb on A Jewish Theology of Resurrection | R. R. Reno - First Things - November 24th, 2023
- This rabbi says the 'fundamental threat' in Israel is not Hamas - CNN - November 24th, 2023
- Argentina's President-Elect To Visit Grave Of World-Famous Rabbi ... - The Daily Wire - November 24th, 2023
- Rabbi Dee: 'People need to understand why Israel is fighting this war' - The Jewish Chronicle - November 24th, 2023
- Denver rabbi headed to Israel on mission to help - CBS News - November 24th, 2023
- Rabbi Betsy Forester on achieving peace in Israel and Gaza - PBS Wisconsin - November 24th, 2023
- Opinion: As a rabbi and ex-student activist, my advice to protesters - Montreal Gazette - November 24th, 2023
- Wayland rabbi says Gaza attacks unleashed torrent of antisemitism - MetroWest Daily News - November 24th, 2023
- Swastikas found on Jewish building inspire Kalamazoo rabbi to create more light - MLive.com - November 24th, 2023
- What the 'DaVinci Code' did for the Catholic Church, Rabbi Shook's ... - St. Louis Jewish Light - November 24th, 2023
- Real Talk: The Rabbi who brought the hostages' families to the 'Ohel' - Arutz Sheva - November 24th, 2023
- Existence of Zionist Israel is antithetical to Judaism: Rabbi Weiss - TRT World - November 24th, 2023
- Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch on the parsha: Don't let the angels ... - Arutz Sheva - November 24th, 2023
- Help little Miriam: Rabbi's daughter kept tripping, mother horrified to ... - Arutz Sheva - November 24th, 2023
- Arizona man charged with threatening to execute rabbi and other Jews - CNN - November 10th, 2023
- Shluchim Give Standing Ovation to Rabbi Kotlarsky at Kinus - COLlive - November 10th, 2023
- Calabasas Rabbi Ordered to Testify in Lawsuit Against Imprisoned ... - Westside Current - November 10th, 2023
- IDF disavows comments by military rabbi calling for conquering Gaza and Lebanon - The Times of Israel - November 10th, 2023
- When the rabbi of your youth dies - Religion News Service - November 10th, 2023
- Frum Rabbi Elected In New Jersey's 30th Legislative District Will ... - CrownHeights.info - November 10th, 2023
- A hassidic grand rabbi's voice of support of the IDF amid war with ... - The Jerusalem Post - November 10th, 2023
- What Makes a Good Rabbi? - Chabad.org - October 31st, 2023
- Rabbi who survived Pittsburgh synagogue shooting 5 years ago considers this dark time - The Times of Israel - October 31st, 2023
- Sgt. Binyamin Loeb, 23: Orthodox paratrooper son of French rabbi - The Times of Israel - October 31st, 2023
- Over 100 U.S. Colleges and Universities Join Rabbi Ari Berman's ... - Yu News - October 31st, 2023
- Local rabbi at rally: Standing with Israel is only choice - Yoursun.com - October 31st, 2023
- Rabbi Braun: "Act This Shabbos The Way You Act Avery Shabbos" - CrownHeights.info - October 31st, 2023
- We have to keep on keeping these lives alive: Rabbi Chaim Mentz - Fox News - October 25th, 2023
- "Do not allow hatred to reign": Twin Cities Rabbi visits Israel amid ongoing conflict - CBS News - October 25th, 2023
- Beverly Hills Politician and Rabbi Launch Campaign to Boycott ... - Middle East Forum - October 25th, 2023
- I'm a Rabbi. Here's Why I Went to a Murdered Palestinian Boy's ... - The Daily Beast - October 25th, 2023
- The Priest, the Rabbi and the Beirut Terrorist Attack of 1983 - National Catholic Register - October 25th, 2023
- Is This the End Times? Is 'Hamas' in the Bible? Messianic Rabbi on ... - Faithwire - October 25th, 2023
- Boston rabbi recounts horrors of Hamas terror attack in Israel - Boston Herald - October 25th, 2023
- Kentuckians rally in support of Palestine, Rabbi says he wants to share love in the face of hate - Fox 56 News - October 25th, 2023
- Rabbi talks release of Evanston mother and daughter by Hamas - NBC Chicago - October 25th, 2023
- Chief Rabbi Lau Meets Troops in the South: 'In the Z'chus of Unity ... - http://hamodia.com - October 25th, 2023
- Rabbi Definition & Meaning | Britannica Dictionary - September 24th, 2023
- Urgent call from Rabbi Gluckowsky: Anash and Shluchim in Eretz ... - COLlive - September 24th, 2023
- The Rabbi and the Rock (Special Podcast Highlight) - Relevant Radio - September 24th, 2023
- Rabbi Matondo in Rangers rallying cry as he hopes fans stick with them - Daily Record - September 24th, 2023
- Protesters hound homophobic rabbi in Tel Aviv amid uproar over religious group - The Times of Israel - September 22nd, 2023
- From a Rabbi to my Catholic friends: We must confront what Pope Pius XII knew about the Holocaust. - America: The Jesuit Review - September 22nd, 2023
- Final probe into prominent German Reform rabbi affirms abuse of power allegations - The Times of Israel - September 22nd, 2023
- On my umpteenth trip to Uman, I finally visited Rabbi Nachmans grave - The Times of Israel - September 22nd, 2023
- Golf with Rabbi Dave | Entertainment | theunion.com - The Union - September 22nd, 2023
- Remembering Rabbi Matthew H. Simon, zl - Jewish Federation of Greater Washington - September 22nd, 2023
- The Rabbi and the Rock - Relevant Radio - September 22nd, 2023
- Temple Institute Rabbi: 'Jews came from all of Israel to blow the ... - Arutz Sheva - September 22nd, 2023
- Rangers Rabbi Matondo dreaming of chance to be involved in Europa League run - Yahoo News UK - September 22nd, 2023
- Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch on the parshah: Cowering in fear - Arutz Sheva - September 22nd, 2023
- Judah ha-Nasi - Wikipedia - August 30th, 2023
- Rabbi who lied to, had sex with several women to have detention extended - The Jerusalem Post - August 30th, 2023
- Israeli rabbi fired by yeshiva after he catfished dozens of women on secular dating apps - The Jewish Chronicle - August 30th, 2023
- Married Israeli rabbi used aliases to lure women on dating apps - The Times - August 30th, 2023
- An Actual Rabbi's Thoughts on Rabbi Rebecca From 'You Are So Not Invited to My Bat Mitzvah' - Alma - August 30th, 2023
- Rabbi Steve Leder on why good people do bad things - Spectrum News 1 - August 30th, 2023
- An American rabbi answers her congregants question: Why do they hate us? - The Times of Israel - August 30th, 2023
- Rabbi Aaron Marsh is a new face at the East Meadow Beth-El ... - liherald.com - August 30th, 2023
- A Kansas City rabbi publishes a new book on embracing 'everyday ... - KCUR - August 30th, 2023
- Young Rabbi Attacked in Crown Heights; Action Still Wasn't Taken - COLlive - August 30th, 2023
- The Time Rabbi Hodakov Apologized to the Rebbe - COLlive - August 30th, 2023
- Before MLK told us he had a dream, a Newark rabbi advised us not to remain silent | Opinion - NJ.com - August 30th, 2023
- Local rabbi, cantorial soloist want to help you stop on Shabbat ... - Jewish News of Greater Phoenix - August 30th, 2023
- York gets first rabbi since community decimated by infamous 1190 pogrom - The Times of Israel - August 8th, 2023
- Spokesman for Hebron: Rabbi Kook resurrected the holy city - Arutz Sheva - August 8th, 2023
- Fade in the Water and Jamie Foxxs Apology With Rabbi Dr. Ari Lamm - The Ringer - August 8th, 2023
- New Discovery/Max reality show 'Survive the Raft' features a Messianic 'rabbi' who says 'I'm Jewish, too' - St. Louis Jewish Light - August 8th, 2023
- New US reality show features a Messianic rabbi who says Im Jewish, too - The Times of Israel - August 8th, 2023
- History-making trans rabbi wants young people to find joy and ... - PinkNews - August 8th, 2023
- Rabbi Pinto in a heartrending talk from his sickbed: "I was between life - The Jerusalem Post - August 8th, 2023
- Tree of Life rabbi says community can begin to heal after shooter sentenced - The Times of Israel - August 8th, 2023
- Rescuing a Rabbi in Buchenwald - International Fellowship of Christians and Jews - August 8th, 2023
- Leon Black's failed rabbi father Eli killed himself in 1975 after trying to bribe Honduras to lower the banana - Daily Mail - August 8th, 2023
- Return of the Wild West Rabbi - Chabad.org - August 8th, 2023
- Rabbi speaks out on being last person to see murdered 14-year-old - New York Post - August 8th, 2023
- Why this rabbi isnt celebrating (or dismissing) the latest Trump indictments - Forward - August 8th, 2023
- Meet the Hampstead rabbi who will do anything for others - The Jewish Chronicle - July 28th, 2023
Comments