The 9th Of Av: On Failures Of Political And Religious Leadership OpEd – Eurasia Review
Posted By admin on July 25, 2022
When Jews mourn the two destructions of Jerusalem and its Holy Temple on the 9th of Av (August 7 this year) they begin by reading the Biblical Book of Lamentations, and feel tears of sorrow, pains of grief, and the agony of loss.
But in Hebrew the Biblical Book of Lamentations is named EaichaHow? So we also should silently think about: How did it happen? How come it happened? Who was responsible: our foreign enemies? our political and religious leaders? our own hate filled, inflexible, sectarianism? our God?
Thus we add to the Biblical Book of Lamentations; the rabbinic anthology of Midrashim (traditional glosses) about how, why and whoEaicha Rabba.
The rebirth of a Jewish state in the Land of Israel makes it more important than ever for our generation and its leaders to turn from 9th of Av mourning to seeking an understanding of the lessons our Rabbis learned from these two national historical catastrophes.
The Talmud (Gitten 56a) reports: The destruction of Jerusalem came through a Kamtza and a Bar Kamtza in this way. A certain man had a friend Kamtza and an enemy Bar Kamtza. Once he made a banquet and said to his servant, go and bring Kamtza. The man went and brought Bar Kamtza.
When the host found Bar Kamtza there he said, You gossip about me, what are you doing here? Get out. Bar Kamtza replied, Since I am here let me stay and I will pay you for whatever I eat and drink. The host refused. Then let me pay you for half the cost of the banquet. No! Then let me pay for the whole banquet. The host refused and took Bar Kamtza by the arm and pulled him outside.
Bar Kamtza said to himself, Since the Rabbis were sitting there and did not stop him, this shows that they agreed with him. I will go and inform against them to the (Roman) Government. He went and told the Governor that the Jews were disloyal.
The Governor asked how he could test them. He replied, Send them an offering (to the Temple) and see if they offer it. So he sent with him a fine (unblemished) calf. On the way, Bar Kamtza made a small blemish on the calfs upper lip, in a place where we (Jews) count it as a blemish but they (the Romans) do not.
The Rabbis were inclined to (compromise and) offer it (on the Alter). Rabbi Zechariah ben Avkulos said to them, People will say that (we approved) blemished animals to be offered on the alter. Then they proposed to kill Bar Kamtza so he could not go inform against them, but Rabbi Zechariah ben Avkulos said to them, Is a person who makes a blemish on a consecrated animal to be put to death?
Rabbi Yohanan (ben Zakkai) thereupon remarked, Through the humility (scrupulousness) of Rabbi Zechariah ben Avkulos; our sanctuary was destroyed, our Temple burnt, and we ourselves exiled from our land.
According to the Talmuds account, what or who was responsible for the catastrophe? Was it just bad luck; the servants unintentional mistake in bringing the wrong man? Was it the hosts stubborn rigidity or unrelenting hostility to someone who gossiped about him? Why didnt the rabbis who were there intervene? Shaming someone in public is considered akin to murder in rabbinic thought.
Perhaps, like some ultra-orthodox Rabbis today, they didnt rebuke the hosts refusal to have anything to do with someone he looked down upon, because they were busy checking if the food was kosher enough? Perhaps those Rabbis thought there is no reason to compromise with transgressors.
Bar Kamtza is the pivotal character in this tragedy. His intention was to humiliate the Rabbis, as he was humiliated, by slandering them to the governor (he was a gossip, which is also akin to murder). But a charge of disloyalty is a dangerous charge since the governor will demand proof.
Did it occur to Bar Kamtzah that the priests would refuse to offer the calf? The Rabbis are willing to compromise the ritual purity of the offering and desecrate the alter to avoid insulting the government, but Rabbi Zechariah ben Avkulos objects. Is he a man of principle, a dangerous fanatic, or a fool? The Rabbis propose killing Bar Kamtzah to shut him up, but Zechariah ben Avkulos again objects. Does he lack the guts to do whatever is needed to prevent a war which will kill tens of thousands?
Rabbi Yohanan ben Zakkai says Rabbi Zechariah ben Avkulos humility (a lack of willingness to act decisively to transgress the Torah in order to save it) doomed the Temple. Does humility prevent Orthodox Rabbis today from solving the problems of thousands of Orthodox women whose husbands will not give them a divorce? Do they lack the guts to prohibit their followers from smoking and overeating while they keep adding stricter and stricter rules for food and female dress?
This Rabbi is known today only from his role in this catastrophe. He is called Rabbi Zechariah ben Eucolus in an account in Eicha Rabba where it is said that he was present at the party and could have prevented Bar Kamtzahs humiliation but did not intervene.
Rabbi Yose says that Zechariah ben Eucolus meekness burnt down the Temple. But Josephus, the Jewish historian, tells us that Zechariah ben Amphicalleus was a leader of a group of extremist priests who half way through the revolt overthrew the more moderate rebellious priests. Perhaps Rabbi Yohanan ben Zakkai, who lived in Jerusalem during the rebellion, used humility ironically to indicate a legalistic, narrow minded extremism dressed up as modesty.
Perhaps this is why the Talmud says that while the first Temple was destroyed because of three evils: idolatry, immorality, and bloodshed; the Second Temple was destroyed at a time when people occupied themselves with Torah, with Mitsvot, and with giving charity. Yet unfettered hatred prevailed. This should teach us that unrestrained hatred is deemed as evil as all the three sins of idolatry, immorality and bloodshed together. (Yoma 9b)
How could people who occupied themselves with Torah study, Mitsvot and Tsadakah (charity) engage freely in hate? The Talmud records this amazing statement, Rabbi Yohanan said: Jerusalem was only destroyed, because they judged by Din Torah (rigorous/strict Law). Should they have judged by the brutal (Roman) laws?(no,) but they judged by strict law, and did not go Lifnim miShurat haDin (beyond the letter of the law). (Bava Mezia 30b).
Strict halakah and narrow minded zeal easily lead to anger and hate, which unfettered and unrestrained lead to disaster. It is not surprising that Rabbi Yohanan ben Zakkai openly criticizes the failure to judge people with understanding, flexibility and loving tolerance. He was the only Rabbi in the Talmud to openly declare a Torah commandment abrogated due to changed circumstances.
All the rest of the Rabbis accomplished the same thing by legal reinterpretation rather than an open ruling. The Jewish people, especially in Israel today, need another Yohanan ben Zakkai to liberate the thousands of women who cannot get remarried because their husbands have disappeared or are refusing to give them a get (divorce).
The Quran refers to Prophet Abraham as a community or a nation: Abraham was a nation/community [Ummah]; dutiful to God, a monotheist [hanif], not one of the polytheists. (16:120) If Prophet Abraham is an Ummah then fighting between the descendants of Prophets Ishmael and Isaac is a civil war and should always be avoided.
If all Arabs and Jews can live up to the ideal that the descendants of Abrahams sons should never make war against each other is the will of God; we will help fulfill the 2700 year old vision of Prophet Isaiah: In that day there will be a highway from Egypt to Assyria. The Assyrians will go to Egypt, and the Egyptians to Assyria. The Egyptians and Assyrians will worship together.In thatdayIsrael will joina three-partyalliance with Egyptand Assyria,a blessing uponthe heart.The LORD of Hosts will bless them saying, Blessed be Egypt My people, Assyria My handiwork, and Israel My inheritance.(Isaiah 19:23-5)
See more here:
The 9th Of Av: On Failures Of Political And Religious Leadership OpEd - Eurasia Review
- Rabbi recounts fear and heroism during deadliest antisemitic attack in ... - June 8th, 2023
- A Legacy Of Leadership And Love: Rabbi Gershon Edelsteins Enduring ... - June 8th, 2023
- Rabbis of LA | Rabbi David Vorspan: The Rabbi Who Never Will Quit - Jewish Journal - June 8th, 2023
- Crime and Murder" - Rabbi Pintos harsh criticism of hurtful teachers - The Jerusalem Post - June 8th, 2023
- Rabbi Shimshon Rafael HIrsch on the parasha: Moshe and Elitism - Arutz Sheva - June 8th, 2023
- Science, Demons, and Salamanders in the Mind of a Great Rabbi ... - Mosaic - June 8th, 2023
- Evening of Song & Inspiration to Feature Rabbi YY Jacobson - COLlive - June 8th, 2023
- Rabbi Harold Kushner was a humble author and teacher - Online Athens - June 8th, 2023
- Brooklyn rabbi who fled to Israel in 2010 when he was accused of molesting children appears in court - Daily Mail - June 6th, 2023
- Why I, as an Orthodox rabbi, am committed to LGBTQ+ inclusion - St. Louis Jewish Light - June 6th, 2023
- Praying in the 21st Century With Theologian Rabbi Arthur Green - jewishboston.com - June 6th, 2023
- Trio gets 15 years in federal prison for armed carjacking spree, including of rabbi in Solon - cleveland.com - June 6th, 2023
- Who Was Rashi? | My Jewish Learning - June 4th, 2023
- Reform Rabbi Draws on His Jewish and Latino Heritage - San Diego Jewish World - June 4th, 2023
- Emmaus Freddy-winning Fiddler production powered by authentic education from local rabbi - lehighvalleylive.com - June 4th, 2023
- The Rabbi in Uniform - COLlive - June 4th, 2023
- Why I, as an Orthodox rabbi, am committed to LGBTQ+ inclusion - Forward - June 4th, 2023
- Recollections of Rabbi Yosef Goldberg - COLlive - June 4th, 2023
- Rabbi Ammiel Hirsch: We are losing the soul of the Reform movement - The Jerusalem Post - June 4th, 2023
- 'I was at shul but the problem was the rabbi wasn't' - The Jewish Chronicle - June 4th, 2023
- Turning the Page: Why a Shul Rabbi Authored a Jewish Childrens Book - Jewish Link of New Jersey - June 4th, 2023
- Rabbi Gershon Edelstein, an architect and guardian of Haredi-secular relations - The Times of Israel - May 30th, 2023
- Who will succeed Rabbi Edelstein as next leader of the non-Hasidic Haredim? - Haaretz - May 30th, 2023
- European rabbi urges auction house to withdraw Hitler items from sale - The Jerusalem Post - May 30th, 2023
- Young Long Island Rabbi Donates Kidney to a Senior Congregant - 'There was no question about what we needed to ... - Chabad.org - May 30th, 2023
- Kentuckys longest-serving rabbi honored after announcing 42-year retirement - WAVE 3 - May 30th, 2023
- Ahavas Achim's Matthews to be ordained as a rabbi - The Daily News of Newburyport - May 30th, 2023
- Live broadcast - Rabbi Pinto's spiritual revolution in Miami - The Jerusalem Post - May 30th, 2023
- I was there as an Indian, says the Rabbi-lawyer who recited Torah at the New Parliament - Moneycontrol - May 30th, 2023
- Temple Beth David Ready To Welcome New Rabbi - Cheshire Herald - May 30th, 2023
- Chief Rabbi tells the General Assembly of journey towards healing ... - The Church of Scotland - May 30th, 2023
- Legacy of 12th-century rabbi, doctor and thinker Moses Maimonides on display in NY - The Times of Israel - May 24th, 2023
- Rabbi Hershel Billet on the future of American Jewry - The Times of Israel - May 24th, 2023
- Bennett wins defamation lawsuit against rabbi who claimed he wasn't Jewish - The Times of Israel - May 24th, 2023
- Compatible Kidney Donor Turned Out to be His Chabad Rabbi - COLlive - May 24th, 2023
- Around the world: Prayers and spiritual commitments for Rabbi ... - The Jerusalem Post - May 24th, 2023
- Rabbi Lader reflects on career ahead of retirement - Cleveland Jewish News - May 24th, 2023
- OPINION: As a rabbi in a small town, I understand the Jewish class ... - The Jewish News of Northern California - May 24th, 2023
- New sefer Torah in West Houston dedicated in honor of Rabbi's father - Jewish Herald-Voice - May 24th, 2023
- This lawmaker and rabbi was scheduled to deliver an invocation. His colleagues replaced him with a Christian - Forward - May 24th, 2023
- Rabbi Pinto's Visit to Dubai with Sheikhs, Businessmen and ... - The Jerusalem Post - May 24th, 2023
- Jewish Rabbi Had A Vision Of Jesus On The Cross | God TV News - GOD TV - May 24th, 2023
- Topeka Rabbi speaks about the importance of Jewish American Heritage Month in Kansas - KSNT News - May 24th, 2023
- Rabbis in the United States | Jewish Women's Archive - May 17th, 2023
- Rabbi - New World Encyclopedia - May 17th, 2023
- It was only 50 years ago this month that the first female rabbi was ... - May 17th, 2023
- RABBI | English meaning - Cambridge Dictionary - May 17th, 2023
- Seeking answers in Judaism? It turns out, a rabbi can help. - May 17th, 2023
- Plane encounter between singer Noa Kirel and top rabbi goes viral - The Times of Israel - May 17th, 2023
- Airplane encounter between Noa Kirel and a top rabbi goes viral - The Times of Israel - May 17th, 2023
- Red carpet rolled out in Dubai: Rabbi Pintos welcome by senior governme - The Jerusalem Post - May 17th, 2023
- The Hampstead rabbi hiking Mount Everest with a Sefer Torah - The Jewish Chronicle - May 17th, 2023
- Rabbi Pinto was asked about the judicial reform; Watch his answer - The Jerusalem Post - May 17th, 2023
- This rabbi is betting $5,000 he can convince you to go vegan - Forward - May 17th, 2023
- Memory Lane: Rabbi Zvi Gottesman, Spared from the Massacre ... - Boro Park 24 - May 17th, 2023
- King Charles praised for helping chief rabbi observe Shabbat at coronation - The Times of Israel - May 6th, 2023
- Film tracks the match made in prison that turned a convict into a rabbi on a mission - The Times of Israel - May 6th, 2023
- Haredi calls for boycott of bread giant after board chair protests leading rabbi - The Times of Israel - May 6th, 2023
- Rabbi Harold Kushner asked God tough questions and shared the answers ... - May 5th, 2023
- On the brink of a rift in the nation: Rabbi Pinto calls for the strength - The Jerusalem Post - March 28th, 2023
- Religious and gay: When coming out means going up against your homophobic rabbi father - Haaretz - February 25th, 2023
- Rabbi Falk to leave Green Road Synagogue in June - Cleveland Jewish News - February 11th, 2023
- The 50 Most Influential Rabbis in America - Newsweek - January 25th, 2023
- Orthodox pilgrimage to the grave of Kabbalah rabbi buried in Istanbul picks up after COVID slump - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - January 23rd, 2023
- Science News Roundup: Meat cultivated from cow cells is kosher, Israel's chief rabbi rules; Space startups funding halved in 2022 as investors shift... - January 23rd, 2023
- Film about rabbi, civil rights activist to be screened Feb. 5 at Fox Theater - The Bakersfield Californian - January 10th, 2023
- The Granada massacre of 1066: When a Muslim mob crucified a Rabbi and murdered almost the entire Jewish population in a city - OpIndia - December 31st, 2022
- www.the-temple.org - December 27th, 2022
- Sunday Sitdown: Local rabbi reflects on meaning of Hanukkah on first night celebration - WAVY.com - December 25th, 2022
- Why Is Naftali Bennett Suing This Rabbi for Defamation? - Israel News - Haaretz - December 13th, 2022
- Spanish rabbi shares story of bridging religions with Mandel JDS - Cleveland Jewish News - December 11th, 2022
- Rabbi: Lets recommit to one another and get the polio vaccine | Opinion - NJ.com - October 15th, 2022
- A Shared Scripture Conversation between a Rabbi and a Pastor - Alpena News - October 15th, 2022
- A Kosher Vape? Meet The Rabbi-Certified Jewish Vape Brand, Oy Vapes! - Herb.co - October 15th, 2022
- Judaism and feminism: how far we have come, how far we need to go The Stute - The Stute - October 15th, 2022
- Six Greater Phoenix rabbis, other clergy highlight Arizona's 'draconian' abortion bans - Jewish News of Greater Phoenix - October 15th, 2022
- Jewish Community of Sedona and the Verde Valley: October 21-27, 2022 - Sedona.biz - October 15th, 2022
- In tribute: A man of dignity, Oklahoma's Ben Shanker, died 'at the high point of Yom Kippur'. He and his wife Shirley, of blessed memory, were my... - October 15th, 2022
- It's splendorous. It's packed with meaning. It's the etrog. J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - October 15th, 2022
- Herzog presides over quasi-biblical gathering revived by his grandfather - The Times of Israel - October 15th, 2022
Comments