This rabbi made the religious case for abortion 30 years ago it didnt go well. – Forward
Posted By admin on June 25, 2022
Information is displayed on a table at the Hope Medical Group for Women in Shreveport, Louisiana in April. When the state legislature sought to ban abortion in 1990, Rabbi Robert Loewy told lawmakers that doing so would violate the religious freedom of Jews. Photo by Getty Images
By Arno RosenfeldJune 24, 2022
Roe v. Wade was the law of the land in 1990 when a Louisiana rabbi brought a very Jewish message to the state capitol in hopes of stopping a bill that would have effectively banned abortion in the state. Now, with Fridays Supreme Court ruling overturning Roe, such bills have a much greater chance of becoming law. And Rabbi Robert Loewys 32-year-old strategy may prove more relevant.
Back then, Loewy made the drive from his home in the suburbs of New Orleans to the capitol in Baton Rouge to represent the New Orleans Jewish Federation. The states Jewish community was unified in opposition to the bill, echoing the liberal politics of most of its members. Loewy thought he had a trump card that would sway the religious lawmakers pushing the abortion ban: his own faith.
Jews, Loewy explained to a House committee, do not believe that life begins at conception as the bills sponsor had claimed, but that a fetus gradually acquires more rights as it develops.
There is a moral and ethical basis for a woman to undergo an abortion, Loewy told legislators.
J.J. Goldberg, a former editor of the Forward, recounted the episode in his 1994 book Jewish Power, and described it as a watershed moment in the communitys abortion advocacy.
The case for abortion as a matter of Jewish religious freedom is a powerful one, Goldberg wrote. But it had never before been made in a public forum.
The argument could become the next legal frontier, as Jews and Jewish groups make the case that bans and restrictions on abortion violate their First Amendment right to freely exercise their faith. The approach gained traction in early May after Politico published a leaked Supreme Court decision striking down Roe, which in 1973 established a constitutional right to abortion. The courts 6-3 ruling eviscerated that right.
At the Jewish Rally for Abortion Justice in May, speaker after speaker invoked the Jewish imperative to abortion in cases where the mothers health was at risk. Whose religious freedom are you trying to protect? Sheila Katz, chief of the National Council of Jewish Women, asked of those who are seeking to outlaw abortion. Not ours.
A synagogue in south Florida earlier this month sued to block legislation that would ban abortions after 15 weeks, arguing that it violated the state constitutions right to freedom of religion.
Rabbi Barry Silver brought the lawsuit on behalf of Congregation LDor Va-Dor, which he leads, and said that his goal was not just to send a message but to carve out protections for Jews in states where abortion is outlawed.
Its not just to make a point or something, Silver said in an interview. Its deadly serious.
But Loewys experience appealing to conservatives who sought to ban abortion 32 years ago may be instructive for the Jewish leaders making the same argument today.
Though Loewys synagogue, Congregation Gates of Prayer, was located near the liberal bubble of New Orleans, it sits in a conservative Congressional district that better reflects the rest of the state. At the time he testified on the abortion bill, his state representative was David Duke, the former grand wizard of the Klu Klux Klan.
Well aware of the legislatures conservative nature especially on abortion Loewy still thought his testimony might persuade some lawmakers by using language they could understand.
I was actually trying to say, if you believe its important to have religion in the public sphere you need to listen to one of the oldest religions, Loewy recounted in an interview this week. Probably naively I thought it would have an influence on votes.
Loewy, by most accounts, did not.
Rep. Louis Woody Jenkins, who was sponsoring the measure, mocked Loewys testimony about the Jewish tradition that babies who die before eight days should not receive a funeral.
We just heard from one crazy religion that doesnt even think babies are people after theyre born, Jenkins told reporters after the hearing.
When Loewy returned to the capitol a few days later to speak to another committee, lawmakers were prepared. Sen. Mike Cross the irony of his name was not lost on me, Loewy said interrupted the rabbi to ask if Judaism also permitted marijuana use and prostitution.
Loewy said that the Torah did not consider killing a fetus to be murder and tried to cite Exodus 21:22.
Thats not in my Bible, Cross snapped.
The incident became known as the rabbi roast, a term coined by a reporter at the time. The community backed off the religious argument, figuring that the reaction from hostile lawmakers was motivated by ignorance and intolerance of advocates for abortion rights not of Jews qua Jews.
Goldberg described local Jews as chastened by the reaction to the religious pitch for abortion access. In framing the bill as an assault on their religious freedom, he wrote, the Jewish communitys leaders may have gone one step too far.
They were holding up Jewish rights as a shield for a separate issue, on the assumption that their opponents had too much respect for religious freedom, and for Jews, to press the attack, Goldberg recounted. As they found out, that was a mistake.
Loewy said that his days testifying against the bill, which passed the legislature but would eventually be vetoed by the governor, would represent the high-water mark of his advocacy on the issue. The fierce backlash to his argument aside, abortion rights was a losing issue in a state with a huge base of conservative voters and the strong influence of the Catholic Church, which is opposed to birth control and abortion.
There are some fights that are just not worth having, Loewy said.
While Loewys approach may not have resonated in Louisiana in 1990, other Jewish leaders remain optimistic that the religious case for abortion rights is a compelling one. After NCJW sent hundreds of rabbis to lobby Congress earlier this year in support of a bill that would protect access to abortion nationally, Katz said that the legislation picked up 36 new sponsors.
It really showed us that there was power in rabbis and spiritual leaders and faith leaders showing up to say this was a religious freedom issue, Katz said. Her organization is also considering legal challenges to abortion bans and said that women who are impacted by those laws could reach out to NCJW.
While Katz emphasized the importance of challenging the idea that religion is anti-abortion, the legal question of whether outlawing abortion violates the religious freedom of Jews remains an open question.
Josh Blackman, a conservative constitutional scholar, wrote a blog post Monday arguing that liberal Jews, like those who belong to Silvers Florida synagogue, have a weak legal case when it comes to abortion because they do not follow other forms of halacha, or Jewish law.
If virtually every other facet of halacha is not binding on members of this congregation, how could it be that this one teaching on abortion is binding so binding, that a states prohibition of that teaching actually substantially burdens the free exercise of religion? Blackman wrote.
Blackmans blog post made waves on social media. Rabbi David Saperstein, a longtime leader in the Reform movement who spent decades working on religious freedom issues, said it missed a key point. The law typically requires only that a plaintiffs beliefs are sincere meaning judges would be unlikely to parse the difference between Reform and Orthodox Jews.
Saperstein said the larger challenge for Jews suing over abortion bans would be that the government could successfully argue that it had a legitimate societal interest in passing these laws that even sincere religious beliefs cannot override. This is similar to the reason why laws prohibiting child marriage have been upheld, despite some religions that encourage it.
Ironically, another potential victory for religious conservatives might open the door to a Jewish abortion exemption. Several Supreme Court justices appear willing to strike down a vaccine mandate in New York State that allows medical exemptions but bans religious ones, Saperstein noted. While Jews have historically opposed such religious carve outs, they may now turn to that line of argument in legal battles over abortion.
If you allow exemptions for anything you should allow it for people who have a legitimate religious claim, Saperstein said, and here the Jewish claim would be very strong.
Arno Rosenfeld is an enterprise reporter for the Forward, where he covers antisemitism, philanthropy and American Jewish institutions. You can reach him at arno@forward.com and follow him on Twitter @arnorosenfeld.
See the rest here:
This rabbi made the religious case for abortion 30 years ago it didnt go well. - Forward
- What Matters Now to Rabbi Seth Farber: Hostages and mixed burials in Jewish law - The Times of Israel - November 24th, 2023
- Our Rabbi Barricaded the Class Door, Warning us to Play Dead - Newsweek - November 24th, 2023
- Rabbi Mark Gottlieb on A Jewish Theology of Resurrection | R. R. Reno - First Things - November 24th, 2023
- This rabbi says the 'fundamental threat' in Israel is not Hamas - CNN - November 24th, 2023
- Argentina's President-Elect To Visit Grave Of World-Famous Rabbi ... - The Daily Wire - November 24th, 2023
- Rabbi Dee: 'People need to understand why Israel is fighting this war' - The Jewish Chronicle - November 24th, 2023
- Denver rabbi headed to Israel on mission to help - CBS News - November 24th, 2023
- Rabbi Betsy Forester on achieving peace in Israel and Gaza - PBS Wisconsin - November 24th, 2023
- Opinion: As a rabbi and ex-student activist, my advice to protesters - Montreal Gazette - November 24th, 2023
- Wayland rabbi says Gaza attacks unleashed torrent of antisemitism - MetroWest Daily News - November 24th, 2023
- Swastikas found on Jewish building inspire Kalamazoo rabbi to create more light - MLive.com - November 24th, 2023
- What the 'DaVinci Code' did for the Catholic Church, Rabbi Shook's ... - St. Louis Jewish Light - November 24th, 2023
- Real Talk: The Rabbi who brought the hostages' families to the 'Ohel' - Arutz Sheva - November 24th, 2023
- Existence of Zionist Israel is antithetical to Judaism: Rabbi Weiss - TRT World - November 24th, 2023
- Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch on the parsha: Don't let the angels ... - Arutz Sheva - November 24th, 2023
- Help little Miriam: Rabbi's daughter kept tripping, mother horrified to ... - Arutz Sheva - November 24th, 2023
- Arizona man charged with threatening to execute rabbi and other Jews - CNN - November 10th, 2023
- Shluchim Give Standing Ovation to Rabbi Kotlarsky at Kinus - COLlive - November 10th, 2023
- Calabasas Rabbi Ordered to Testify in Lawsuit Against Imprisoned ... - Westside Current - November 10th, 2023
- IDF disavows comments by military rabbi calling for conquering Gaza and Lebanon - The Times of Israel - November 10th, 2023
- When the rabbi of your youth dies - Religion News Service - November 10th, 2023
- Frum Rabbi Elected In New Jersey's 30th Legislative District Will ... - CrownHeights.info - November 10th, 2023
- A hassidic grand rabbi's voice of support of the IDF amid war with ... - The Jerusalem Post - November 10th, 2023
- What Makes a Good Rabbi? - Chabad.org - October 31st, 2023
- Rabbi who survived Pittsburgh synagogue shooting 5 years ago considers this dark time - The Times of Israel - October 31st, 2023
- Sgt. Binyamin Loeb, 23: Orthodox paratrooper son of French rabbi - The Times of Israel - October 31st, 2023
- Over 100 U.S. Colleges and Universities Join Rabbi Ari Berman's ... - Yu News - October 31st, 2023
- Local rabbi at rally: Standing with Israel is only choice - Yoursun.com - October 31st, 2023
- Rabbi Braun: "Act This Shabbos The Way You Act Avery Shabbos" - CrownHeights.info - October 31st, 2023
- We have to keep on keeping these lives alive: Rabbi Chaim Mentz - Fox News - October 25th, 2023
- "Do not allow hatred to reign": Twin Cities Rabbi visits Israel amid ongoing conflict - CBS News - October 25th, 2023
- Beverly Hills Politician and Rabbi Launch Campaign to Boycott ... - Middle East Forum - October 25th, 2023
- I'm a Rabbi. Here's Why I Went to a Murdered Palestinian Boy's ... - The Daily Beast - October 25th, 2023
- The Priest, the Rabbi and the Beirut Terrorist Attack of 1983 - National Catholic Register - October 25th, 2023
- Is This the End Times? Is 'Hamas' in the Bible? Messianic Rabbi on ... - Faithwire - October 25th, 2023
- Boston rabbi recounts horrors of Hamas terror attack in Israel - Boston Herald - October 25th, 2023
- Kentuckians rally in support of Palestine, Rabbi says he wants to share love in the face of hate - Fox 56 News - October 25th, 2023
- Rabbi talks release of Evanston mother and daughter by Hamas - NBC Chicago - October 25th, 2023
- Chief Rabbi Lau Meets Troops in the South: 'In the Z'chus of Unity ... - http://hamodia.com - October 25th, 2023
- Rabbi Definition & Meaning | Britannica Dictionary - September 24th, 2023
- Urgent call from Rabbi Gluckowsky: Anash and Shluchim in Eretz ... - COLlive - September 24th, 2023
- The Rabbi and the Rock (Special Podcast Highlight) - Relevant Radio - September 24th, 2023
- Rabbi Matondo in Rangers rallying cry as he hopes fans stick with them - Daily Record - September 24th, 2023
- Protesters hound homophobic rabbi in Tel Aviv amid uproar over religious group - The Times of Israel - September 22nd, 2023
- From a Rabbi to my Catholic friends: We must confront what Pope Pius XII knew about the Holocaust. - America: The Jesuit Review - September 22nd, 2023
- Final probe into prominent German Reform rabbi affirms abuse of power allegations - The Times of Israel - September 22nd, 2023
- On my umpteenth trip to Uman, I finally visited Rabbi Nachmans grave - The Times of Israel - September 22nd, 2023
- Golf with Rabbi Dave | Entertainment | theunion.com - The Union - September 22nd, 2023
- Remembering Rabbi Matthew H. Simon, zl - Jewish Federation of Greater Washington - September 22nd, 2023
- The Rabbi and the Rock - Relevant Radio - September 22nd, 2023
- Temple Institute Rabbi: 'Jews came from all of Israel to blow the ... - Arutz Sheva - September 22nd, 2023
- Rangers Rabbi Matondo dreaming of chance to be involved in Europa League run - Yahoo News UK - September 22nd, 2023
- Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch on the parshah: Cowering in fear - Arutz Sheva - September 22nd, 2023
- Judah ha-Nasi - Wikipedia - August 30th, 2023
- Rabbi who lied to, had sex with several women to have detention extended - The Jerusalem Post - August 30th, 2023
- Israeli rabbi fired by yeshiva after he catfished dozens of women on secular dating apps - The Jewish Chronicle - August 30th, 2023
- Married Israeli rabbi used aliases to lure women on dating apps - The Times - August 30th, 2023
- An Actual Rabbi's Thoughts on Rabbi Rebecca From 'You Are So Not Invited to My Bat Mitzvah' - Alma - August 30th, 2023
- Rabbi Steve Leder on why good people do bad things - Spectrum News 1 - August 30th, 2023
- An American rabbi answers her congregants question: Why do they hate us? - The Times of Israel - August 30th, 2023
- Rabbi Aaron Marsh is a new face at the East Meadow Beth-El ... - liherald.com - August 30th, 2023
- A Kansas City rabbi publishes a new book on embracing 'everyday ... - KCUR - August 30th, 2023
- Young Rabbi Attacked in Crown Heights; Action Still Wasn't Taken - COLlive - August 30th, 2023
- The Time Rabbi Hodakov Apologized to the Rebbe - COLlive - August 30th, 2023
- Before MLK told us he had a dream, a Newark rabbi advised us not to remain silent | Opinion - NJ.com - August 30th, 2023
- Local rabbi, cantorial soloist want to help you stop on Shabbat ... - Jewish News of Greater Phoenix - August 30th, 2023
- York gets first rabbi since community decimated by infamous 1190 pogrom - The Times of Israel - August 8th, 2023
- Spokesman for Hebron: Rabbi Kook resurrected the holy city - Arutz Sheva - August 8th, 2023
- Fade in the Water and Jamie Foxxs Apology With Rabbi Dr. Ari Lamm - The Ringer - August 8th, 2023
- New Discovery/Max reality show 'Survive the Raft' features a Messianic 'rabbi' who says 'I'm Jewish, too' - St. Louis Jewish Light - August 8th, 2023
- New US reality show features a Messianic rabbi who says Im Jewish, too - The Times of Israel - August 8th, 2023
- History-making trans rabbi wants young people to find joy and ... - PinkNews - August 8th, 2023
- Rabbi Pinto in a heartrending talk from his sickbed: "I was between life - The Jerusalem Post - August 8th, 2023
- Tree of Life rabbi says community can begin to heal after shooter sentenced - The Times of Israel - August 8th, 2023
- Rescuing a Rabbi in Buchenwald - International Fellowship of Christians and Jews - August 8th, 2023
- Leon Black's failed rabbi father Eli killed himself in 1975 after trying to bribe Honduras to lower the banana - Daily Mail - August 8th, 2023
- Return of the Wild West Rabbi - Chabad.org - August 8th, 2023
- Rabbi speaks out on being last person to see murdered 14-year-old - New York Post - August 8th, 2023
- Why this rabbi isnt celebrating (or dismissing) the latest Trump indictments - Forward - August 8th, 2023
- Meet the Hampstead rabbi who will do anything for others - The Jewish Chronicle - July 28th, 2023
Comments