How will history judge Trump and his enablers? Youre asking the wrong question. – Forward
Posted By admin on February 6, 2021
From the day Donald Trump was ushered into the White House to the day he was ushered out, commentators have found comfort in the phrase history will judge. If they mean that historians will not look kindly on Donald Trump and his enablers, they are probably right. But right or wrong, their judgment will probably not matter to future generations. We need look no further than the tension between Jewish history and Jewish memory to understand why this is so.
In his brilliant book Zakhor, which examines the fraught relationship between Jewish history and Jewish memory, the late historian Yosef Yerushalmi claimed that the latter will always best the former. The Jewish imperative to remember declensions of the verb zakhor ring out nearly 200 times in the Hebrew Bible has long had little if anything to do with the writing of history. Until the modern era, Yerushalmi argues, Jews were less interested in establishing historical narratives than in establishing metahistorical meaning. With the destruction of the Temple in 70 CE, the rabbis had all the history they needed.
Yerushalmis insight oddly echoes the old joke about the two Jewish women complaining about a restaurants fare: The food was terrible says one; Yes, and it was such small portions too, says the other. So, too, with the Jewish response to historys fare: The servings are few and terrible. From the fall of the Temple in 70 CE and the expulsion from Spain to the Polish pogroms and the Shoah, the servings of history have been traumatic. As a result, it is as if everything and nothing has changed over the millennia. If the prophets, writes Yerushalmi, had established the pattern to history based on the destruction of the Temple, it is a pattern that seems to have stuck with us ever since.
Medieval Jews, writes Yerushalmi, continued to subsume even major new events to familiar archetype through the early modern era. In the wake of the Spanish expulsion, Jews did not turn to history and historiography for comprehension, but instead to the Kabbalah for consolation. The mystical teachings of Isaac Luria offered an interpretation of history that lay beyond history. The desire for something more than history to explain history remains embedded in Jewish culture. Reflecting on the massive historiography of the Shoah, Yerushalmi more or less concludes that rarely have so many historians done so much to inform so few. Instead, most Jews have turned to literature and ideology in their search for meaning. The result, Yerushalmi concludes is that while many Jews are searching for a past, they patently do not want the past that is offered by the historian.
All of this casts a sharp light not just on the relationship between Jews and their history, but also between other groups and their histories. While commentators invoke history as the measure by which Trump will be judged, some of these groups have different measures in mind. Clearly, this is case with Americas religious right.. As Andrew Whitehead and Samuel L. Perry argue in their new book Taking Back America for God, this powerful movement embraces a specific vision of Christianitys relationship to American identity and civic life.
We can add American history to that list of relationships. The Christian right is as dismissive of academic historians as early modern European Jews were of the few scholars who sought to base history on worldy, not other-wordly causes. profane history to explain 1492. Then and now, these groups thought traditional historiography irrelevant at best, invidious at worst. In fact, for Christian nationalists like mega-preacher Robert Jeffress, the real purveyors of myth are the trained historians. We are, in their eyes, a benighted profession either clueless or contemptuous of this countrys Christian foundations. Our success, he warns his flock, depends on our country being faithful to those eternal truths of Gods word.
What Lurias followers and Christian nationalists share is the conviction that the pasts meaning is found not in material, political, or social changes, but instead in unchanging and transcendental truths. Then and now, history is not the study of events unfolding causally but instead, as Yerushalmi argues, a series of situations into which one could somehow be existentially drawn. No less important, for both groups, this approach to history seems to endow the individual with the power to participate actively in hastening its messianic liquidation.
The similarities end here, though. One crucial difference between the two religious groups is that the kabbalists did not participate actively by storming palaces and churches. Instead, they limited their participation in repairing the world to performing mitzvahs. As for the Christian insurrectionists, repairing the world means tearing it apart and terrorizing those still wedded to its reality. While Jeffress condemned the insurrection as sinful, he refused to condemn former President Trump declaring: I dont regret for one minute supporting him.
For those of us devoted to our democracy and our world, this moment has existential import. At such a moment, Yerushalmi believed, historians have a crucial role to play. But it is a role that demands an audience. If our books are to be read, we must write them for readers beyond the academy. We cannot succeed by continuing to write on narrow topics in turgid prose. The divorce of history from literature, Yerushalmi lamented, has been catastrophic for both Jewish and non-Jewish historical writing. Those who are alienated from the past cannot be drawn to it by explanation alone; they require evocation as well. The most urgent of mitzvahs that historians can perform is not to tell us to judge who is guilty or innocent, but instead to show us to evoke how we reached the point. This is the first step to take if we hope to avoid reaching such points ever again.
Robert Zaretsky teaches at the University of Houston. His new book, The Subversive Simone Weil: A Life in Five Ideas, will be published in February by University of Chicago Press.
Read this article:
How will history judge Trump and his enablers? Youre asking the wrong question. - Forward
- 'The Shoah Songbook' to be Performed on Holocaust ... - OperaWire - November 28th, 2023
- Opinion | The Paradigm Shift of 10/7 and A Plan for the Jewish Future - Fathom Journal - November 28th, 2023
- I Found Surprising Comfort in the Polish Village My Ancestors Once ... - Alma - November 28th, 2023
- An angry God outside Uttarkashi tunnel, a manhunt inside Gaza tunnels, and overcoming tunnels of the mind: Eye-catching photos of the week - Forbes... - November 28th, 2023
- Premium Doc On Genghis Khan Expedition In The Works With Pernel Media - Deadline - November 28th, 2023
- Steve McQueen and Jonathan Glazer Confront the Holocaust - The Nation - November 28th, 2023
- USC Shoah Foundation's exhibit included in the Holocaust Museum ... - uscannenbergmedia.com - November 18th, 2023
- The Real Danger of Using Holocaust Analogies Right Now - TIME - November 18th, 2023
- 'Never since the Shoah has the Jews of France felt so isolated ... - The Jerusalem Post - November 16th, 2023
- Have we forgotten the lessons of Shoah? - The Spectator - November 16th, 2023
- Exploring the emotional recovery of a Shoah survivor who lost father ... - The Jewish Chronicle - November 16th, 2023
- A look at St. Louis International Film Festival's Jewish-themed and ... - St. Louis Jewish Light - November 16th, 2023
- Tuesday in Washington - The Jewish Star - November 16th, 2023
- The Legacy of Filmmaker Claude Lanzmann - United States Holocaust ... - November 4th, 2023
- Castaways Theatre Production of Shoah January 5 to 14, 2024 - Prince William Living - November 4th, 2023
- Shoah Foundation to capture Oct. 7 testimonies - Daily Trojan Online - November 4th, 2023
- Antisemitism on Wikipedia: Distorting the History of the Holocaust - USC Shoah Foundation | - October 31st, 2023
- Antisemitism and the Blood Libel | USC Shoah Foundation - USC Shoah Foundation | - October 31st, 2023
- USC Shoah Foundation to collect testimony on Hamas onslaught - The Times of Israel - October 29th, 2023
- A polarizing tale of the Lodz Ghetto, retold as horror story and farce - Forward - October 29th, 2023
- Holocaust scholars weigh in on politicians comparisons of Hamas to Nazis - The Times of Israel - October 29th, 2023
- Needed now more than ever: 'Survivors,' with its diverse cast ... - eJewish Philanthropy - October 29th, 2023
- Shoah Foundation to collect testimonies from survivors of Oct. 7 ... - Haaretz - October 27th, 2023
- SHOAH E'NUFF: WHY I AM WRITING IN MIRIAM TYRK FOR CITY ... - The Red Hook Star-Revue - October 27th, 2023
- They should leave the Holocaust alone - EL PAS USA - October 27th, 2023
- Shoah movie review & film summary (1985) | Roger Ebert - October 25th, 2023
- Don't Call Hamas Nazis; If they are not Nazis, what are they? - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - October 25th, 2023
- Online Antisemitism in International Contexts and Ways to Track it - USC Shoah Foundation | - October 25th, 2023
- The Legacy of Schindler's List: Commemorating the Film's 30th ... - USC Shoah Foundation | - October 14th, 2023
- Community memorial for the worst tragedy to befall the Jewish ... - Jewish News - October 14th, 2023
- President Folt's statement regarding the situation in Israel and Gaza - USC Shoah Foundation | - October 14th, 2023
- Lithuania must acknowledge its role in the Holocaust - opinion - The Jerusalem Post - September 26th, 2023
- The White Factory review: An important addition to the Shoah canon - The Jewish Chronicle - September 22nd, 2023
- In an unsettling account of French collaboration with Nazis, disturbing parallels with todays politics - Forward - September 22nd, 2023
- Mom Shocked By 8th Grade Teacher Reading Anne Frank's Diary ... - Bored Panda - September 22nd, 2023
- On the History of Antisemitism | USC Shoah Foundation - USC Shoah Foundation | - September 18th, 2023
- Renaissance of Italian synagogues and cemeteries showcased at Ferrara Jewish museum - The Times of Israel - September 18th, 2023
- The lesson of history & hate: Is Holocaust 1.0 the new Holocaust ... - New York Daily News - September 18th, 2023
- Catholic institutions offered shelter to Jews during the Second World ... - Jesuits Global - September 18th, 2023
- How I learned to fill in the gaps in my family's Shoah story - The Jewish Chronicle - September 12th, 2023
- The Zoryan Institute Issues an Open Letter to the Rabbinical Centre of Europe - Armenian News by MassisPost - September 12th, 2023
- Village View: USC Shoah Foundation to celebrate 30th anniversary - Main Line - August 22nd, 2023
- 78 years after the Shoah, Israels air defense system to protect ... - JNS.org - August 22nd, 2023
- Sidney Itzkowitz fought with Jewish partisans behind Nazi lines ... - The Globe and Mail - August 22nd, 2023
- Oprah Winfrey Net Worth 2023: What Is The TV Host Worth? - HotNewHipHop - August 22nd, 2023
- Holocaust survivor whose family were ripped apart during the Shoah ... - The Jewish Chronicle - August 14th, 2023
- Deny and Distort | USC Shoah Foundation - USC Shoah Foundation | - August 14th, 2023
- The ultimate Jewish guide to Milan: What to see, eat and do ... - Jewish Unpacked - August 14th, 2023
- Antisemitism and Radical Anti-Israel Bias on the Political Left in ... - ADL - August 14th, 2023
- Remembering the Treblinka rebellion - JNS.org - August 14th, 2023
- From Nazi Camp to Memorial Centre: In Serbia, the Transition Isn't ... - Balkan Insight - August 14th, 2023
- Controversy swirls around Bollywood romcom and use of Shoah ... - JNS.org - August 3rd, 2023
- A Film About the Holocaust Survivor Who Helped Make Abortion ... - Kveller.com - August 3rd, 2023
- Our doors are open: York gets its first resident rabbi in more than 800 years - The Guardian - August 3rd, 2023
- Making a difference in the community - Australian Jewish News - August 3rd, 2023
- Seven weeks of consolation! | 7 - Arutz Sheva - August 3rd, 2023
- Letters to the editor, 4 August 2023 - The Jewish Chronicle - August 3rd, 2023
- Rabbi Uziel and the Holocaust: New Readings for Tisha b'Av - Jewish Journal - July 20th, 2023
- Why Germany Struggled to Reckon With the Nazi Past - Jacobin magazine - July 20th, 2023
- The fight against British extremism is never over - The Jewish Chronicle - July 20th, 2023
- David Shulick Promoted to Vice President of Corporate Affairs for ... - PR Web - July 20th, 2023
- Keep the Postal Service Out of the Booze Delivery Business - gvwire.com - July 20th, 2023
- In-N-Out Burger Employees Forbidden to Wear Masks Unless They Have a Doctors Note - gvwire.com - July 20th, 2023
- In Sweden, they burn Torahs - Religion News Service - July 20th, 2023
- Nazis in the cellar: is antisemitism coming out of hiding? - Prospect Magazine - July 20th, 2023
- Why this vegan activist's Holocaust analogy has angered the Jewish ... - SBS News - July 20th, 2023
- CA High-Speed Rail Gets Busy in 2023 With Five New Overcrossings - gvwire.com - July 20th, 2023
- The 25 Highest-Rated Movies of All Time on Letterboxd - MovieWeb - July 20th, 2023
- Diary shows hardships of post-Shoah refugees - The Jewish Star - July 14th, 2023
- Virtual Reality Brings New Look at the Holocaust - The Media Line - July 14th, 2023
- Peter Moffat to adapt The Escape Artist - Televisual - July 14th, 2023
- Preserving histories: Teaching the Holocaust to future generations - Worcester Mag - July 14th, 2023
- Roundup: Bears In The Woods, Hiro On The Mound - 06880 - July 14th, 2023
- I dreamed of joining the IDF growing up and finally donned the ... - The Jewish Chronicle - July 14th, 2023
- As Tree of Life trial enters final phase, 6 Jewish scholars on what text and tradition say about the death penalty - Forward - July 14th, 2023
- USC Shoah Foundation Testimonies - United States Holocaust Memorial Museum - July 9th, 2023
- The riots in France have become antisemitic - opinion - The Jerusalem Post - July 9th, 2023
- Obituary: Sidney Cyngiser, 99, shared his story about the Shoah ... - The Canadian Jewish News - July 7th, 2023
- Parisian Holocaust Memorial Trashed The European Conservative - The European Conservative - July 7th, 2023
- Reunion of Torah Scrolls | Community | thejewishnews.com - The Jewish News - July 7th, 2023
Comments