What to Stream: The Sorrow and the Pity, a Historical Documentary That Transformed Frances National Identity – The New Yorker
Posted By admin on July 14, 2022
All films relate to their place and time, but some are nearly incomprehensible out of context. Thats the case with Marcel Ophulss great 1969 documentary, The Sorrow and the Pity, even though its story is well known. The two-part, four-hour film, which is streaming on OVID in a new restoration and is also available on Milestone and Kanopy, is about the Second World War in France, focussed on life in the small city of Clermont-Ferrand, in the center of the country. It covers the German invasion and the Occupation of France; the formation of the Vichy regime, just twenty-nine miles from Clermont, under Marshal Philippe Ptain; the rise of the French Resistance; and the Liberation in 1944 and its aftermath. What has made those facts familiar is, in significant measure, the film itself: its a work of history that changed the course of history, and its impact on its moment is exemplified in the opposition that it faced and ultimately overcame.
In The Sorrow and the Pity, Ophulsmaking his first feature-length documentarytells a vast and intricate story in a form that now seems classical, even hackneyed. Its composed mainly of interviews with a wide-ranging group of participants and witnesses to the events. Ophuls cuts the material into interview bites and assembles them to develop the storys arc; the interviews are punctuated with illustrative archival footage. As familiar as the format is now, when Ophuls made The Sorrow and the Pity, few documentaries of note were constructed in this way. Extended on-camera interviews depended on portable synch-sound equipment that was developed only in the late nineteen-fifties, resulting in Jean Rouch and Edgar Morins Chronicle of a Summer (the film for which Morin coined the term cinma-vrit), Robert Drews Primary, and such successors as the Maysles brothers Salesman and Frederick Wisemans Hospital.
Unlike those modern masterworks, however, The Sorrow and the Pity is neither immersive nor reflexive. Instead, its originality is found in its very simplicityits deceptive modesty. Though Ophuls and his co-writer, Andr Harris, are heard, sometimes even seen, in discussion with the interview subjects, the movie doesnt emphasize these interactions or their centrality to the onscreen action. Rather, their intervention is at its most emphatic, and most conspicuous, in the editing of the large body of interview footage (between fifty and sixty hours worth, according to Ophuls) into a taut, coherent narrative. Ophuls and Harris rarely challenge the subjects assumptions or assertions; putting their interviewees at ease, they collect a varied and copious array of accounts and perspectives. This very varietyits panoramic scope, its complexity, its conflicting points of viewis the films raison dtre.
The interviews feature a remarkable range of participants, filmed on location (in their homes or workplaces, or in public, or at a cannily chosen site of significance) and suggesting a cross-section of French society during the war: a sampling of classes, ideologies, and wartime activities that renders the individual speakers and their experiences both singular and exemplary. (Only the dearth of women as onscreen subjects diminishes the films representative authority.) The Sorrow and the Pity includes Resistance fighters from modest circumstanceswhether farmers or working peopleas well as high-ranking politicians and even aristocrats who were motivated by patriotism, indignation, or ideology. The film similarly spotlights collaborators from the cosseted haute bourgeoisie, along with middle-class functionaries and small-business owners who were pressured into coperation with the occupiers. Theres even an unrepentant defender of Vichy (and the son-in-law of one of its officials) who takes grotesque pains to minimize the effects of the Holocaust on Jews in France and of the French governments part in it. Ophuls also puts the daily life of the Occupation and the Resistance into an international political context, by way of interviews with British politicians and officers, German officials (including a translator for Hitler), and the French politician Pierre Mends France, who worked with the Free French government-in-exile of Charles de Gaulle. (Along with his tale of anti-Semitic persecution under Vichy and his escape from France, Mends France offers warnings about the enduring and unquenched temptations of anti-Semitism and xenophobia.)
Ophulss editorial storytelling has a deft brilliance that moves imperceptibly between the personal and the general, the representative and the distinctive. Theres a mighty, quasi-literary power to the interviews: the story of a Clermont shopkeeper named Klein, who took pains to avoid being misidentified as Jewish (a strange anticipation of Joseph Loseys 1976 drama, Monsieur Klein); a woman whod been convicted, based on handwriting samples, of denouncing a resister to the Gestapo; and the story of a gay British spy with a German lover in Paris. We learn of the narrow escape of French politicians to Morocco en route to London and the excruciating decision of British leaders to bomb the French fleet in Mers-el-Kbir, Algeria (then a French territory), to prevent it from falling into German hands. The farmer Louis Grave, who was active in the Resistance, was denounced, arrested, and deported to Buchenwald, but, after the Liberation, he refused to seek revenge against the person who denounced him to the Gestaponor did Grave offer forgiveness. He bore the knowledge of the betrayal as if it were a form of moral revenge, superior to prosecution or violence.
This range of backgrounds, inclinations, and activities marks the frame-shattering power of Ophulss practical aesthetic. He states publicly what, in the twenty-five years that separated the film from the Liberation, had been privately understood, whether in family circles or in the halls of power, but had gone largely unexpressed. He contradicts the foundational myth of Frances postwar Fourth and Fifth Republicsnamely, that France, with the exception of some dastardly politicians and a relatively small number of collaborators, was largely a country of resistance, that the French Resistance far outweighed and outnumbered French collaborationists. For that matter, the film also presents an intellectual X-ray of the ideological morass of anti-Semitism and anti-Communism that underlay Frances defeat by Germany and readiness to collaboratethe demonization of the democratic moderate left, the preference of many for an anti-democratic far right, the racist hatred that fuels such a bent, and the admiration for a bloodthirsty foreign dictator who fosters and abets those authoritarian sympathies. (A word to the wise.)
The Sorrow and the Pity in no way diminishes the commitment or effectiveness of Resistance fighters or their behind-the-scenes abetters and enablers. Far from debunking the Resistance, Ophuls intensifies our vision of the heroism of the resisters, precisely because their actions were exceptionalbecause they took place amid the heads-down passivity of many neighbors and the active hostility of others. Whats more, the documentary also emphasizes that active sympathizers to the Resistance, who didnt bear arms but aided it merely by knowing about itby knowing that their neighbors were engaged in partisan combat and saying nothingwere also heroic. The potential price of resistancearrest, torture, execution, deportation to concentration campsshrieks through the interviews, too, highlighting the courage of resisters while also suggesting empathy with those who merely went about their business. One interviewee, the British politician Anthony Eden, serves as something like Ophulss spokesperson, reserving his judgment upon the people of France under Vichy by asserting that those who havent experienced the horror of an occupation by a foreign power have no right to pronounce upon those who did.
In its matter-of-factness, the film is nonetheless a work of outrage, less at individuals, even the most contemptible on view, than at France as a wholepostwar France and its self-silencing, self-exonerating political mythology. Theres something strangely, implicitly meta about The Sorrow and the Pity: its main story is that France has been telling itself a story. Yet that myth, of a nation of resisters, isnt explicitly unfolded in the film any more than, say, the myth of Manifest Destiny is unfolded in the greatest Hollywood Westerns; its there as the unchallenged and ambient background to the action, the underlying idea on which the action depends. In TheSorrowand the Pity, that action is the talk that reveals the fabrication of that founding myth. The entirety of the movie is, in effect, a counter-storyi.e., the complex and intractable truth, which had little place in French public life or in the sense of French identity. Its as if all of France were implicated as the documentarys virtual reverse angleits challenging, defiant closeup.
Ophuls, who was born in 1927, was a participant in the Events of May, 1968. He, along with his films producers, Harris and Alain de Sedouy, were working for French television at the time and went on strike, which cost them their jobs and their programs. For all the political demands of students and other activists at the time, the crucial focus of May was a cultural shift: a breaking-down of ossified mores, of the out-of-touch and out-of-synch barrier between Frances public culture and its residents lives.
Yet the film, in attempting to break the silence on the realities of Vichy France, was subjected to a silencing. The Sorrow and the Pity premired in West Germany in 1969, but, although intended for French television (which was then entirely state-run), it was rejected for broadcast by means of a subterfuge that was itself a silencing. The filmmakers held private screenings, but televisions bureaucratic decision-makers simply never attended them, claiming that they had no time to consider such a long filmas if, in trying to avoid the likely controversy of rejecting the film on its merits, they were ignoring it in the hope that it would go away. Instead, the movie received a very limited theatrical release, and wasnt shown on French television until October, 1981five months after Franois Mitterrand, a Socialist, was elected President of France. Once it did air, according to Le Monde, it wasnt the political and sociological event that the channels had anticipated. This ostensible failure was a mark of the films success: in its relatively clandestine way, it had already done its epochal job. The silence was broken; the revelations had become common knowledge.
Go here to see the original:
- Anti-Israel Groups Push White House To Weaken Recognized Anti-Semitism Definition - Washington Free Beacon - May 20th, 2023
- Jewish Students at Yale Law School Invited an Israeli Politician To Speak About Anti-Semitism. Then They Caved to Pressure. - Washington Free Beacon - April 22nd, 2023
- History of antisemitism in the United States - Wikipedia - April 16th, 2023
- History of antisemitism - Wikipedia - April 8th, 2023
- Anti-Defamation League reports dramatic rise in antisemitism - PBS NewsHour - March 25th, 2023
- Houston ranked among worst offenders for anti-Semitism - KTRK-TV - March 24th, 2023
- Anti-Semitism - Nazi anti-Semitism and the Holocaust | Britannica - February 7th, 2023
- Anti-Semitism | History, Facts, & Examples | Britannica - February 2nd, 2023
- Antisemitism - Wikipedia - February 2nd, 2023
- Origins and concept of anti-Semitism | Britannica - February 2nd, 2023
- Lizzy Savetsky exits RHONY reboot over anti-Semitism - January 6th, 2023
- Benjamin Netanyahu: Anti-Semitism Is The Oldest Disease, Given Extra ... - December 31st, 2022
- Governor Ron DeSantis Signs Anti-Semitism Protections Bill CS/CS/HB 741 - December 31st, 2022
- Kanye West: I've been 'beat to a pulp' amid anti-Semitism scandal - December 21st, 2022
- Don Lemon Critiques Dave Chappelle Monologue on SNL - December 21st, 2022
- Anti-Semitic incidents in US hit all-time high, according to new ADL ... - December 21st, 2022
- Dave Chappelle Sets Hair Aflame, Now Being Accused of Anti-Semitism ... - November 26th, 2022
- Between Kanye and the Midterms, the Unsettling Stream of Antisemitism - The New York Times - November 6th, 2022
- Kyrie Irving will begin suspension of at least 5 games Friday over antisemitism controversy. The NBA star has since apologized - CNN - November 6th, 2022
- New opinion poll illuminates growing challenges of polarization and ... - October 19th, 2022
- Meng, Fitzpatrick, Manning, Weber, Veasey, Granger, Lieu And Smith Call For Update From State Department On Its Investigation Into Instances Of... - October 19th, 2022
- Anti-Semitism and the Socialist Workers Party - World Socialist Web Site - WSWS - October 19th, 2022
- Where Kanye Wests brand deals stand amid anti-Semitism, WLM controversies - Page Six - October 19th, 2022
- Kanye West reaches out to Donald Trump amid anti-Semitic backlash - The News International - October 19th, 2022
- Partisan bias created a toxic media culture that tolerates anti-Semitism - JNS.org - October 19th, 2022
- CUNY Union President Blames White Christian Nationalism for Anti ... - October 1st, 2022
- Anselm Franke on the Future of documenta: Were witnessing old structures not wanting to die - Notes - E-Flux - October 1st, 2022
- Hill TV Segment on Rashida Tlaib and Israel Is Censored - The Intercept - October 1st, 2022
- The past echoes in the present: A review of Ken Burns' 'The U.S. and the Holocaust - Idaho Capital Sun - October 1st, 2022
- Toronto launches awareness campaign to combat anti-Semitism - September 18th, 2022
- Investigation underway into antisemitism at U of Vermont - The Associated Press - en Espaol - September 18th, 2022
- 'The number 6 million is impenetrable': Burns discusses new film, 'The U.S. and the Holocaust' New Hampshire Bulletin - New Hampshire Bulletin - September 9th, 2022
- Here's why conspiracy theories about Jeffrey Epstein keep flourishing - NPR - September 9th, 2022
- Ben & Jerry's will amend lawsuit against Unilever over Israel ice cream sale - Reuters.com - September 9th, 2022
- Will Viktor Orbn Bring His Racist Rhetoric to the United States this Week? - Center For American Progress - August 4th, 2022
- Macron decries anti-Semitism on 80th anniversary of Jewish deportations - Reuters.com - July 19th, 2022
- Former Oath Keeper reveals racist, antisemitic beliefs of white nationalist group and their plans to start a civil war - The Conversation Indonesia - July 14th, 2022
- 53 Percent Blame Fox News for Spread of Extremist Ideologies Like ... - July 8th, 2022
- Was the Patriot Front March in Boston a Sign of the New KKK? - Boston University - July 8th, 2022
- New UK-Led Initiative to Enhance Kentucky K-12 Holocaust Education - UKNow - June 4th, 2022
- No, Ann Coulter, I Am Not Responsible for the 'Great Replacement' Theory - The Atlantic - June 4th, 2022
- Statement from the Catholic Diocese of Cleveland and Lake Catholic High School May 25, 2022 - Catholic Diocese of Cleveland - May 27th, 2022
- Slavery, Anti-Semitism and Harvards Missing Moral Compass - The Wall Street Journal - May 20th, 2022
- The Intersectionality of Hate - The Atlantic - May 20th, 2022
- Philadelphias Jewish history museum reopens after bankruptcy and a 2-year shutdown - The Philadelphia Inquirer - May 20th, 2022
- Israel Observes Holocaust Remembrance Day Amid a Global Rise of Anti ... - May 8th, 2022
- Governor Abbott Appoints Parker, Names Goldberg Chair Of Texas Holocaust, Genocide, And Anti-Semitism Advisory Commission - Office of the Texas... - April 30th, 2022
- University of Maryland's Anti-Semitism Task Force Chief ... - April 27th, 2022
- Rabbi Calls for Education and Leadership to Combat Hate Crimes in New Jersey - wbgo.org - April 18th, 2022
- Are Global Autocracies Here to Stay? - Northeastern University - April 18th, 2022
- The return of the anti-Dreyfusards is possible - The Hindu - April 18th, 2022
- Learning from the past to effectively fight anti-Semitism today - Al Jazeera English - March 16th, 2022
- Russia-Ukraine: Ugly truths in the time of war - Al Jazeera English - March 16th, 2022
- Ukraine's Only Woman Rabbi Among the Many Jews Fleeing War - Voice of America - VOA News - March 16th, 2022
- The law-flouting, truth-denying, science-deriding Trumpian Republican extremists are the real RINOs - Ohio Capital Journal - March 16th, 2022
- Colleyville hostage scene triggers calls for action ... - February 21st, 2022
- Colleyville Neighborhood Wakes Up to Flyers with Hate-filled Messages Tossed onto Lawns - NBC 5 Dallas-Fort Worth - February 21st, 2022
- Envisioning Justice: The Campus Voice This Week With Speakers and Workshops - University of Arkansas Newswire - February 21st, 2022
- Rosen, Texas Senators Lead and Pass Bipartisan Resolution Condemning Antisemitic Attack on Congregation Beth Israel - Jacky Rosen - February 19th, 2022
- 'It's part of a larger pattern': Texas synagogue hostage ... - January 20th, 2022
- Was Luther Anti-Semitic? | Christian History ... - January 20th, 2022
- Why So Many People Still Don't Understand Anti-Semitism - The Atlantic - January 20th, 2022
- Documenta Responds to Allegations of Anti-Semitic Connections to BDS Movement - ARTnews - January 20th, 2022
- Rep. Houlahan: My father survived the Holocaust by a miracle. It shouldnt take a miracle to be Jewish and alive. | Opinion - The Philadelphia Inquirer - January 20th, 2022
- Governor Abbott Appoints Five to the Texas Holocaust, Genocide and Anti-Semitism Advisory Commission - Office of the Texas Governor - January 9th, 2022
- Condemning anti-semitism, governor and Jewish leaders ... - January 4th, 2022
- Helena's Jewish community is raising funds to buy the state's oldest synagogue - MTPR - January 4th, 2022
- Jordanian TV rejects German stations anti-Semitism accusation - January 1st, 2022
- Poland is the land of anti-Semitism - January 1st, 2022
- Was Martin Luther Guilty of Anti-Semitism? - December 22nd, 2021
- Is Donald Trump an Anti-Semite? - The New Yorker - December 22nd, 2021
- 'It's trivializing the lives who so greatly suffered': Outrage continues after Holocaust imagery used in anti-mandate rally - CTV News Atlantic - December 22nd, 2021
- Trump Goes Full Anti-Semite, Unloads on American Jews in Wildly Bigoted Rant - Vanity Fair - December 18th, 2021
- Changing How You Spell 'Anti-Semitism' Won't Stop Anti-Semitism - The Atlantic - December 16th, 2021
- Dutch MP found guilty of creating a breeding ground for anti-Semitism - POLITICO Europe - December 16th, 2021
- Danvers High School Dealing With Another Investigation After Swastika Found in Bathroom - NBC10 Boston - December 16th, 2021
- Joint Communication to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions - Renewed... - November 30th, 2021
- An Archive Traces the History of Anti-Semitism Across Europe - Hyperallergic - November 23rd, 2021
- Azeem Rafiq's anti-Semitism does not undermine his claim that cricket is racist - it just proves he is part of the problem - Telegraph.co.uk - November 23rd, 2021
- Darlings of the freedom movement must denounce the anti-Semites in their wings - The Sydney Morning Herald - November 23rd, 2021
Comments