The ADL, Progressives and White Nationalists – City Watch

Posted By on June 17, 2022

GUEST COMMENTARY - We shall state our position at the outset: The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) does not speak for all Jews, it certainly does not speak for usthe daughters of Holocaust survivors and refugeesand increasingly, it does not speak for anyone who cares about justice and human rights.

Despite some laudable activism historically, the ADL is losing credibility as a civil rights organization and with good reason.

In remarks made to the ADL Virtual National Leadership Summit, ADLs CEO, Jonathan Greenblatt, engaged in a range of misconceptions and distortions that are beyond the scope of this short piece to address. Early in his presentation, he equated antizionism with antisemitism, a strategy now used to deflect criticism of Israels gross violations of Palestinian human rights, shielding Israel from any accountability. However, perhaps most disgraceful was the false moral equivalence he drew between antizionismwhich he regards as a form of extremismand white nationalism. He states: Antizionism as an ideology is rooted in rage. It is predicated on one concept: the negation of another people, a concept as alien to the modern discourse as white supremacy.

Hence, in Mr. Greenblatts view, those of usprogressive Jews and others who speak critically of Israeli policy, in defense of Palestinian human rights, and equality between Jews and Palestinians are antizionists and hence, antisemites and extremists, as evil in our intent and impact as white supremacists. If ever an argument existed that undermines the fight against antisemitism, it is this one with its false assertions, false equivalencies, and forced division within the Jewish community, and between Jews and other progressive groups.

Our personal histories and understanding of Judaism demand that we condemn the domination of one people over another, oppose Jewish supremacy in all its forms, especially its 2018 codification into Israeli law, and continue to struggle against the deliberate dispossession of the Palestinian people and the destruction of their society.

According to a 2021 poll by theJewish Electoral Institute, twenty percent of American Jews support legal equality between Jews and Palestinians in one state. Twenty-eight percent think Israel is practicing apartheid.As the recent editorial in theHarvard Crimsonshows, students increasingly understand the struggle for Palestinian liberation as the anti-apartheid struggle of their generation. Rather than engage with students and others in a campaign to end Israels abusive occupation and violation of human rightswhich is also in Israels long-term interestthe ADL would rather cast accusations of antisemitism at anyone who criticizes Zionism in an attempt to weaken widening popular support for the Palestinian cause.

In his speech, Mr. Greenblatt said the following: We will not stop speaking out against injustice whether against Orthodox Jews or the unaffiliated; Ashkenazi or Sephardi or Mizrahi; but also will not stop speaking out on behalf of all minorities, Mormons and Muslims, Bahai and Buddhists, AAPI and LGBTQ, and anyone who is targeted and victimized because of their identity.

Does this mean the ADL is prepared to speak out against the expulsion (read: forcible transfer) by Israel (with the sanction of Israels High Court of Justice) of at least 1,000 Palestinian Muslim residents of Masafer Yatta in the West Banks South Hebron Hills, who have been living there for generations, so that the Israeli army may use it as a firing zone? Up to twelve Palestinian villages will be destroyed and with them, a living Bedouin culture.

We believe that the best way to fight antisemitism is for Jews to join with other groups that are fighting racism and the rise of white supremacy. Especially now, when minority rights in particular are under siege on so many fronts, attacking justice organizations in the name of Jewish safety makes us all less safe. Throwing charges of antisemitism at anti-racist organizations weakens what should be a common struggle. Mr. Greenblatts statement seems to be solidifying progressive condemnation of the ADL. MajorMuslim,Jewishandsocial justiceorganizations are beginning to distance themselves and calling on other progressivesto reconsider the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) as a partner in social justice work.

Towards the end of his address to the ADL Summit, Mr. Greenblatt said, We will not be silent. We will not be deterred. We will not be passive in the face of prejudice.

Neither will we, Mr. Greenblatt.

(Elsa Auerbach, Professor Emerita, Department of English, University of Massachusetts Boston, Sara Roy, Senior Research Scholar, Center for Middle Eastern Studies, Harvard University and Eve Spangler, Associate Professor of Sociology, Boston College.)


The ADL, Progressives and White Nationalists - City Watch

Related Post


Comments are closed.