The rise of the anti-Zionist Jews and heretical messianism – JNS.org
Posted By admin on July 4, 2022
(July 4, 2022 / JNS) Anyone involved in the discourse on Israel and Zionism is aware of the fact that the words as a Jew always presage something distinctly monstrous. As a Jew is inevitably followed by ferocious denunciations of Israel, Zionism, the Israel lobby, the pro-Israel American Jewish majority and more or less everything elseexcept, of course, for hardline Palestinian nationalists, left-wing anti-Semites and Muslim pogromists.
It would be a mistake, however, to see anti-Zionist Jews as wholly alien to us. They are, in fact, part of our historical legacy and a phenomenon that has recurred throughout the history of the Diaspora: that of radical Jewish messianism.
Messianism is, of course, fundamental to Jewish belief, and is not by definition a bad thing. At its best, it can be what philosopher Eric Hoffer called a miraculous instrument for raising societies and nations from the deadan instrument of resurrection. Indeed, even secular Zionists are Messianists to one degree or another. In its radical form, however, Jewish messianism has remarkable destructive potential.
Radical messianism, generally speaking, has followed a consistent pattern over the centuries, and usually occurs in four stages. The formulation that follows is my own, but it stands on the formidable shoulders of the great scholar of the Kabbalah Gershom Scholem, particularly his book The Messianic Idea in Judaism.
Antinomianism: After declaring the arrival or imminent arrival of the messianic age, the Messianists assert that Jewish tradition and law have been superseded, transformed or completely vitiated, and often engage in behavior that directly challenges Jewish norms. The most famous example is the 17th century movement surrounding the false messiah Sabbatai Zevi.
Subscribe to The JNS Daily Syndicateby email and never missour top stories
Spiritualization: As part of this rejection of the law, Messianists spiritualize it. The rabbinic tradition is rejected as too much of this world to wield practical authority in the next, and is declared to be, at best, an expression of spiritual truths. Practice, in effect, becomes faith.
Heresy: Antinomianism and spiritualization inevitably lead to outright heresy. For example, the person of the messianic claimant is often declared Divine, contrary to Jewish prohibitions on idolatry. The ultimate result is usually a complete break from Judaism itself through conversion or even the founding of a separate religionthe most obvious example being Christianity.
Retaliation: Having split from Judaism, the now independent Messianists turn on it, denounce and demonize their former brethren and often incite or commit acts of considerable violence. The long history of Christian anti-Semitism is the best-known example, but cults like the 18th century Frankistswho aided in a blood libel case after abandoning Judaism en massehave also followed this pattern.
In the case of the anti-Zionist Jews, we are seeing this process repeat itself. First, the anti-Zionist Jews are proudly antinomian. They reject, in whole or in part, the moral consensus of the Jewish peoplewhich is, whether the anti-Zionist Jews like it or not, profoundly Zionist. Indeed, if it were not, the anti-Zionist Jews would have no reason to exist, given that they base their entire identity on violating that particular norm.
Spiritualization is most notable in phenomena like the use of the term Tikkun Olam by radical Jewish activists, but it is by no means confined to them. All anti-Zionist Jews employ Jewish terminology and concepts, but abstract them out so that they stand in for transcendental concepts like justice, rights, liberation or resistance. Traditional Jewish practice is, in effect, superseded by pure thought.
The question of heresy is more difficult, in that most anti-Zionist Jews are not religious in the formal sense. However, out of their antinomianism, they are creating something like a heretical faith. Being an anti-Zionist Jew is taking on a systemic form that defines personal and spiritual identity much as formal religion does. In effect, the anti-Zionist Jews undergo a conversion, though in a distinctly secular age, formal conversion is no longer necessary. Political submission is all that is required.
The issue of retaliation is so obvious as to go without saying. If anything defines the anti-Zionist Jews, it is their remarkably hateful and poisonous rhetoric. To them, the Jewish people are a force for pure evil. As a result, they accuse us of all possible sins: racism, genocide, settler-colonialism, political and financial corruption and undue influence, control of the media and the public discourse and so on.
Moreover, the intention behind their discursive venom is obvious: not just to defame the Jews, but to break them. This is, in fact, the ultimate essence of their ideology. They know that they cannot break Israel without also breaking the Jews, and this, they hope, will be their ultimate vengeance.
In quite another context, Scholem wrote: Whether or not Jewish history will be able to endure this entry into the concrete realm without perishing in the crisis of the Messianic claim which has virtually been conjured upthat is the question which out of his great and dangerous past the Jew of this age poses to his present and to his future.
In an age in which, to some degree, Jewish redemption and Jewish destiny have been realized in Zionism and the State of Israel, we must also ask this question. But if anything is certain, it is thateven though they are part of a long and often dark tradition that is nonetheless oursthe anti-Zionist Jews have already perished in the crisis of the messianic claim. It is incumbent upon the rest of us, who have made the choice to stand firm in our sense of redemption and destiny, to see that we endure it and them.
Benjamin Kerstein is a writer and editor living in Tel Aviv. Read more of his writing on Substack and his website. Follow him on Twitter @benj_kerstein.
The rest is here:
The rise of the anti-Zionist Jews and heretical messianism - JNS.org
- First known depictions of biblical heroines Jael and Deborah uncovered in Israel - Religion News Service - July 14th, 2022
- Israeli Communications Minister Says He Was Threatened Over 'Kosher Cellphone' Reform - The Epoch Times - July 14th, 2022
- Kol Ami Echoes Voice of the People - Jewish Exponent - July 14th, 2022
- Is Intermarriage Really the End of American Jews? - Algemeiner - July 14th, 2022
- Helping the Community Grow: Meet Lindsay Ottersen, the Volunteer Who Keeps on Giving Detroit Jewish News - The Jewish News - July 14th, 2022
- Is It Proper To Participate In Higher Risk Activities Like Whitewater Rafting Or Mountain Climbing? - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - July 14th, 2022
- The Rise of the ANTI-Zionist Jews and Heretical Messianism - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - July 14th, 2022
- Jewish community to join ACLU in lawsuit against Ohio's six-week abortion ban - News 5 Cleveland WEWS - July 12th, 2022
- The ordination of the first American woman rabbi a win for democracy - Online Athens - July 12th, 2022
- Jewish liberal groups urge Biden to stop eviction of Palestinians from their homes in villages near Hebron - Forward - July 12th, 2022
- The Family Purity 'Scandal' in Israel: An Open Letter to Guy Pines - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - July 12th, 2022
- The Beautiful Power of the Golden Rule - Patheos - July 12th, 2022
- Love and Absurdity - aish.com Ponder, Philosophy - Aish.com - July 12th, 2022
- A fight for the right to poverty and ignorance - The Times of Israel - July 12th, 2022
- Faith: A dream of heaven reminds to live life with love - Austin American-Statesman - July 10th, 2022
- Earliest depictions of biblical Deborah, Yael found at 5th-century Galilee synagogue - The Times of Israel - July 10th, 2022
- Napa Valley's OneHope is latest entry into kosher wine market J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - July 10th, 2022
- The God Squad: The righteous of all nations have a share in the World to Come - Walla Walla Union-Bulletin - July 10th, 2022
- Yom Kippur: History & Overview - Jewish Virtual Library - July 4th, 2022
- To Erez, my bar mitzvah teacher | Arie Hasit | The Blogs - The Times of Israel - July 4th, 2022
- Israeli foreign minister condemns Russia's Lavrov for 'unforgivable ... - June 30th, 2022
- Congregation Ahavas Israel is a Staple of West Michigan Conservative Judaism Detroit Jewish News - The Jewish News - June 30th, 2022
- Abortion access is a Jewish value: Reaction to Supreme Court overturning Roe v. Wade - Forward - June 30th, 2022
- Community invited to Shabbat Under the Stars at Temple Beth-El - Daily Herald - June 30th, 2022
- Shalom Rubanowitz: The Rabbi on the Beach - Jewish Journal - June 30th, 2022
- When Truth Is Sacrificed To Power - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - June 30th, 2022
- Voices of Faith: Celebrating LGBTQ Pride, conversion and Torah - Record-Courier - June 30th, 2022
- Statement from the JCRC on the overturn of Roe v. Wade - Heritage Florida Jewish News - June 30th, 2022
- A Jewish prescription for July 4th skepticism | The Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle - thejewishchronicle.net - June 30th, 2022
- Power in the Blood: True Religion and Transformation in C.S. Lewis' Till We Have Faces - tor.com - June 30th, 2022
- The Universalistic Vision of Judaism - Jewish Journal - June 26th, 2022
- New class offered by Chabad Lubavitch of Park City will go 'Beyond' what is right - The Park Record - June 26th, 2022
- America's religious communities are divided over the issue of abortion: 5 essential reads - The Conversation - June 26th, 2022
- A Reform Jewish perspective on abortion - KELOLAND.com - June 26th, 2022
- The Sunday View: Can Jews ever learn to share the Western Wall? - Jewish News - June 26th, 2022
- The Myth That Happened | The Myth That Happened - Patheos - June 26th, 2022
- Israeli Government to Dissolve: New Elections Expected in Fall - The National Interest Online - June 26th, 2022
- Whatever Happened to the 'Pro-Jewish' Left? | AEI - American Enterprise Institute - June 26th, 2022
- We must grow from everything we see or hear: Rabbi Levi Greenberg - El Paso Times - June 6th, 2022
- Opinion: Race Realism in the Holy Land - Prescott eNews - June 6th, 2022
- Hillel of Buffalo celebrates 75 years of enriching students' lives - UB Now: News and views for UB faculty and staff - University at Buffalo - June 6th, 2022
- Pauline Interpretation: A Rising Tide Of Interpretations - Patheos - June 6th, 2022
- Letters To The Editor June 3, 2022 - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - June 6th, 2022
- America needs its own Jubilee: We are a nation in profound crisis - Salon - June 6th, 2022
- Shavuot: A Jewish holiday of renewing commitment to God - The Conversation Indonesia - June 4th, 2022
- The CJN goes one-on-one with: Leah Oppenheimer - Cleveland Jewish News - June 4th, 2022
- Before 'Palestine': Exploring the Unbroken Jewish Connection to Temple Mount - Honestreporting.com - June 4th, 2022
- Faith: As you prepare for Pentecost Sunday, remember the early disciples - Craig Press - June 2nd, 2022
- Bradley Cooper Accused of 'Ethnic Cosplay' Over Leonard Bernstein Role - Newsweek - June 2nd, 2022
- Lawmakers hear Ohio's version of Florida's 'Don't Say Gay' bill - News 5 Cleveland WEWS - June 2nd, 2022
- This private, on-demand hot rabbi may soon be the star of her own reality TV show - The Times of Israel - June 2nd, 2022
- Questions in Judaism with Rabbi Benzion Shemtov | Article | The United States Army - United States Army - May 31st, 2022
- Rabbi Aryeh Markman: Connecting Jews to their Judaism - Jewish Journal - May 31st, 2022
- The Surge of Converts to Judaism in Ancient Rome - aish.com - Aish - May 31st, 2022
- Israel: Right-wing Opposition Members Vow To Defeat All Coalition Bills - i24NEWS - May 31st, 2022
- The ordination of the first female rabbi 50 years ago has brought many changes and some challenges - The Conversation - May 31st, 2022
- What happens when a Muslim becomes an apostate and renounces Islam? This is what the Islamic scriptures say - OpIndia - May 31st, 2022
- Coffee with Warren: We are healers of a broken world - Cochrane Today - May 31st, 2022
- Fairmount Temple initiatives aim to connect young adults, change tunes - Cleveland Jewish News - May 31st, 2022
- How will Justice Jackson Treat Israel and Judaism? - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - April 18th, 2022
- For questions about identity, I've written my own haggadah J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - April 18th, 2022
- Reform movement sends mixed messages in response to harassment report - Forward - April 18th, 2022
- What is Pesach? A guide to the Jewish Passover holiday - EWN - April 18th, 2022
- For Jews fleeing Ukraine, Passover takes on new meaning - The Associated Press - en Espaol - April 18th, 2022
- Can an all-Mormon cast pull off 'Fiddler on the Roof'? J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - April 18th, 2022
- No Invitation to a Passover Seder? Youre Not Alone. - The New York Times - April 18th, 2022
- Douglas Todd: Can Easter, Passover and Ramadan ease the pain of war? - Vancouver Sun - April 18th, 2022
- The rebbes simple but genius recipe - The Jewish Standard - April 18th, 2022
- Hadas Fruchter Is a New Kind of Orthodox Jewish Leader - The Wall Street Journal - April 11th, 2022
- From Stanford to the rabbinate: Phil Pizzo moving on - The Stanford Daily - April 11th, 2022
- Seeing life through the optimistic lenses of the Rebbe | Column - Tampa Bay Times - April 11th, 2022
- My nonconversion story. Part 5: He's not the Messiah - Freethought Blogs - April 11th, 2022
- Jewish Weeb Excited to Learn You Read the Torah Right to Left Just Like Manga - Hard Drive - April 11th, 2022
- The End of the Road in Cincinnati? - Tablet Magazine - April 11th, 2022
- Idit Silman, what are you afraid of? | Zev Farber | The Blogs - The Times of Israel - April 11th, 2022
- Tzara'at And The Power Of Shame - The Jewish Press - JewishPress.com - April 11th, 2022
- Hebrew Congregation and Wider USVI Community Reach Out to Ukraine - St, Thomas Source - April 11th, 2022
- Mother and daughter share a bond through LIFE & LEGACY - Jewish Community Voice - April 11th, 2022
- Cincinnati's Hebrew Union College could stop ordaining rabbis, blurring the future of the institution - WVXU - March 29th, 2022
- Indecent: The Intersection of Queerness and Judaism on Stage - The Trail - The Puget Sound Trail - March 29th, 2022
Comments