The Jewish and intellectual origins of this famously non-Jewish Jew – JNS.org
Posted By admin on August 29, 2022
(August 25, 2022 / Jewish Journal) Editors note: Excerpted from the new three-volume set, Theodor Herzl: Zionist Writings, the inaugural publication of The Library of the Jewish People edited by Gil Troy, to be published this August marking the 125th anniversary of the First Zionist Congress. This is the second article in a series. The first in the series is available here.
Theodor Herzl was born on May 2, 1860, in Pest, Hungary, across the River Danube from Buda. The second child and only son of a successful businessman, Jakob, he was raised to fit in to the elegant, sophisticated society his family and a fraction of his people had fought so hard to enter. But it is too easy to caricature his upbringing as fully emancipated and assimilated.
His paternal grandfather, Simon Loeb Herzl, came from Semlin, todays Zemun, now incorporated into Belgrade. There, Simon befriended Rabbi Judah ben Solomon Chai Alkalai. This prominent Sephardic leader was an early Zionist, scarred by the crude anti-Semitism of the Damascus Blood Libel of 1840, inspired by the old-new Greek War of Independence in the 1820sand energized by the spiritual and agricultural possibilities of returning the Jews to their natural habitat, their homeland in the Land of Israel. It is plausible that the grandfather conveyed some of those ideas, some of that excitement, to his grandson.
Still, the move from Semlin to Budapest, from poverty to wealth, from intense Jewish living in the ghetto to emancipated European ways in the city, placed the Herzl family at the intersection of many of his eras defining currents.
The 1800s were years of changeand of isms. Creative ideas erupted amid the disruptions of industrialization, urbanization and capitalism. Three defining ideologies were rationalism, liberalism and nationalismwith each one shaping the next. The Age of Reason, the Enlightenmentscience itselfrose thanks to rationalism. Life was no longer organized around believing in God and serving your king, but following logic, facts, objective truth. The logic of reason flowed naturally to liberalism, an expansive political ideology rooted in recognizing every individuals inherent rights. Finally, as polities became less God-and-king-centered, nationalism filled in the God-sized hole in many peoples hearts. Individuals bonded based on their common heritage, language, ethnicity, or regional prideand needs.
Subscribe to The JNS Daily Syndicateby email and never missour top stories
Ideas are not static. In an ideological age rippling with such dramatic changes, the different isms kept colliding and fusing, like atoms becoming molecular compounds. Some combinations proved more stableand constructivethan others.
Liberalism combined with nationalism created Americanism, the democratic model wherein individual rights flourished in a collective context yielding the liberal-democratic nation-state. An offshoot of liberalism emphasizing equality more than rights fused with rationalism and created Marxism, although Karl Marx admitted his theories could only be enacted with irrational terror. Marxism with that violent streak, drained of liberalism, became communism, while a hyper-nationalism, rooted in blood-and-soil loyalty, and the kind of Marxist rationalism and totalitarianism also drained of any liberalism, created Nazism.
A similar impressionistic summary of the Jewish experience would track how the nineteenth centurys ideological clashes shaped the major movements and institutions still defining Judaism, from the Reform movement to Zionism, from the modern synagogue to the State of Israel. Judaism and rationalism set off the explosion of scholarshipthe Wissenschaftwhile Judaism mixed with liberalism triggered the Reform and Conservative movements theological inventiveness. In response, ultra-Orthodoxy emerged, hostile to changeessentially subtracting liberalism from Judaism. Modern Orthodoxy synthesized, accepting some liberalism in Judaism and eventually Jewish nationalism without too much rationalism. And, thanks to Herzl and others, the compound of Judaism and liberalism and nationalism yielded Zionism.
The actual historical process was much messier. It began with the great double-edged sword of European Emancipation. First in the West, then in the East, some Europeans welcomed Jews with equal rights and extraordinary opportunities, liberating many to move to the citiesand for a few to succeed on legendary scales. Moses Mendelssohn (17291786), the Herzl of the HaskalaEnlightenmentwas a Jew who as a philosopher dazzled Berlin. But, unlike Herzl, Mendelssohn was so fluent in Judaism and Hebrew that in 1783 he started translating much of the Bible into High German, adding commentary sporadically too. Mendelssohn epitomized the Haskala ideal of being a full, functioning, literate Jew in the house and a full, functioning, popular man on the street. And, unlike Herzl, Mendelssohn was ugly, infamously so, a walking ghetto stereotype with his crooked back and hooked nose.
Mendelssohn was accepted. Jews, however, realized that Europes embrace often came at a cost: Jews had to be willing to give up their Jewishness, to fit in so much that many lost their way. Mendelssohn had six children who survived into adulthoodonly two remained Jewish. Most disturbing, the Jewish rush into modern European society triggered a backlash, an updated, racist Jew-hatred that became increasingly potent as nationalist demagogues blamed the eras problems on Europes traditional scapegoat, the Jews.
Rather than being welcomed smoothly into European life, most Jews felt mugged by modernity. The complex realities never matched the euphoric hopes of themaskilim, the Enlightened Reformers, that their people would awake from their ghetto-imposed long slumber, as the Russian-JewishmaskilY. L. Gordon would write in Hebrew in 1866.
Developing Mendelssohns vision as the pioneering Jewish modernizer, Gordon celebrated the essential bargain Jews like Theodor and his parents accepted. The deal was: Be a man when you wander outside and a Jew when at home. In Herzls householdlike so many other bourgeois Jewish homesthe success in looking normal on the streets came at a high Jewish cost, even at home.
For Herzl and his family, Middle European Jews caught in the middle, every educational choice became a marker. Were you looking backward to your traditional past or forward to your enlightened future? Initially, Herzls parents, Jakob and Jeannette ne Diamant, tried doing both. When their son was eight days old, they initiated their son Theodor into the great identity juggle by giving him a Hebrew nameBinyamin Zeev.
Ultimately, then, Binyamin Zeev Herzl was far more rooted in Judaismand the Jewish struggle of the nineteenth century, than most legends acknowledge.
Professor Gil Troy is the author of The Zionist Ideas and the editor of the three-volume set Theodor Herzl: Zionist Writings, the inaugural publication of the Library of the Jewish People, to be published this August marking the 125th anniversary of the First Zionist Congress.
This article was originally published byThe Jewish Journal.
Read more:
The Jewish and intellectual origins of this famously non-Jewish Jew - JNS.org
- Hebrew alphabet | writing system | Britannica - February 4th, 2023
- How to Learn Hebrew | My Jewish Learning - January 23rd, 2023
- Yahweh | YHWH, Adonai, Elohim, Meaning, & Facts | Britannica - January 23rd, 2023
- Washington Hebrew Congregation to Pay Nearly $1M in Lawsuit Over Child Care Safety Laws - NBC4 Washington - December 31st, 2022
- Have you paid attention to the Hebrew word President Nelson keeps teaching about? - LDS Living - October 1st, 2022
- Debates about migration have never been simple just look at the Hebrew Bible - Religion News Service - October 1st, 2022
- It's Jewish New Year: but what is Rosh Hashanah? - Euronews - October 1st, 2022
- Islam And Judaism Can Bring Peace To The Middle East OpEd - Eurasia Review - October 1st, 2022
- Opinion: The antisemitism was real in 1950s Milwaukee I was there and I remember - The Wisconsin Jewish Chronicle - October 1st, 2022
- Assemblies of God (USA) Official Web Site | Jesus Made Me Kosher Conversations - AG News - October 1st, 2022
- When is Yom Kippur 2022? What is the Jewish holiday? What to know - USA TODAY - October 1st, 2022
- Chabad of Northeast Portland celebrates High Holy Days and a new home - Here is Oregon - October 1st, 2022
- You are never alone - Bonner County Daily Bee - October 1st, 2022
- The Power of With | Hebrew College Wendy Linden - Patheos - October 1st, 2022
- Modern Hebrew - Wikipedia - September 25th, 2022
- Rosh Hashanah 2022: When is it, traditions, greetings and how to wish someone happy new year in Hebrew - Manchester Evening News - September 25th, 2022
- Joseph Smith and Hebrew: How he learned it - Deseret News - September 25th, 2022
- Venices Hebrew School is growing year by year | Religion - YourSun.com - September 25th, 2022
- Jewish communities in Minnesota and around the world set to welcome new year 5783 - CBS News - September 25th, 2022
- This vintage video of a Jewish boys choir has gone viral on TikTok and its a joy to watch - Forward - September 25th, 2022
- Church-Community Connection: We need to talk about Bruno - Peoria Times - September 25th, 2022
- Israels Jewish population passes 7 million on eve of Rosh Hashanah - The Times of Israel - September 25th, 2022
- The Fruit Traditions Behind Rosh Hashanah - Mashed - September 25th, 2022
- Clearmind Applies for Patent to Treat Obesity and Metabolic Syndrome - GlobeNewswire - September 25th, 2022
- Taking Hold of the Shofar: Dreams of Past & Future - Patheos - September 25th, 2022
- Palestinian Organizations, Islamist Figures, And Hamas Warn Of 'Unprecedented Incursion' By Jews Into Al-Aqsa Mosque During Upcoming Holidays, Urge... - September 25th, 2022
- Debates about migration have never been simple just look at the Hebrew Bible - Times Union - September 16th, 2022
- Joan & Alan Bernikow JCC will partner with Hebrew Public Charter School of S.I. to provide after-school progr - SILive.com - September 16th, 2022
- BUDDHIST REFLECTIONS ON THE HEBREW PSALMS: The McLeod Ganj Psalter RSV, Week 4 - Patheos - September 16th, 2022
- Chabad couple holds UAEs largest-ever Jewish wedding on anniversary of peace deal with Israel - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - September 16th, 2022
- Then the Lord God formed man from the dust of the ground. Granite Falls Advocate Tribune - Granite Falls Advocate Tribune - September 16th, 2022
- The essence of it - The Jewish Standard - September 16th, 2022
- Not teaching math and science - another double standard for the ultra-Orthodox in Israel - All Israel News - September 16th, 2022
- Three Cultures Foundation offers Modern Hebrew classes for the academic year 2022/2023 - Atalayar - September 6th, 2022
- Buddhist Reflections on the Hebrew Psalms: The McLeod Ganj Psalter RSV, Week 2 - Patheos - September 6th, 2022
- What Other Secrets Are Hidden in the Qumran Caves? - Israel Today - September 6th, 2022
- God over war: Thousands of ultra-Orthodox Jews are making a pilgrimage to Ukraine - EL PAS USA - September 6th, 2022
- Gov. Wolf Announces $4.2 Million in Federal Funding to Protect Diverse Communities Targeted by Hate Crimes - pa.gov - September 6th, 2022
- Hackers leak information of 30,000 Israeli students and teachers - Ynetnews - September 6th, 2022
- Painstakingly crafted, Torah scroll arrives on Bainbridge Island to celebration - Kitsap Sun - September 6th, 2022
- Jewish Israelis are heading to Arabic class and learning a bit more about Palestinians - Forward - September 6th, 2022
- 30 Boy Names That Start With A, From Aaron To Azad - Romper - September 6th, 2022
- Tim Throckmorton: Back to school is time to reflect on the parent's job - The Tribune | The Tribune - Ironton Tribune - September 6th, 2022
- Israeli President Herzog's speech at the 50th anniversary memorial of the Munich Olympics massacre - JNS.org - September 6th, 2022
- Animal Welfare in the Bible - CounterPunch.org - CounterPunch - September 6th, 2022
- All the Hebrew Curses You Need to Know - Kveller.com - August 29th, 2022
- Kickass Women of the Hebrew Bible - Criminal Element - August 29th, 2022
- Who really is God? - The State Journal-Register - August 29th, 2022
- FROM THE ARCHIVE: Talking student debt, 50 years ago this week J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - August 29th, 2022
- Berlin police are investigating whether charges can be filed against Abbas for Israel Holocausts comment - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - August 29th, 2022
- The rashtrapatni row should make us rethink the everyday bias against women in our languages - Scroll.in - August 29th, 2022
- Hebrew media: Israel soldiers will not be allowed to fly over Saudi Arabia, Oman - Middle East Monitor - August 18th, 2022
- 3 poetic tools found in the Bible that might help you better understand your 'Come, Follow Me' reading - LDS Living - August 18th, 2022
- Israeli President unveiled Hebrew translation of book Indians at Herods Gate on 76th Independence Day - ThePrint - August 18th, 2022
- New Year: New Mission, Vision, and Value Statements at THA | AZ Jewish Post - Jewish Post - August 18th, 2022
- FROM THE ARCHIVES: Over a century of caring for Jewish seniors J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - August 18th, 2022
- But Dust and Ashes We Are | Hebrew College Wendy Linden - Patheos - August 18th, 2022
- The relics St. Helena brought to Rome from the Holy Land - The Catholic Telegraph - August 18th, 2022
- Your Daily Phil: The highest per-capita charity bike ride in the world + A pluralistic teen Havruta - eJewish Philanthropy - August 18th, 2022
- Israeli man drowns in Sinai during family vacation with his wife and 2 kids - The Times of Israel - August 18th, 2022
- Archaeologists at the Sea of Galilee Say They May Have Found the Real-Life Birthplace of St. Peter, First Pope of the Christian Church - artnet News - August 18th, 2022
- Merger streamlines two East Bay after-school programs J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - August 18th, 2022
- We spoke to Miriam, the Hebrew tutor Nathan Fielder hired for his fake family on HBOs The Rehearsal - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - August 13th, 2022
- A-Z List of 200 Short Girl Names That Are All Sugar and Spice - Parade Magazine - August 13th, 2022
- 13: The Musical Is the Perfect Jewish Family Night Movie - Kveller.com - August 13th, 2022
- Seeds of Consolation: Open-Eyed Torah for a Friend - Patheos - August 13th, 2022
- When It Comes to Lightning, Dont Pass the Salt - The New York Times - August 13th, 2022
- Stephen Currys Mother, Who Was Transformed After Israel Visit, Inspired Her Son to Get Biblical Tattoo That Showcases His Deep Christian Beliefs -... - August 13th, 2022
- Saudi social-media influencer: 'Hope our nation will sign a peace treaty with Israel' - JNS.org - August 13th, 2022
- The origin story of the carried interest tax break (or carried interest tax loop : Planet Money - NPR - August 13th, 2022
- A Word of Torah: The Fewest of All People Detroit Jewish News - The Jewish News - August 13th, 2022
- Yaron Peleg Named Director of the Middlebury School of Hebrew - Middlebury College News and Events - August 10th, 2022
- A-Z List Of 200 Short Boy Names That Are Simple And Sweet - Parade Magazine - August 10th, 2022
- Outstanding speakers to inspire our teachers - Australian Jewish News - August 10th, 2022
- How this Jewish basketball nerd became the voice of the Warriors J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - August 10th, 2022
- Human rights organizations to Israeli Defense Minister, Attorney General, and COGAT: Cease attacks on Gaza's civilian population immediately and open... - August 10th, 2022
- Ethereum (ETH-USD) Traders Prepared to "Sell the News" in September - InvestorPlace - August 10th, 2022
- The challenge: To feed 10 billion people with healthy food by the year 2050 - CTech - August 10th, 2022
- New details about what is going on with the former American Hebrew Academy campus - WFMYNews2.com - July 21st, 2022
- Walk Through Beautiful Stained Glass Windows At This Unique Museum In Mississippi - Only In Your State - July 21st, 2022
Comments