How American Jews (stayed) white | David E. Bernstein | The Blogs – The Times of Israel
Posted By admin on July 14, 2022
Among progressives, there is a bitter debate over whether American Jews whose ancestors immigrated to the US from Europe should be deemed white (and thus beneficiaries of white privilege), or non-white, given their vulnerability to antisemitism, including violence from white nationalists who deem them to be non-white.
I believe that this debate misses the mark; it tries to fit antisemitism, which has myriad origins, most of which have nothing to do with whiteness such as Jews being Christ-killers) into the American black-white paradigm. This reaches an absurd apex when people assert that the Nazis killed Jews because they thought Jews werent white, as if the Nazis didnt have their own bizarre racial hierarchy one that didnt match that of the Jim Crow South.
That said, the US has its own official racial classifications, dictated by the federal Office of Management and Budget in 1978. These classifications dictate the boxes one checks for race on college admissions forms, mortgage applications, the Census, job applications, and more. Where do Jews fit in?
The short answer, as discussed in my new book, Classified: The Untold Story of Racial Classification in America, is that the US government has always deemed Jews whose ancestors came from Europe origin to be white. There was some controversy in the early twentieth century about the racial status of immigrants from the Middle East and North Africa, but the government ultimately determined MENA people, including Jews, are white. The 1978 rules, still in effect, dictate that all people of European and MENA origin are classified as generically white.
Things could have turned out differently. Around 1910, the US immigration bureaucracy considered classifying Jews separately from other European immigrants; for demographic purposes, these officials wanted to be able to distinguish, say, ethnic Poles from Jews from Poland. After protests from Jewish organizations, officials instead settled for asking immigrants their mother tongue; this allowed Yiddish-speaking Jews to be tabulated separately, without putting them in a separate racial classification.
In the late 1950s, the US government began requiring federal contractors to report on their minority employees, including Spanish-Americans, Orientals, Indians, Jews, and Puerto Ricans, to help identify illegal discriminatory hiring patterns. Within a few years, some civil rights organizations objected that including Jews in the data diverted resources better-used to combat discrimination against black Americans, who suffered more economically from discrimination than Jews did. Jewish organizations, never comfortable with the government keeping official tabs on Jews, agreed that Jews should be dropped from the forms.
In the 1970s, a few prominent activists argued that Jews should receive more explicit attention from the civil rights bureaucracy. Occasionally, Jewish leaders even expressed support for including Jews in affirmative action programs, but mainstream Jewish organizations never took up the cause.
American Jews remain extremely sensitive to any hint that they should be classified by the government separately from other Americans. The New York Times incorrectly reported in 2019 that the Trump administration was about to issue an executive order interpreting Judaism as a race or nationality. Much of the American Jewish world was briefly up in arms, until it became clear that the Times report was wrong. Jews today are classified as non-Hispanic whites unless they are also members of one of the official minority categories, such as Asian American or African American.
The only partial exception to Jews being generically part of other racial groups is Hasidim. In the 1970s, their representatives lobbied vigorously to be included in federal affirmative action plans for minority-owned small businesses. Lobbyists for the Hasidim pointed out that unlike other American Jews, Hasidim wear distinctive attire that makes them targets for discrimination. Moreover, Hasidim have high rates of poverty and receive little secular education, as their schools emphasize study of Jewish religious texts. The strict tenets of their faith, such as avoiding contact with the opposite sex, make it difficult for them to enter the secular business world. Finally, many Hasidim use Yiddish as their everyday language and speak English only as a second language.
As discussed in Classified, Hasidim achieved such recognition from the federal Commerce Department and the Department of Housing and Urban Development, and retain that minority status today, giving them an advantage in government contracting. The big prize, though, was the Small Business Administration, and attempts to gain minority status with the SBA failed.
During the Carter administration, SBA General Counsel Ed Norton tentatively concluded that Hasidim met the programs requirements. The SBA invited public comments on the Hasidims application. The agency received strongly negative feedback, primarily from African Americans. Congressman Parren Mitchell, the leading congressional advocate for the Section 8(a) program, sent a letter to numerous African American entrepreneurs and politicians warning that inclusion of Hasidic Jews would diluteexisting resources earmarked forother minorities.
Norton, meanwhile, had a change of heart. He reasoned that the Hasidim were primarily disadvantaged because of their religious traditions, and that it would be unconstitutional to provide special benefits to a group defined by religion because of their religion. The SBA therefore denied the Hasidims petition, and the Hasidim apparently did not appeal.
In short, legally speaking, the vast majority of American Jews have always been deemed white by the government, and remain classified as such today.
That said, a change may be in the offing. The Biden administration is considering amending Americas racial classification scheme to include a classification for Middle East and North African. This classification would include Jews who immigrated from that region, Israelis, and some fraction of Ashkenazi Jews who consider themselves more Middle Eastern by religion, culture, and genetics than European.
David E. Bernstein is a professor at the Antonin Scalia Law School, George Mason University, where he teaches constitutional law and evidence. He is married to an Israeli and travels to Israel regularly.
See more here:
How American Jews (stayed) white | David E. Bernstein | The Blogs - The Times of Israel
- Hasidic Judaism | Encyclopedia.com - November 26th, 2023
- Pro-Palestine protesters plan to 'flood' Brooklyn -- near Hasidic Jewish site: 'The louder we will be' - New York Post - October 29th, 2023
- Hasidism: An Overview | Encyclopedia.com - October 18th, 2023
- Plans to form Viznitz Hasidic village in Sullivan County halted by ... - Times Herald-Record - October 18th, 2023
- Rough Diamonds Gets the Details of Hasidic Life Right, but Fails to ... - Mosaic - October 18th, 2023
- I left the Hasidic world three years ago. This time of year, I dearly miss it - Forward - October 8th, 2023
- Democrat congressional candidate and former member walks back calling Kevin McCarthy's meeting with Hasidic le - Daily Mail - October 6th, 2023
- I'm A Queer Woman Who Left My Marriage In The Hasidic Community. Theres One Thing People Don't Understand. - HuffPost UK - September 30th, 2023
- Hasidic Judaism - Wikiwand - September 24th, 2023
- Hasidic | definition in the Cambridge English Dictionary - September 22nd, 2023
- Hasidic rapper Moshe Reuven is making history - Unpacked - Jewish Unpacked - September 22nd, 2023
- Yeshivas refusal to enroll a 10-year-old pits a Hasidic father against a non-Hasidic mother - Forward - September 22nd, 2023
- List of Hasidic dynasties and groups - Wikipedia - September 12th, 2023
- Hasidic rockers Why Evolution Is True - Why Evolution Is True - September 12th, 2023
- I led an antisemitism training for workers in a labor dispute with their Hasidic bosses. Heres what I learned - Forward - September 12th, 2023
- Hasidim | Encyclopedia.com - September 5th, 2023
- What Hasidic Boys Learn, An Enlightening Conversation with Moshe ... - CrownHeights.info - September 5th, 2023
- New Hasidic song slams yeshivas that reject students who dont fit in - Forward - September 5th, 2023
- Rap group Three 6 Mafia arrives on TikTok with videos of Hasidic ... - The Jewish News of Northern California - August 22nd, 2023
- Hasid - Wikipedia - August 16th, 2023
- Viznitz Hasidic group petitions for village in Thompson, Fallsburg - Times Herald-Record - August 6th, 2023
- Cardi B Stirs Controversy Tweeting Photo of Hasidic Jews After ... - Algemeiner - August 6th, 2023
- Hasidic life in Uman: A journey across Ukraine to the Tomb of Rabbi ... - Milwaukee Independent - August 6th, 2023
- THE HASIDIC KOPPLE Comes to the Cameri Theatre This Month - Broadway World - July 9th, 2023
- Hundreds protest Hasidic pilgrimages to Haifa monastery - The Times of Israel - June 25th, 2023
- The Belzer Rebbe Has Created A Program To Support Ex-Hasidic Jews - Jew in the City - June 10th, 2023
- The Hasidic Community's Reckoning Over COVID-19 - The Atlantic - May 22nd, 2023
- How the haredi Orthodox are changing Israel - May 22nd, 2023
- When One Parent Leaves a Hasidic Community, What Happens to the Kids? - May 22nd, 2023
- Hasidic Judaism - May 9th, 2023
- Hasidic Movement: A History - May 9th, 2023
- Hasidic philosophy - May 9th, 2023
- Suspect arrested in assaults on Hasidic Jewish men in Outremont - Montreal Gazette - April 22nd, 2023
- Hasidic Judaism Rules & Customs | What Does Hasidic Mean? | Study.com - March 28th, 2023
- How Public Money Goes to Support a Hasidic Villages Private Schools ... - February 25th, 2023
- How the Hasidic Jewish Community Became a Political Force in New York - February 25th, 2023
- Ashkenazi Hasidim - Wikipedia - February 17th, 2023
- What Is Chabad? | My Jewish Learning - February 11th, 2023
- Payot - Wikipedia - February 4th, 2023
- Anti-Hasidic bias claimed in suit over 2,600-home Lost Lake project - January 2nd, 2023
- Why Do Hasidic Jews Dress So Differently? - Seeker - December 27th, 2022
- Hasidic School Is Breaking State Education Law, N.Y. Official Rules - December 11th, 2022
- Zeldin Sees a Path to Becoming Governor. It Runs Through Brooklyn. - December 11th, 2022
- Jeff Wilbusch left his Hasidic community at 13. Now he's exploring his ... - December 11th, 2022
- Hasidic School to Pay $8 Million After Admitting to Widespread Fraud - December 7th, 2022
- Developer claims anti-Hasidic bias in suit over thwarted housing plans - December 7th, 2022
- In Hasidic Enclaves, Failing Yeshivas Flush With Public Money - The New ... - December 7th, 2022
- New York Hasidic School Admits to Benefit Fraud Conspiracy, Agrees to ... - November 6th, 2022
- Mother of 10 says her kids didn't learn basic reading, math, science at ... - November 6th, 2022
- Upsherin - Wikipedia - November 6th, 2022
- Why The New York Times translated its Hasidic yeshiva investigation ... - October 17th, 2022
- Im not Hasidic, but an afternoon in Williamsburg deepened my appreciation of Sukkot - Forward - October 17th, 2022
- A food truck at Duke University offers a truce to rising tensions on Mideast politics - Religion News Service - October 17th, 2022
- A More Perfect Mediocracy by Liel Leibovitz | Articles - First Things - October 17th, 2022
- Stop saying there's a polio emergency | News, Sports, Jobs - Alpena News - October 6th, 2022
- Where do Hochul and Zeldin stand on education? - Chalkbeat New York - October 6th, 2022
- How concierge IV therapy went from Instagram trend to pre-Yom Kippur hydration hack - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - October 6th, 2022
- War-torn Ukraine prepares for mass arrival of Hasidic Jews to Uman - September 27th, 2022
- Thousands of Hasidic Jews defy travel warnings by making New Year ... - September 27th, 2022
- Wanted for slapping Hasidic man in unprovoked attack - New York Daily News - September 27th, 2022
- The Civic Duties of Hasidic Schools | Cole S. Aronson - First Things - September 23rd, 2022
- A formerly Hasidic mom who sued her sons yeshiva will head nonprofit advocating for secular education - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic Agency - September 23rd, 2022
- Letters to the editor | | tulsaworld.com - Tulsa World - September 23rd, 2022
- No Soul Is Safe in Teaser Trailer for the Jewish Folklore Horror Film THE OFFERING GeekTyrant - GeekTyrant - September 23rd, 2022
- I read a secret transcript of Hasidic sex advice. Ive read worse. - Forward - August 12th, 2022
- South Blooming Grove finishes review of 600-home Clovewood project - Times Herald-Record - August 12th, 2022
- Jewish perspectives on abortion diverse, often oversimplified | News, Sports, Jobs - Williamsport Sun-Gazette - August 12th, 2022
- Groundbreaking album breathes new life into nearly abandoned Jewish musical art - Forward - August 12th, 2022
- Synagogue plan rejected in Haverstraw; RLUIPA litigation threat looms - The Journal News - August 12th, 2022
- Mormons are being oppressed and mocked on TV. We're not alone. - Religion News Service - August 8th, 2022
- Lufthansa will create a position to fight antisemitism after kicking more than 100 Hasidic passengers off a flight - JTA News - Jewish Telegraphic... - July 31st, 2022
- What sort of Yiddish did Jews in Hungary speak? - Forward - July 31st, 2022
- What the Polio Case in New York Tells Us About the End of Polio - Kaiser Health News - July 31st, 2022
- Rockland County police searching for white Ford F-150 truck in connection to recent attacks on Hasidic Jews - CBS New York - July 19th, 2022
- De Blasio quits crowded race for Congress in heavily Jewish district - Forward - July 19th, 2022
- Jewish group sues Long Island beach town over turning its worship land into a lifeguard center - Washington Times - July 19th, 2022
- Progressives Have Abandoned Haredi Children - Jewish Currents - July 16th, 2022
- At this Yiddish music festival, tradition is everything and nothing J. - The Jewish News of Northern California - July 16th, 2022
- At a Yiddish music festival in bucolic Massachusetts, tradition is everything and nothing - Forward - July 14th, 2022
- This couldnt happen anywhere: How coverage of the shooting failed Highland Park - Forward - July 10th, 2022
Comments